Liquor Laboratory

Can You Substitute Whiskey for Bourbon? (2024 Updated)

Can You Substitute Whiskey for Bourbon

Last Updated on March 27, 2024 by Lydia Martin

There is a lot of debate surrounding the topic of substituting whiskey for bourbon. Some people swear that it’s a sin to do so, while others think that it’s no big deal.

So, what’s the truth? Can you substitute whiskey for bourbon in recipes? Let’s take a closer look at the two spirits and find out!

Substituting Whiskey For Bourbon

Arran Scotch Whisky

Since bourbon and other whiskeys have similarities in grains, production process, and maturation, you can substitute whiskey for bourbon in a recipe. Bourbon is just a specialized form of whiskey, so some of the flavors may be a bit different, but overall they work in a very similar fashion.

For instance, a Scotch whisky that tastes woody, fruity, and sweet may complement the flavors of your recipe if it has a similar profile to the bourbon it’s replacing.

Wheat whiskey is a great replacement in sweet dishes, while rye whiskey is ideal for dressings and fruit recipes.

Is Bourbon the Same As Whiskey?

Not really. All bourbons are whiskey, but not all whiskeys are bourbon, so technically, bourbon may not be the same as other whiskey types like Scotch. They may share some similarities like their grain, production, and maturation process, but their differences set them apart.  

In 1964, the US Congress designated bourbon as a distinctive product of the United States [1], so unlike other types of whiskey, bourbon production is highly regulated. 

Is There A Difference in Taste? 

A glass of whiskey with stones

Yes, bourbon and other whiskey types may have different tastes. Since the bourbon mash bill is different from other whiskeys (at least 51% corn), it tends to be sweeter with notes of oak, caramel, and vanilla. 

Rye whiskey tends to be spicier because of the rye content, while wheat whiskey is drenched with caramel and hints of citrus. Scotch whisky is buttery and malty, Irish whiskey is fruity and light, while Tennessee whiskey is sweet and mellow. 

If you substitute bourbon for another whiskey, expect little difference in taste, especially if used in a small amount. 

Read: What’s the Best Bourbon Substitute For Cooking?

Can You Use Bourbon Instead of Whiskey in A Recipe?

Yes, you can use bourbon instead of whiskey in a recipe. Bourbon is a versatile spirit, and this alcoholic drink is used for cooking and flavoring sauces and desserts.

If you use bourbon in a recipe as a substitute for another whiskey type, we don’t think there would be much change in the taste. It would be best to use the same quantity of bourbon if you want to substitute whiskey with another liquor. 

Related Posts:

Why Replace Whiskey, Anyway? 

Irish Whiskey

Most people replace whiskey with alcohol substitutes or non-alcoholic drinks for three reasons:

  1. Whiskey is out of stock
  2. To try something new
  3. They want non-alcohol alternatives

Since whiskey and bourbons have similarities, it is safe to use bourbon in a recipe to replace whiskey. You can also use the same amount of Irish whiskey and Scotch whisky as substitutes for bourbon. 

If you want non-alcohol substitutions, you can substitute two tablespoons of whiskey with the same amount of non-alcoholic bourbon vanilla extract. You can find this on Amazon or in grocery stores.

In cooking recipes, you can pour white grape juice, sparkling cranberry juice, lemon juice, rice vinegar, apple cider vinegar, balsamic vinegar, or sweet apple juice as a replacement for whiskey.   

What Other Liquors Can You Use? 

Dark Rum

You can replace bourbon or substitute whiskey with other liquors like brandy, dark rum, and cognac. If you love to drink alcohol, you’ll find the differences in the flavor profile of each whiskey and bourbon substitute a bit intriguing.  

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Are bourbon and whiskey interchangeable?

Yes, bourbon and other whiskeys are interchangeable. Even though bourbon tastes sweeter than other whiskey types, it can be used as a substitute in recipes. Moreso, some ingredients like apple juice, apple cider, and white grape juice will greatly help in balancing out the flavors.

What is the closest thing to bourbon?

The closest thing to bourbon may be Scotch, which is also another type of whiskey. Other options include brandy and rum, especially in cooking.

Is bourbon sweeter than whiskey?

Yes, bourbon is sweeter than whiskey. If the bourbon mash bill contains malted barley and wheat instead of rye, it is more on the caramel and vanilla extract side.

Can you use whiskey instead of bourbon in a recipe?

Yes, you can generally use whiskey as a substitute for bourbon in a recipe, as bourbon is a type of whiskey. However, keep in mind that bourbon has a specific flavor profile characterized by its sweet and robust notes due to its unique production process, including the use of new charred oak barrels. If the recipe relies on the distinct taste of bourbon, the substitution might alter the final flavor slightly.

Does bourbon taste different from whiskey?

Yes, bourbon does taste different from other types of whiskey. Bourbon is a specific category of whiskey, and while all bourbons are whiskies, not all whiskies are bourbons. The taste difference arises from the legal requirements for bourbon production, which include using a mash bill containing at least 51% corn and aging the spirit in new charred oak barrels. These factors contribute to bourbon’s characteristic sweetness, full body, and distinct flavor profile, setting it apart from other whiskies like Scotch or rye.

What can I use if I don’t have bourbon?

If you don’t have bourbon, you can substitute it with another whiskey variety, such as rye whiskey, Tennessee whiskey, or Irish whiskey, depending on the specific flavor profile you desire. Each type of whiskey has its unique characteristics, so the choice will impact the final taste of your recipe. It’s essential to consider the dish’s overall flavor and experiment to find the best substitute that complements the other ingredients.

Can you use Jack Daniels as bourbon?

Jack Daniel’s is not classified as bourbon; it is a Tennessee whiskey. While it shares similarities with bourbon, such as being predominantly corn-based and aged in new charred oak barrels, Jack Daniel’s undergoes an additional step known as the Lincoln County Process, where the whiskey is filtered through sugar maple charcoal before aging. This imparts a distinct smoothness to Jack Daniel’s, setting it apart from the typical characteristics of bourbon. While you can use Jack Daniel’s as a whiskey substitute in some recipes, it’s essential to be aware of its unique flavor profile and the potential impact on the final dish.

Is Jack Daniel’s a bourbon or whiskey?

Jack Daniel’s is a type of whiskey, specifically classified as Tennessee whiskey. While all bourbons are whiskies, not all whiskies, including Tennessee whiskey, meet the criteria to be labeled as bourbon. Jack Daniel’s undergoes an additional filtration process known as the Lincoln County Process, which involves passing the whiskey through sugar maple charcoal before aging, contributing to its distinct flavor and character.

Is bourbon stronger than whiskey?

The strength of bourbon compared to other whiskies depends on the alcohol by volume (ABV) content, and both bourbon and other whiskies can vary in potency. Typically, bourbon and whiskey have similar ABV ranges, falling between 40% and 60%. Strength is more a factor of the specific brand, distillation process, and whether the spirit is cask strength or diluted before bottling, rather than a clear distinction between bourbon and whiskey.

Is bourbon smoother than whiskey?

Whether bourbon is smoother than other whiskies is subjective and depends on personal taste preferences. Bourbon is a type of whiskey, and both can exhibit smooth characteristics depending on factors such as the mash bill, aging process, and individual brand characteristics. Some may find bourbon’s sweetness and full-bodied nature contribute to a perceived smoothness, while others may prefer the smoother qualities of different types of whiskey like Irish or Canadian whisky.

Why is Jack Daniel’s not bourbon?

Jack Daniel’s is not classified as bourbon due to its unique production process, specifically the Lincoln County Process. While bourbon and Tennessee whiskey share similarities, including being made from a mash bill that is predominantly corn and aged in new charred oak barrels, the additional filtration step distinguishes Tennessee whiskey. The Lincoln County Process involves dripping the whiskey through sugar maple charcoal before aging, imparting a smoothness and mellow character to Jack Daniel’s. This process, which is not required for bourbon, sets Tennessee whiskey, including Jack Daniel’s, apart from the bourbon category.

Why is bourbon smoother than whiskey?

Whether bourbon is perceived as smoother than other whiskies is subjective and depends on various factors. Bourbon’s smoothness can be attributed to its production process, including the new charred oak barrel aging, which imparts distinct flavors and mellows the spirit. Additionally, the corn-heavy mash bill contributes to a sweeter and fuller-bodied profile, creating a smoother taste for many palates.

How do you imitate bourbon flavor?

Imitating bourbon flavor involves understanding its key characteristics and replicating them with alternative ingredients. To mimic bourbon’s taste, combine a base spirit, such as neutral grain spirit or another whiskey, with sweeteners like honey or maple syrup to replicate the caramel notes. Introduce vanilla and oak flavors using extracts or aging the mixture with oak chips. Experimenting with proportions allows you to tailor the imitation bourbon to your taste preferences.

What are the three ingredients of bourbon?

Bourbon production involves more than three ingredients, but three crucial elements contribute to its character:

Corn: Bourbon must have a mash bill containing at least 51% corn, providing a sweet and full-bodied foundation to the spirit.

Barley: A small amount of barley is added to the mash to facilitate fermentation, as barley contains enzymes that convert starches into sugars.

Rye or Wheat: Completing the mash bill, bourbon includes either rye or wheat, each imparting unique flavors. Rye adds spiciness, while wheat contributes to a softer and smoother profile.

These three grains, combined with water and yeast, undergo fermentation and distillation to create the distinct flavor profile of bourbon.

What are the three main ingredients of bourbon?

The three main ingredients of bourbon, often referred to as the “trinity of grains,” are corn, barley, and either rye or wheat. These grains form the mash bill, determining bourbon’s flavor profile. With a minimum of 51% corn, the sweet and rich characteristics of corn dominate, while barley provides essential enzymes for fermentation, and rye or wheat adds complexity with spicy or mellow notes, respectively. This trio, in combination with water and yeast, defines the fundamental ingredients in the production of bourbon.Top of Form

So, Can You Substitute Whiskey For Bourbon?

You can substitute whiskey for bourbon in a recipe because, after all, all bourbons are whiskey. However, you may notice a slightly different flavor profile on other whiskey types and bourbon.

Bourbons are sweeter than Scotch or Tennessee whiskey, but they can blend well when mixed with other ingredients and will go unnoticed. 


Designating Bourbon Whiskey

Lumint ad Side Bar
Flex Ad Side Bar