15 Best Extra Añejo Tequilas: Full Reviews (2023 Updated)

Last Updated on August 22, 2023 by Lydia Martin

When an añejo is aged longer, it becomes a more exceptional spirit. It has a strong scent that introduces quality and a palate that tells a story of how it was made. It also offers a finish that lingers even after it has been swallowed. 

Here are the best Extra Añejo tequilas you can try for your afternoon relaxation sessions.

Top 15 Extra Añejo Tequilas For Your Home Bar

1. Avion Reserva 44

Avion Reserva 44 on desk

Avion Reserva 44 is a product of Pernod Ricard USA. These bottles are slow-roasted for 72 hours before being processed in their proprietary ultra-slow filtration system. This extra-añejo tequila is also known for its balanced taste and smooth finish. This aged tequila uses single-sourced agaves from Jesus Maria, Mexico. 

Avion Reserva 44 is best sipped neat or on the rocks because of its complex flavors. You will taste sweet notes of honey, caramel, and vanilla with a full taste of oak and agave that intensifies in the mouth.

2. Casa Noble Single Barrel 

Casa Noble Single Barrel on desk

Casa Noble Single Barrel is a product of Maestro Tequilero Jose “Pepe” Hermosillo. His methods include using their proprietary corkscrew milling in extracting the juice from roasted agave and utilizing native airborne yeast to ferment the juice. 

Casa Noble is triple-distilled. Unlike other brands, Casa Noble uses new, lightly toasted French barrels for the aging process. These bottles are certified organic by the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) and California Certified Organic Farmers (CCOF). 

3. Cincoro Extra Anejo

Cincoro Extra Anejo on desk

Cincoro Extra Añejo Tequila is one of the celebrity-endorsed tequilas. This brand is co-owned by basketball legend Michael Jordan and other sports personalities like Jeanie Buss, Wes Edens, and Wyc Grousbeck. 

The last co-owner of this brand is the entrepreneur, Emilia Fazzalari. They contracted Destiladora del Valle de Tequila to create their variety of tequilas. Cincoro Extra Añejo is aged from one to three years with flavors or rich agave taste and oak. 

This variant is one of the most expensive and best tequilas on the market. 

4. Codigo 1530 Origen Extra Anejo

Codigo 1530 Origen with box on table

Codigo 1530 Origen Extra Añejo is a spirit aged for 72 months inside French oak cognac barrels. This tequila is one of the most refined tequilas on the market. 

It has subtle flavors of Blue Agave, vanilla, spices, and sweet oak. These flavors are achieved by following traditional methods as a strict code, thus the name Codigo 1530. They stand by the code of only producing high-end tequila based on Mexican culture.

5. Don Julio Ultima Reserva

Don Julio Ultima Reserva on desk with cocktail

Don Julio tequila has plenty of Extra Añejo varieties, but the Ultima Reserva is probably the most fitting entry for this list. They used the Solera [1] aging method, which combines tequila variants. 

This tequila is aged inside ex-bourbon barrels and transferred on seasoned Madeira wine casks during its last months. Bourbon lovers will appreciate the taste of toasted almonds and sweet agave in this Extra Añejo tequila.

6. Don Ramon Limited Edition Extra Anejo

Don Ramon Limited Edition on table with cocktail

Don Ramon Limited Edition Extra Anejo tequila is from Casa Don Ramon, which started operation in 1996. This particular bottle is a limited edition release, with only 5,000 in production. 

These agave spirits are aged for three years inside used rum barrels. This method of aging tequila allowed the spirit to develop a smooth texture with a complex flavor. The Swarovski crystals-embellished bottles are specially-created to contain this Extra Añejo.

7. El Tesoro Extra Anejo 

El Tesoro with box on desk

El Tesoro is the favorite of many Mexicans who love traditional-tasting tequilas. They utilize the Tahona method in extracting the agave juice with all their variants. However, El Tesoro Extra Añejo is aged differently, lasting four to five years. 

The longer aging ensures that the flavors acquired from ex-bourbon barrels are full. This Extra Anejo tequila has chocolate, toasted almonds, and coffee flavors blended with cooked agave. It is incredibly smooth too.

8. Gran Patron Piedra

Gran Patron Piedra with box on table

Gran Patron Piedra is one of the most sought-after Extra Anejo tequila. Patron is considered a total package since they have a good reputation for quality, taste, and representation. Gran Patron Piedra had 36 years in oak barrels. 

These are stored inside used American white oak barrels, French oak barrels, and new American oak barrels. This brand is always a part of Extra Anejo tequila reviews because of its complexity and refined smoothness with a long solid finish. 

9. Herradura Seleccion Suprema

Herradura Seleccion Suprema on desk with cocktail

Herradura Seleccion Suprema does have a supreme taste, considering the number of awards it collected. Their citations include their award from Ultimate Spirits Challenge as “Best Tequila in the World” in 2014. 

It has a balanced agave, oak, and caramel flavor with a finish of sweet vanilla bean extract, caramel, and baking spices on the palate. To the nose, this Extra Anejo tequila is bursting with sweet oaky flavors which go all the way to the mouth. 

10. Jose Cuervo Reserva De La Familia Extra Anejo

Jose Cuervo Reserva De La Familia on table with box

The special Jose Cuervo Reserva De La Familia Extra Anejo tequila is not an ordinary blend. This tequila has a mix of a 30-year-old Extra Anejo tequila from pure agave grown from Hacienda Cuervo. 

The blended tequila goes through oak aging for another three years before bottling. You will get a subtle taste of oak, cognac, vanilla, and floral flavors from nose to finish.

11. La Adelita Extra Anejo

La Adelita on desk with shot glasses

La Adelita Extra Añejo tequila is from La Adelita Single Estate tequila. This is one of the aged brands from Mexico with great agave-tasting liquors, whether this is a silver tequila, reposado, or Anejo. You get great value for your money with this aged spirit, though the price is not very high. 

The color of this aged tequila variant is creamy and silky-looking in a golden amber shade. The flavor is complex where you taste white pepper, floral and fruity with touches of sassafras, apricot, and marzipan. 

12. Lobos 1707 Tequila Extra Anejo

Lobos 1707 on table with cocktail

Lobos 1707 Extra Añejo is another celebrity-endorsed brand. Basketball superstar Lebron James is an investor of Lobos 1707 tequila. The NBA player appreciated the quality of these agave spirits the first time he tasted them. 

The Extra Añejo has traditional tequila flavors where the smell of agave is very rich, accompanied by notes of citrus, tobacco, and sherry. Three years in oak barrels toned down the harshness and turned it into mellow alcohol that glides down the throat. 

13. QUI Rare Extra Anejo

QUI Rare Extra Anejo on desk with shot glass and lime

QUI Rare Extra Anejo tequila is rare, considering the time spent aging on this variant. Twelve years inside Tennessee whiskey and French Bordeaux barrels make this tequila one of the best. It does not have a dark color despite the long aging process. 

The smoothness of this drink is different. It glides through. The palate is pronounced yet subtle. Being aged over a decade allowed it to develop a well-blended scent of caramel, vanilla, wood, and tobacco. You can taste savory smooth oak and buttery agave from tongue to finish. 

14. Tapatio Excelencia

Tapatio Excelencia on table with cocktail

Tapatio Excelencia is from La Alteña Distillery, personally-owned by Master Distiller Carlos Camarena. This brand uses agave grown from Mexico’s highlands and uses ex-Bourbon casks when aging tequila. 

What sets this Extra Añejo tequila apart is the unusual spiciness of their agave spirits with a blend of dark chocolate, creamy molasses, and oak. This tequila also has flavors of dried fruits, roasted nuts, and vanilla, with hints of black pepper and white pepper.

15. Tears of Llorona Extra Anejo

Tears of Llorona on desk with cocktail

Tears of Llorona Extra Anejo is a luxury brand from Master Tequilero, German Gonzalez. The unique trait of this tequila is its one-of-a-kind taste since it was aged in sherry, scotch, and cognac barrels. Bourbon drinkers will be familiar with some of the tastes. 

However, the blend of dried fruit, caramel flan, and dark chocolate is not a common flavor found in everyday tequila. It also has a higher alcohol content than other aged añejos, at 86-proof.

Extra Añejo Price & Age Comparison

Extra Añejo Price & Age Comparison

Bottle Age (In Months) Size Alcohol By Volume Average Price
Avion Reserva 44 44 months 750ml 40% $137
Casa Noble Single Barrel  60 months 750ml 40% $127
Cincoro Extra Anejo 40-44 months 750ml 40% $1,508
Codigo 1530 Origen Extra Anejo 72 months 750ml 40% $309
Don Julio Ultima Reserva 36 months 750ml 40% $787
Don Ramon Limited Edition Extra Anejo 36 months 750ml 40% $596
El Tesoro Extra Anejo 45-60 months 750ml 40% $127
Gran Patron Piedra 36 months 750ml 40% $376
Herradura Seleccion Suprema 49 months 750ml 40% $369
Jose Cuervo Reserva De La Familia Extra Anejo 36 months 750ml 40% $175
La Adelita Extra Anejo 48 months 750ml 40% $111
Lobos 1707 Tequila Extra Anejo 36 months 750ml 40% $157
QUI Rare Extra Anejo 144 months 750ml 40% $599
Tapatio Excelencia 36 months 750ml 40% $146
Tears of Llorona Extra Anejo 60 months 750ml 43% $203

Why Don Julio 1942 Isn’t Included On The List 

Don Julio 1942 is not included on the list because it was only aged for two and a half years. Extra Añejo tequila is aged for at least three years or 36 months. 

Don Julio 1942 tequila is a very savory añejo tequila with a sweet vanilla and agave taste that can compete with other Extra Añejo brands in the market. 

Related Posts:

How To Drink Extra Añejo 

Herradura Extra Añejo

Extra Añejo tequila can be drunk neat. Its smooth and flavorful taste is best enjoyed when sipped. It allows you to experience the plethora of flavors from the nose down the throat. 

It is also a tasty drink on the rocks. It is not advisable to use this variant in a mixed drink as you will waste its savory taste, which was acquired over years of aging. 

Learn how to drink Anejo tequila here.


Is Extra Añejo good for margaritas?

No, Extra Añejo is not good for margaritas or cocktails because of its refined and mellowed taste. This variant will not work well with citrus or other sweet and fruity flavors as these are best enjoyed straight. 

Why are Extra Anejo tequilas dark?

Extra Añejo tequila is dark because of the time it spent inside barrels. Some are used American oak, while others are French barrels used in their maximum capacity. The color stain inside these barrels influences the color of the tequila and its flavor. 

Finding the Best Extra Anejo Tequilas 

Tequila should be enjoyed straight, the traditional way. This is what Mexicans say when it comes to their national drink. Each brand has a defining taste but remains true to what a real tequila should be, with a full agave taste. 

These spirits are smooth and sophisticated, just as an aged tequila should be. So if you want to sit and sip tequila on the balcony and relax, take your pick and have a relaxing time. 



Lydia Martin

Lydia Martin hails from Redmond, Washington, where you’ll find some of the best cocktail bars and distilleries that offer a great mix of local drinks. She used to work as a bar manager in Paris and is a self-taught mixologist whose passion for crafting unique cocktails led her to create Liquor Laboratory. Lydia can whip up a mean Margarita in seconds! Contact at [email protected] or learn more about us here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *