Updated November 2026
Grenadine and cherry syrup are not the same thing. Grenadine is a sweet red syrup that was originally made from pomegranate juice, sugar and water, and its name comes from the French word for pomegranate, grenade. Cherry syrup is made from cherries or cherry flavor and tastes brighter and more tart. Most supermarket grenadine today contains no pomegranate at all, which is why so many people think it tastes like cherry. You can swap one for the other in most drinks at a 1 to 1 ratio, but the flavor will change.
Both syrups turn a drink red and add sweetness, so they often sit side by side on the bar. Here is how they differ in ingredients, taste and use, and when the swap works. For more detail on the flavor, see what grenadine tastes like.
Grenadine vs cherry syrup at a glance
- Base fruit: grenadine was traditionally pomegranate; cherry syrup is cherry juice, cherry flavor or the syrup from a jar of maraschino cherries.
- Flavor: real grenadine is sweet and tart with a deep berry note; commercial grenadine is mostly sweet and fruity; cherry syrup tastes clearly of cherry, often sour cherry.
- Color: both are bright red, so they look almost identical in a glass.
- Classic uses: grenadine goes in the Tequila Sunrise, Shirley Temple and many tiki drinks; cherry syrup is used for cherry sodas, cherry limeades, dirty sodas and desserts.
- Alcohol: both are normally alcohol free. Maraschino liqueur, which is sometimes confused with cherry syrup, is a full strength liqueur.
What is grenadine?
Grenadine was originally prepared from pomegranate juice, sugar and water. It has nothing to do with the Grenadines islands. Over time, to cut costs, many manufacturers replaced the fruit base with other fruits or artificial ingredients, and grenadine is so lightly regulated that its flavor can vary widely from brand to brand.
Rose’s, the most common US brand, lists high fructose corn syrup, water, citric acid, sodium citrate, sodium benzoate, FD&C Red #40, natural and artificial flavors and FD&C Blue #1, with no pomegranate juice. That candy red, fruit punch flavor is what most people picture when they think of grenadine, and it is the main reason grenadine is often mistaken for cherry syrup. Brands made with real pomegranate taste noticeably more tart and complex, so check the ingredient list on the back of the bottle.
What is cherry syrup?
Cherry syrup is any sweet syrup flavored with cherries. The most common types are:
- Flavored coffee and soda syrups. Torani Cherry Syrup lists pure cane sugar, water, citric acid, cherry juice concentrate, preservatives, natural flavors, caramel color and FD&C Red #40. The brand describes it as bright, tart and sour with a touch of sweetness and suggests it for sodas, lemonades, sparkling water and iced tea.
- Maraschino cherry juice. The syrup from a jar of red cocktail cherries is very sweet with an almond like cherry flavor. Many bartenders use a splash in a Shirley Temple.
- Cocktail cherry syrup. Jars of dark Italian cocktail cherries are packed in a thick, dark syrup that is excellent in Manhattans and Old Fashioneds.
- Homemade cherry syrup. Simmer equal parts fresh or frozen cherries, sugar and water, then strain.
Do not confuse cherry syrup with maraschino liqueur
Maraschino liqueur is a cherry flavored spirit, not a syrup. Luxardo Maraschino Originale, the best known example, is 32% ABV and is distilled from the leaves, pits, stems and skins of sour marasca cherries, following a recipe from 1821. Under 27 CFR § 5.150, a liqueur or cordial must contain at least 2.5% sugar by weight of the finished product, and it can only be labeled dry when sugar is under 10% by weight. Grenadine and cherry syrup, by contrast, are nonalcoholic sweeteners. Swapping maraschino liqueur in for either syrup adds alcohol and a drier, more floral flavor, so do not use it one for one.
Can you use cherry syrup instead of grenadine?
Yes, in most drinks. Start with the same amount, taste, then adjust:
- Tequila Sunrise: the IBA spec is 45 ml tequila and 90 ml fresh orange juice poured over ice in a highball glass, with 15 ml grenadine added last and not stirred so it sinks for the sunrise effect. Cherry syrup sinks the same way and gives a cherry orange flavor. Our best tequila for a Tequila Sunrise guide covers the base.
- Shirley Temple: ginger ale or lemon lime soda, a splash of grenadine and a maraschino cherry. Cherry syrup works well here and many people prefer it.
- Roy Rogers: cola with grenadine and a cherry. Cherry syrup turns it into a cherry cola.
- Sours and tiki drinks: recipes that rely on grenadine’s tartness may taste flatter with a very sweet cherry syrup. Add a little extra lemon or lime juice to rebalance.
Going the other way, grenadine can replace cherry syrup in sodas and limeades, though the drink will taste less like cherry. For other options, see our list of grenadine substitutes and our comparison of grenadine vs simple syrup.
How to make real grenadine at home
Homemade grenadine takes about 10 minutes and tastes far better than most bottled versions:
- Combine 1 cup of 100% pomegranate juice and 1 cup of sugar in a small saucepan.
- Warm over low heat, stirring, until the sugar dissolves. Do not boil hard, or the fresh fruit flavor fades.
- Off the heat, add a squeeze of lemon juice and, if you like, a few drops of orange flower water.
- Cool, bottle and refrigerate. Use it within a few weeks and discard it if it smells fermented or grows mold.
Holiday drinks with grenadine or cherry syrup
Red syrups are handy for festive drinks. Add a splash to sparkling wine with a cherry for a quick holiday sparkler, use cherry syrup in a cranberry and ginger ale punch for kids, or build a Dirty Shirley with 1.5 oz vodka, lemon lime soda and grenadine for the adults. For more ideas, see our best grenadine cocktails, our Tequila Rose drinks and our best bourbon cherries guide.
How strong are grenadine drinks?
The syrups themselves are alcohol free, but the drinks they go into are not. A US standard drink is 14 grams of alcohol, or about 0.6 oz, the amount in 1.5 oz of 80 proof spirit. A Tequila Sunrise made with 45 ml (about 1.5 oz) of 40% tequila is about one standard drink (1.5 x 0.40 / 0.6 = 1.0), and so is a Dirty Shirley with 1.5 oz of 80 proof vodka. Sweet, fruity drinks hide alcohol well, so keep count and never drink and drive. Learn more about standard drinks and shots.
FAQ
Is grenadine cherry flavored?
Not traditionally. Grenadine was made from pomegranate. Many commercial brands use artificial flavors that taste like cherry or fruit punch, which causes the confusion.
Can I use maraschino cherry juice instead of grenadine?
Yes. It is sweeter and tastes more of cherry, so use a little less and add a squeeze of citrus if the drink tastes too sweet.
Does grenadine have alcohol?
No. Grenadine is a nonalcoholic syrup, which is why it is used in Shirley Temples and other kids’ drinks.
What is the difference between grenadine and maraschino liqueur?
Grenadine is an alcohol free syrup. Maraschino liqueur is a clear cherry spirit; Luxardo’s version is 32% ABV.
Is there pomegranate in Rose’s grenadine?
Rose’s lists high fructose corn syrup, water, acids, preservatives, colors and natural and artificial flavors, with no pomegranate juice.
Sources
- 27 CFR § 5.150, Liqueurs and cordials, Cornell Legal Information Institute.
- Wikipedia, Grenadine (name origin, original ingredients, Rose’s ingredient list, light regulation).
- Torani, Cherry Syrup product page (ingredients and description).
- Luxardo Maraschino Originale product sheet (32% ABV, marasca cherries, 1821 recipe).
- International Bartenders Association, Tequila Sunrise recipe.
- NIAAA, What Is a Standard Drink?
More in Bar Basics.