Last Updated on August 22, 2023 by Lydia Martin
Goldschläger and Fireball are two prominent cinnamon liqueurs from Sazerac Company.
One features a real 24-karat gold inside the bottle, while the other is popular because of its strong cinnamon taste and aroma.
But which cinnamon liqueur is better? Here’s a detailed comparison between Goldschläger vs Fireball. Read on.
Comparing Goldschläger & Fireball Whisky
Fireball is a flavored whiskey that combines cinnamon and Canadian whisky, while Goldschläger is a flavored schnapps liqueur with a spicy cinnamon taste.
Fireball has a golden amber hue, while Goldschläger has a clear appearance with gold flake leaves.
The Fireball was introduced in Canada in 1984, while Goldschläger was produced in Switzerland in the 1990s.
Fireball has lower alcohol proof than Goldschläger, which makes it easier to drink. In addition, Fireball is cheaper by roughly $12.50 than Goldschläger.
History & Origin
Fireball came out in 1984 in Canada, but it was known as “Dr. McGillicuddy’s Fireball Whisky” before Sazerac ditched its Dr. McGillicuddy’s name and gave the sweet treat a bit of makeover.
On the other hand, Goldschläger was originally crafted in Switzerland in the 1990s.
When Diageo acquired it, it was produced in Italy. But now that Sazerac owns the brand, it is manufactured in Montreal.
Goldschläger means “gold beater” about the gold leaf manufacturer who turns gold bricks into thin sheets.
Production & Distillation
Fireball cinnamon is a blend of Canadian whisky, cinnamon flavoring, and sweetener.
It was originally part of Seagram’s flavored schnapps but is now part of the Sazerac Company.
Goldschläger is a cinnamon-flavored schnapps from Switzerland, and this liqueur is prominent because of its gold flakes floating inside the bottle.
Goldschläger has a clear appearance because it is schnapps, a distilled spirit with flavorings .
While most people think Sazerac halted the production of Goldschläger, it is continually produced.
“There was a time when we were constantly doing shots of Goldschläger.”– Bo Wayne, Veteran Bartender.
Goldschläger is out of the limelight as other cocktails and spirits trends gain traction.
Fireball’s main ingredients are Canadian whisky, cinnamon, and sweeteners. The brand uses an all-natural cinnamon to give the liqueur a unique and sweet taste.
Fireball is also blended with Canadian whisky, a distilled spirit that should be aged in a wooden barrel for three years .
On the other hand, Goldschläger is made from neutral spirits, artificial or natural cinnamon, and sugar. Learn how to make cinnamon whiskey here.
While Fireball has been known to be a cinnamon whisky, it is not a whisky but a liqueur or flavored whiskey.
It may contain Canadian whisky, but since it has 33% ABV and is produced outside Canada, it cannot be considered a Canadian whisky.
On the other hand, Goldschläger is a schnapps liqueur, a strong alcoholic beverage flavored with cinnamon.
Due to its taste, it has great versatility in desserts and cocktails.
Goldschläger features higher alcohol content than Fireball cinnamon whisky.
Goldschläger boasts 43.5% alcohol content (87 proof), but it was originally developed with 53.5% ABV. Also, each 750ml contains not more than 0.1 gram of gold leaf.
On the contrary, Fireball cinnamon whisky contains 33% ABV (66 proof).
Also, to cater to other states that can sell spirits with low alcohol content, they offer 21% ABV (42 proof).
Palate: Sweet, rich cinnamon, black pepper, and fiery chili-like heat
Nose: Sweet and rich cinnamon
Color: Clear with flakes of gold
Finish: Long, dry, with cinnamon and black pepper
Palate: Very sweet with a strong finish of candied cinnamon and spick kick of whiskey
Nose: Sweet cinnamon, cider, with a slightly peppery aroma
Color: Golden amber
Finish: Cinnamon, menthol, spicy candy, with unique notes
Goldschläger features a nice clear bottle with a minimal label to highlight the 24-karat gold flakes of the liqueur.
Fireball cinnamon whisky bottle features a yellow label with a fire-breathing dragon.
Ownership & Distillery
Goldschläger is owned and produced by Diageo, but in 2018, they sold it to Sazerac Company, including 19 other lower-end brands.
It is produced in Montreal and bottled in Louisville, Kentucky.
The Sazerac Company owns the Fireball cinnamon whiskey, but Seagrams previously owned it. Sazerac Company bottles it in Louisville, Kentucky.
Fireball is cheaper than Goldschläger. Based on Drizly online, Fireball costs around $21.99 per 1L bottle, while Goldschläger costs roughly $34.49 per 1L bottle.
Is Goldschläger still made?
Yes, Goldschläger is still in production. Sazerac owns the brand, produced in Montreal, imported, and bottled in Sazerac Company, Louisville, KY.
Is Fireball more popular than Goldschläger?
Yes, Fireball is more popular than Goldschläger. Some drinks may or may not love Fireball, but it is undeniably more popular than Goldschläger.
Is the gold in Goldschläger worth anything?
No, the gold in Goldschläger does not worth anything. The gold accounts for less than $1 as it weighs 0.1 grams which means it is near-negligible for its roughly $35 per 1L bottle price tag.
In the 1990s, Goldschläger was extremely popular, and seeing a bottle gives us a trace of nostalgia.
However, Fireball cinnamon is better than Goldschläger in terms of taste and price.
Fireball cinnamon is a flavored whiskey with a lower ABV than Goldschläger, but it makes a great drink.
It has an aggressive cinnamon flavor worth taking a shot or mixing in cocktails.