15 Best Gins for Tom Collins Cocktail (2023 Edition)

Last Updated on October 26, 2023 by Lydia Martin

Tom Collins is a classic example of a great cocktail that only requires a few simple ingredients—gin, simple (or sugar) syrup, club soda, and lemon juice.

This fantastic drink is a true thirst quencher, perfect for hot summer days. However, this classic drink will be much more enjoyable when you use the best gin for Tom Collins. 

Whether you want to recreate the original Tom Collins or a new take on this refreshing drink, here’s our recommended Tom Collins gins for an ultimate drinking experience. 

Top 15 Gins For Tom Collins (Tried & Tasted)

15. Barr Hill Tom Cat

Bottle of Barr Hill Tom Cat

Average Price: roughly $45/750ml 

Alcohol Content: 43% ABV 

Why We Like It: Barr Hill Tom Cat is a unique blend of gin as it’s aged in new American oak barrels, so it has the flavors of the whiskey while maintaining the taste of gin.

The fresh juniper opens with classic aromas and finishes with raw honey. Barr Hill is the right gin if you want your Tom Collins with an Old Tom style.  

14. Gray Whale Gin

Man Holding Bottle of Gray Whale Gin

Average Price: roughly $36/750ml 

Alcohol Content: 43% ABV 

Why We Like It: This gin is made with six California-grown ingredients, such as juniper, mint, lime, and douglas fir, foraged along the route of the Gray Whale.

The aroma of fresh citrus and juniper berries lingers, along with kombu sea kelp and cool mint flavors, followed by a fine almond finish. 

Try it in a collins glass or try to sip it neat.

13. Mahón Gin Floral Gin

Mahón Gin Floral Gin

Average Price: roughly $27/750ml

Alcohol Content: 41% ABV 

Why We Like It: Mahon Floral is a smooth, creamy, sweet, and subtle gin with a lot of notes that can go well with certain types of citrus. 

It’s best served on a Tom Collins, but it tastes great with other cocktails, too, like Salty Dog or Gimlet [1]. 

Its rich floral notes complement well with lemon zest and club soda, which can be a good base for making cocktails. 

12. Ransom Old Tom

Pouring Bottle of Ransom Old Tom on a Glass

Average Price: roughly $35/750ml 

Alcohol Content: 44% ABV 

Why We Like It: One of the most accurate Tom Collins gins on this list is Ransom Old Tom. This will capture not just gin fanatics but whiskey [2] drinkers as well for its caramel notes.

Ransom Old Tom can be considered the best for Tom Collins for its dark color and woodsy flavor. 

However, it didn’t rank that high because of its light caramel flavor, which we find a bit off in Tom Collins. But this depends on your style, so you better try this out. 

11. Bluecoat Elderflower Gin

Average Price: roughly $34/750ml 

Alcohol Content: 47% ABV 

Why We Like It: This new addition to the Bluecoat family is a subtle yet powerful blend of elderflower that adds a touch of floral and light to the gin’s already robust taste. 

It’s perfect with a variety of lemon-forward drinks, like orange or lemon juice. It’s one of the tasty flavored gins [3] we’ve tried.

When mixed with an ounce of simple syrup and other spices, it makes a great Tom Collins.  

10. The Botanist Islay Dry Gin

The Botanist Islay Dry Gin Bottle and a Glasses

Average Price: roughly $41/750ml 

Alcohol Content: 46% ABV 

Why We Like It: This gin has rich floral notes and is herbaceous and sweeter than modern gins. Some herbs and flowers used include apple mint, white clover, meadowsweet, and wood sage.

This brand takes great pride in creating high-quality gin using only the finest ingredients. 

Behind this excellent drink are foragers who carefully pick all 22 kinds of botanicals to create a truly unique and balanced gin.

9. Whitley Neill Blood Orange Gin

Hand Holding Bottle of Whitley Neill Blood Orange Gin

Average Price: roughly $29.99/750ml 

Alcohol Content: 43% ABV 

Why We Like It: This gin infused with blood orange adds a sweet and fruity flavor to any simple drink, particularly great for a Tom Collins cocktail. 

We like the combination of different botanical extracts, such as fennel seeds, orris root, sweet orange, and lemon, giving a fresh and crisp flavor. 

Besides, other components, like coriander seeds and juniper berries, contribute to its intense and flavorful finish.

8. St. George Terroir

Hand Holding Bottle of St. George Terroir

Average Price: roughly $29/750ml

Alcohol Content: 45% ABV 

Why We Like It: St. George Terroir Gin is an expression of a rich, earthy, and forest-driven character. 

Its nose is filled with aromas of California bay laurel, fir, and coastal sage. It can be paired with other evocative botanical varieties, like angelica root and bitter pine nuts. 

If you’ve tried the Bols Genever, this is on the intense side. But it’s not overwhelming.   

7. Hayman’s Old Tom Gin

Bottle of Hayman's Old Tom Gin

Average Price: roughly $26/750ml 

Alcohol Content: 41.4% ABV 

Why We Like It: Hayman’s Old Tom Gin is a classic gin made from the family’s original recipe. 

If you want a more complex drink than London dry gin, opt for Hayman’s Old Tom. 

“The gin and tonic has saved more Englishman’s lives and minds than all the doctors in the Empire.”

— Winston Churchill, British Statesman, Soldier, and Former  Prime Minister of the UK

Hayman’s gin is delicate and versatile. It’s a bit sweet compared to the London dry varieties, but it still has a light juniper flavor. 

Although complex, it’s not overpowering, perfect for making a classic Tom Collins. 

6. Plymouth Gin

Bottle and a Glass of  Plymouth Gin

Average Price: roughly $34.99/750ml 

Alcohol Content: 41.2% ABV 

Why We Like It: If you don’t want Old Tom style with a slightly sweet taste, we suggest Plymouth original gin for a Tom Collins. 

It has rich juniper notes with a pleasant sweetness. Besides, the notes of lemon peel, angelica seeds, green cardamom, and orris root give this fantastic gin a tasty profile. 

So when mixed with other ingredients, it complements well, making for a delicious and balanced classic Tom Collins.   

5. Neversink Spirits Gin

Average Price: roughly $41/750ml 

Alcohol Content: 43% ABV 

Why We Like It: Neversink gin, made using a base apple spirit and juniper, is distilled through a combination of other botanical elements.

It works well with Tom Collins due to its apple spirit base, which gives it a more fruit-forward flavor than other gins. 

We like the aromatics perceiving the spirit’s sweeter nature, which softens the effect of Tom Collins’ simple syrup component. 

The sugar content is low, so no worries, even if you gulped on a tall glass filled with Tom Collins. 

4. Sipsmith Lemon Gin

Hand Holding Bottle of Sipsmith Lemon Gin

Average Price: roughly $29.99/750ml 

Alcohol Content: 40% ABV 

Why We Like It: This London dry gin boosts lemon flavor, so if you want an extra citrusy Tom Collins, Sipsmith won’t disappoint. 

This is perfect for beginners as it’s light and not complex. 

This special blend of gin takes the Sipsmith’s London dry recipe and adds a bit of lemon and myrtle for a refreshing and aromatic drink.  

This is one of the most refreshing gin brands here on this list, and you can sip it on its own.

3. Tanqueray No. 10

Bottle of Tanqueray No. 10

Average Price: roughly $28/750ml 

Alcohol Content: 47.3% ABV 

Why We Like It: Tanqueray No. 10 boosts the perfect balance of juniper-forward taste and citrus tones, making it a nice addition to any gin-based cocktail like Tom Collins.

It tastes perfect with fresh lemon juice, club soda (or any soda water), simple syrup, and maraschino cherry, which are the main components of a Tom Collins. 

If you want a traditional gin for your next Tom Collins at a budget-friendly price, Tanqueray is one of the best options.      

2. Bombay Sapphire London Dry Gin

Pouring Bombay Sapphire London Dry Gin on a Jigger

Average Price: roughly $25/750ml 

Alcohol Content: 47% ABV 

Why We Like It: One of our favorite gins for a Tom Collins is Bombay Sapphire, made with traditional juniper berries, almonds, angelica root, orris root, coriander seeds, cassia bark, and lemon peel. 

As expected, this London dry gin makes a smooth yet intense Tom Collins. Aside from adding it to classic cocktails, it’s enjoyable when served in a glass filled with ice on its own.   

1. Beefeater Gin

Man Holding Bottle of  Beefeater Gin

Average Price: roughly $20/750ml 

Alcohol Content: 44% ABV 

Why We Like It: Our top pick for a Tom Collins is the Beefeater London dry gin. It offers everything you’d possibly want in a great drink. 

The juniper-forward taste and rich citrus notes make for a perfect Tom Collins or classic cocktail. 

What we like the most in this popular drink is it provides both the strength of gin and lingering flavors of citrus.   

 *Average prices are based on Drizly online. Prices may vary in local liquor shops.


Can you use any gin for Tom Collins?

Yes, you can use any gin to make a Tom Collins cocktail at home. But for a great cocktail drink, we suggest using London dry gins. 

What’s the best gin type to use for Tom Collins?

The best gin type for a prefect Tom Collins is a London Dry Gin [4], like the Beefeater London Dry Gin. It has everything you’d ask for in a Tom Collins cocktail gin. 

To Sum It Up 

When it comes to Tom Collins, we hail Beefeater Gin as the best gin for perfect refreshment.

It has all the balance of citrus and juniper plus the kick of alcohol, like it’s made for Tom Collins.

But we don’t just stop with one drink, right? So, you better try other options—from the Barr Hill Tom Cat to the Bombay London Dry Gin for various flavors, enough to satisfy your palate.     



Lydia Martin

Lydia Martin hails from Redmond, Washington, where you’ll find some of the best cocktail bars and distilleries that offer a great mix of local drinks. She used to work as a bar manager in Paris and is a self-taught mixologist whose passion for crafting unique cocktails led her to create Liquor Laboratory. Lydia can whip up a mean Margarita in seconds! Contact at [email protected] or learn more about us here or feel free to give Lydia a tip.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *