10 Best Whiskeys for Eggnog To Elevate Your Holiday (2023)

Last Updated on November 27, 2023 by Lydia Martin

When it comes to crafting the perfect eggnog, selecting the best whiskey is crucial. Aside from the traditional rum, brandy, or cognac, you can use whiskey (be it Scotch or bourbon).

So, I did a whiskey taste test and explored various bottles to find the ideal match for eggnog recipes.

If you’re seeking the best whiskey for eggnog, here are my top recommendations to turn eggnog from good to delectable!

Top 10 Whiskey Bottles For Eggnog

1. Angels Envy Rye Whiskey

Bottle of Angels Envy Rye Whiskey

Average Price: Approx $84.99/750ml (Total Wine)

Alcohol Content: 50% ABV

Nose: Candied, citrus, and spicy

Palate: Sherry wood, oak, honeyed spice

Star Rating: 5/5

Why I Like It: This spirit is my top-tier choice for eggnogs since it has complexity and smoothness, making for a luxurious drinking experience.

Centuries have honed the passion of Americans for whiskey, crafting a legacy of taste and tradition.” – Liquor Laboratory

The combination of flavors and gentle sweetness from rum finishing makes it one of the ideal ingredients in eggnog recipes.

If you’re the type of person seeking the perfect bite, Angel’s Envy should be on your top list!

But why is eggnog seasonal?

2. Four Roses Small Batch

Bottle of Four Roses Small Batch and a Glass on Top of a Wooden Barrel

Average Price: Around $32.99/750ml (Total Wine)

Alcohol Content: 45% ABV

Nose: Floral, caramel

Palate: Rich, mellow

Star Rating: ★★★★☆

Why I Like It: Four Roses SB’s mellow and rich profile enhances the creaminess of egg nog recipes. I like how the floral hints add an elegant touch, complementing the stuff in an egg nog mix.

If you want to deviate from the usual rum or cognac and are looking for a subtle alternative, Four Roses bourbon is a good choice aside from Sherry instead of opting for the complexity of vodka or tequila.

3. Old Grand Dad 114

Hand Holding Bottle of Old Grand Dad 114

Average Price: $28.99/750ml (Total Wine)

Alcohol Content: 57% ABV

Nose: Cinnamon, oak

Palate: Strong, spicy

Star Rating: ★★★★☆

Why I Like It: If you’re looking for a real spike and complexity, try Old Grand 114. Its high proof and spicy profile make it a robust choice for egg nog recipes, bringing warmth and depth.

If Scotch can’t deliver the spike you want, Old Grand Dad is an excellent choice. This bourbon whiskey is a great base for an eggnog drink with an on-point spiciness and a bit of earth tones.

4. High West Double Rye Whiskey

Bottle of High West Double Rye Whiskey and a Glass

Average Price: Roughly $37.99/750ml (MSRP)

Alcohol Content: 46% ABV

Nose: Spices, herbaceous

Palate: Bold, peppery

Star Rating: ★★★★☆

Why I Like It: This spirit introduces a bold, peppery flavor to an eggnog drink, perfect for those who want to enjoy something stronger and spicier during the holidays.

Though it seems weird, I find the peppery bit of High West complementing well with eggs, cream, milk, and other stuff in egg nog recipes.

Also Read:

5. Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey

Man Holding Bottle of Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey

Average Price: Approx. $27.49/750ml (Total Wine)

Alcohol Content: 35%

Nose: Nutty, candied

Palate: Peanut butter

Star Rating: ★★★★☆

Why We Like It: Of course, you can always have a fun twist, elevating the milky drink. Skrewball’s unique peanut butter notes add a quirky, nutty twist to the traditional eggnog drink.

Although produced with a lower ABV, it can turn a simple drink into a holly jolly treat. If you hard pass stronger spirits, you’ll surely like the mildness and unique flavors of Skrewball.

6. Jim Beam Black Label Whiskey 

Jim Beam Black Label Whiskey Bottle and a Glass

Average Price: Approx. $23/750ml (Wine-Searcher)

Alcohol Content: 43% ABV

Nose: Vanilla, oak

Palate: Rich, smooth

Star Rating: ★★★★☆

Why We Like It: The rich and smooth profile of Jim Beam Black Label complements eggnog wonderfully, providing a velvety texture and a hint of vanilla.

If you hard pass complex and intense spirits for eggnog, Jim Beam is a good choice since it’s milder with an on-point smoothness, perfect for the upcoming festive season.

7. Maker’s Mark

Bottle of Maker's Mark and a Glass

Average Price: Around $25/750ml (Drizly)

Alcohol Content: 45% ABV

Nose: Sweet, woody

Palate: Smooth, rich

Star Rating: ★★★★☆

Why We Like It: Maker’s Mark’s smooth and rich character adds a luxurious depth to eggnog, making it a go-to for a refined holiday drink.

If you’re the type of person with a passion for something sophisticated yet approachable and delicious, you can’t go wrong with Marker’s Mark. Trust me, it goes well with eggs and other eggnog components.

8. Jack Daniel’s Tennessee Whiskey

Man Holding Jack Daniel's Tennessee Whiskey

Average Price: Around $20/750ml (MSRP)

Alcohol Content: 40% ABV

Nose: Oak, caramel

Palate: Smooth, honeyed

Star Rating: ★★★★☆

Why I Like It: Jack Daniel’s brings a traditional, smooth taste to eggnog the closer you get to rum and brandy. Its honeyed notes complement the richness of eggnog, making it a classic choice.

When you mix it in egg nog recipes, its robust taste doesn’t overwhelm, imparting a somewhat full body and smoothness – delivering a satisfying drinking experience.

9. Evan Williams BiB

Bottle of Evan Williams BiB

Average Price: Roughly $19.99/750ml (Total Wine)

Alcohol Content: 50% ABV

Nose: Caramel, oak

Palate: Balanced, warm

Star Rating: ★★★☆☆

Why We Like It: If you don’t feel like splurging for the upcoming holiday season, Evan Williams BiB is a great value whiskey for eggnog.

“A classic eggnog is just eggs, cream, and sugar.” – H. Joseph Ehrmann, Bartender & Proprietor

Most importantly, I like the balanced, warm flavor that seamlessly blends with eggnog’s components like eggs and creams, enhancing its traditional bite without overpowering.

10. Fireball Cinnamon Whisky

Two Glasses of Fireball Cinnamon Whisky and a Bottle

Average Price: Around $15.09/750ml (Total Wine)

Alcohol Content: 33% ABV

Nose: Grated cinnamon

Palate: Spices, sugar, cinnamon

Star Rating: ★★★☆☆

Why I Like It: The fiery cinnamon kick of Fireball whisky [1] adds a unique twist to egg nog recipes, delivering a warming drink perfect for the holidays.

It goes well with other ingredients, like milk and creams. But mind you, it’s delightfully heavenly to taste, but it’s intensely fiery (far, far from the bittersweet notes of cognac in your usual eggnog).


What is the very best alcohol to put in eggnog?

The best alcohol to put in eggnog includes brandy, rum, and cognac. But of course, you can use other spirits like bourbon, vodka, and tequila.

What is the best bourbon to use for eggnog?

The best bourbon for eggnog is a kind of spirit that goes well with the eggnog’s components, like milk, eggs, etc. Angel’s Envy and Four Roses Small Batch Bourbon are some of the best choices, which balance the sweet and rich notes complementing the milky concoction.

In Conclusion

After my taste test with various whiskeys, Angels Envy stands out as the best whiskey for eggnogs.

Its smooth, complex profile not only complements milk, eggs, and other components but enhances eggnog flavors [2], making each sip a delightful experience.

Most importantly, I can say that Angel’s Envy is a kind of spirit produced with the right ABV, perfect not just for sipping but also for crafting holly jolly drinks!



Lydia Martin

Lydia Martin hails from Redmond, Washington, where you’ll find some of the best cocktail bars and distilleries that offer a great mix of local drinks. She used to work as a bar manager in Paris and is a self-taught mixologist whose passion for crafting unique cocktails led her to create Liquor Laboratory. Lydia can whip up a mean Margarita in seconds! Contact at [email protected] or learn more about us here or feel free to give Lydia a tip.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *