Liquor Laboratory

4 Best Casamigos Tequila Bottles Tasted & Ranked (2023)

Best Casamigos Tequila 

Last Updated on November 5, 2023 by Lydia Martin

Casamigos was founded in 2013 by Hollywood actor Geroge Clooney and his friends, and despite being new to the business, it was named the fastest-growing spirit brand in 2022.

With the Casamigos tequila surging in popularity, choosing the best Casamigos tequila should be based not only on the price point but also on tasting notes and versatility. 

We blind-tasted and ranked the four Casamigos tequila bottles to help you out. Follow through. 

Top 4 Casamigos Tequila Bottles Ranked 

4. Casamigos Mezcal

Casamigos Mezcal Bottle and a Glass

Average Price: Roughly $69.29 per 750 ml (Drizly)

Alcohol Content: 40% ABV

Why We Like It: Casamigos Mezcal is made from 100% Espadin, which is slow-cooked, crushed, and fermented before it undergoes twice distillation. 

Casamigos Mezcal was third in line on our blind tasting, and it has a lovely fragrance of fruit, herbal, and smoke. 

We noticed that it is too sweet compared to the traditional tequila, so it ended up fourth on the ranking. 

It has little to offer to Meszal enthusiasts, but it is a good sipper. It features very little smoke, lemon peel, and vanilla on the palate. There are no off-putting notes or harshness. 

3. Casamigos Añejo

Woman Holding Bottle of Casamigos Añejo

Average Price: Roughly $64.98 per 750 ml (Drizly)

Alcohol Content: 40% ABV

Why We Like It: Casamigos Añejo is crafted using 100% blue weber agave [1] from the Highlands of Jalisco, and its unique flavor profile is a result of their extra slow and traditional process. 

The Casamigos Añejo was first in line on our blind tasting, and it has the right balance of sweetness layered with barrel oak and spice. 

It has a gentle mouthfeel with rich vanilla and butterscotch notes. We noticed the oakiness and preserved agave flavor after spending time in contact with oak barrels [2]. 

Casamigos Añejo makes a great sipper because it is smooth with a little burn. However, it lacks the complexity that we are looking for in tequila. 

2. Casamigos Blanco

Close Up Shot of Casamigos Blanco Bottle

Average Price: Roughly $52.99 per 750 ml (Drizly)

Alcohol Content: 40% ABV

Why We Like It: Casamigos Blanco is the tequila in the purest form, and it is proudly made from 100% blue weber agave of Highlands of Jalisco, which signifies premium quality. 

The Casamigos Blanco was second in line for our blind tasting, and we first noticed the citrusy sweetness of the tequila. 

It is more fruit-forward than the añejo and mezcal, and we appreciate the notes of vanilla and mint from start to finish. 

If you are looking for a mellow, slightly sweet, and uncomplicated tequila, Casamigos Blanco is an excellent option.

We blind-tasted it neat, but it works wonders when consumed with ice and cocktails. 

1. Casamigos Reposado

Close Up Shot of Casamigos Reposado Bottle

Average Price: Roughly $59.99 per 750 ml

Alcohol Content: 40% ABV

Why We Like It: Casamigos Reposado is an aged tequila, and it is crafted using 100% blue agave from the rich soil of Jalisco, Mexico. 

The beautiful golden honey tequila was last in line for our blind tasting and managed to get the spot of being the best Casamigos tequila for its well-balanced flavor profile and versatility. 

We were welcomed with a rich caramel, vanilla, cocoa, and agave aroma. The notes of spicy oak, dried fruits, and a sweet agave linger on the palate. 

Casamigos Reposado has more interesting notes than its other siblings. It boasts a smoky upfront, soft mouthfeel, the right amount of spice, and heat on every sip. 

Is It Worth The Hype? 

Yes, Casamigos is worth the hype. Besides being a celebrity-backed spirit, it has flavorful tasting notes that will not crush your palate, even if you are new to tequila. 

You may find it expensive compared to other tequila brands, but their selection offers excellent drinkability and mixability that not all tequila brands can offer. 

“We wanted everyone to be able to drink it [Casamigos] and not be exclusive.”

– Rande Gerber, Casamigos Co-Founder

Casamigos Tequila Price & Cheat Sheet

Type Rating Average Price Best For How It’s Served
Casamigos Reposado 4 Stars Roughly $59.99 Sipping  Neat, on the rocks
Casamigos Blanco 3 Stars Roughly $52.99 Sipping, cocktails, and shots Neat, in cocktails
Casamigos Añejo 3 Stars Roughly $64.98 Cocktails In cocktails
Casamigos Mezcal 2.5 Stars Roughly $69.29 Sipping and cocktails  Neat and in cocktails

*Average prices are based on Drizly. Prices may vary in local liquor shops.

Finding The Best Casamigos Tequila 

Casamigos Tequila on a Countertop

For Shots

Casamigos Blanco is best for tequila shots, especially if you have money to burn (because it can be expensive compared to other tequila options). 

Casamigos Blanco has signature sweet agave and vanilla notes, making it an excellent shooter. Check out our favorite chasers for Casamigos here

For Sipping

Casamigos Reposado, Mezcal, and Blanco are excellent bottles widely enjoyed as sippers. 

It has smooth-tasting notes and mouthfeel with little to no burn. You don’t need a mixer to enjoy the taste of tequila

For Margaritas & Cocktails

While Casamigos Blanco will undoubtedly give you a tasty Margarita, Casamigos Añejo and Mezcal can also elevate the taste of your favorite cocktails.

Casamigos Mezcal, Añejo, and Blanco can elevate your cocktail and do not overpower other ingredients. Since they are smooth and drinkable, they blend greatly in cocktails, especially fruity ones. 

What’s The Best Casamigos Tequila For Beginners? 

Casamigos Blanco is the best Casamigos tequila for beginners. Aside from being the cheapest, it has lighter and more approachable tasting notes from the lineup. 

Casamigos Blanco is smooth, sweet, and easy to sip, with little burn and a nice kick on the way down. 

FAQs 

Is Casamigos tequila expensive?

Yes, Casamigos tequila can be expensive, but it was crafted to be delectable and accessible priced. 

In addition, the brand uses traditional processes and premium ingredients, making the tequila worth its price. 

Is Casamigos tequila high quality?

Yes, Casamigos tequila is high quality. It may not be as premium as other top-shelf liquors, but the agaves used are of high quality, and the tasting notes speak a lot about themselves. 

Which Casamigos tequila is the smoothest?

Casamigos Reposado is the smoothest Casamigos tequila. It is tasty and smooth, with a nice hit and spices on the back end that plays excellently. 

In Summary

With the Casamigos tequila surging in popularity, we hope we have clarified that Casamigos tequilas are great, even if they are not celebrity-backed spirits. 

The Casamigos Blanco, Añejo, and Mezcal are great bottles because they offer fantastic tasting notes with a solid punch. 

However, Casamigos Reposado caught our hearts and taste buds for its complex yet impressive flavor profile. It has a nice kick and hit and does not give you the worst hangover in the morning. 

References:

  1. https://www.thrillist.com/spirits/tequila/why-blue-weber-agave-tequila 
  2. https://www.thespruceeats.com/effect-of-aging-on-liquor-759921
Lumint ad Side Bar
Flex Ad Side Bar