Last Updated on November 27, 2023 by Lydia Martin
Eggnog flavors are a blend of taste, especially during the festive season. I’ve sipped, savored, and created varieties of this creamy delight, and I can say that each flavor has its unique charm.
So, if you’re looking for different eggnog recipes, I’ve listed delicious eggnog flavors below, from the classics to contemporary twists – all packed with creamy goodness.
12 Eggnog Types & Their Flavors
1. Old-Fashioned Eggnog
This eggnog recipe is a timeless classic – a comforting combination of raw eggs, milk, sugar, and spices, often spiked with brandy, rum, or bourbon.
“Eggnog – a cup of comfort and cheer you need in life.” – Liquor Laboratory
Palate: Milky and delicious, with a delicate balance of honeyed and spice notes.
Nose: Soft scents of nutmeg and molasses, with a hint of booze
Color: Classic thick white
Finish: Smooth, with a comforting warmth and a lingering spice.
2. Rum Traditional Eggnog
This eggnog flavor brings a Caribbean twist with the addition of dark or spiced rum, typically enriching the classic flavor.
Palate: Frothy texture complemented by the boldness of rum and a balanced sweetness.
Nose: Sweet notes of rum underlined by caramel, nutmeg, clove, and allspice.
Color: A creamy, pale hue.
Finish: Warm and satisfying with a distinct rum aftertaste.
3. Sugar Cookie Eggnog
Inspired by the beloved holiday treat, this eggnog flavor combines the sweetness and comfort of sugar cookies into a drinkable dessert beverage.
Palate: Candied vanilla and sugar notes reminiscent of freshly baked cookies
Nose: Aromatic vanilla with buttery undertones, evoking baked goods
Color: Light golden, akin to a sugar cookie
Finish: Sweet and dessert-like, leaving a taste of holiday treats
4. Eggnog Martini
A sophisticated take on eggnog, this Martini flavor blends the frothy texture of nog with the crispness of vodka.
Palate: Silky and delicious, with the distinct flavors of eggnog enhanced by the spirit.
Nose: A mix of liquor sharpness and standard eggnog seasonings.
Color: Milky with a frothy consistency, resembling a classic Martini.
Finish: Strong and spirited, leaving a memorable impression
Tip: Create an Amaretto-based eggnog Martini glass to enjoy a sweet almond note, creating a sophisticated winter cocktail that your guests will surely enjoy.
5. Dairy-Free Holiday Nog
A vegan and lactose-intolerant-friendly option, this nog uses plant-based milk while keeping the beloved holiday flavors. If you like serving non-dairy eggnogs, this is for you!
Palate: Lighter and nuttier than traditionally served eggnog, with a gentle sugar flavor.
Nose: Subtle herbs and sweetness, less intense than dairy-based flavors
Color: A lighter beige, reflecting the plant milk used
Finish: Refreshing and smooth, without the heaviness of dairy.
6. Spiced Eggnog
This eggnog flavor heightens the spice factor. It is filled with cinnamon, cloves, and nutmeg notes, perfect for spice lovers celebrating the holidays.
Palate: A robust mix of seasonings balanced with the milky base of eggnog.
Nose: A decadent scent of warm, seasonal herbs (nutmeg and cloves)
Color: Cream-colored with visible specks of herbs
Finish: Lingering warmth of spices, leaving a cozy rum aftertaste
7. Bourbon Eggnog
This egg nog is the Southern twist on the classic flavor, incorporating bourbon for a rich, oaky depth and blending seamlessly with the creamy base.
Palate: Creamy with a pronounced spirit character, adding taste complexity.
Nose: Hints of molasses and the distinct oakiness
Color: A deeper cream color, tinged with amber
Finish: Warm and smooth, with the bourbon’s velvety taste
8. Brandy Eggnog Flavor
Elegantly combining brandy with traditional-style eggnog, this beverage delivers a fruity and warm sipping experience, perfect for the upcoming Christmas holidays.
Palate: Velvety smooth with a noticeable presence of brandy’s warm and fruity notes
Nose: Sweet and warm, with the distinct aromas of brandy
Color: Creamy with a subtle amber glow from brandy and egg yolks
Finish: Smooth and rich, leaving a warm essence
9. Gingerbread Eggnog
Gingerbread eggnog captures the essence of gingerbread, making this flavor a holiday favorite. It features ginger, cinnamon, and a hint of molasses and is best served chilled or poured on the rocks.
Palate: A delightful mix of gingerbread spices and creamy eggnog
Nose: Strong ginger and cinnamon notes, sweetened by molasses
Color: Slightly darker than traditional eggnog, reflecting the rum and spices
Finish: Sweet with a spicy gingerbread kick reminiscent of the cookies
10. White Christmas
This festive flavor blends creamy eggnog  and white chocolate liqueur, providing a luxurious and sweet-filled holiday season treat. Serve it in a cocktail glass with edible gold or chocolate flakes garnish.
Palate: Rich and creamy with a delicate white chocolate flavor (packs calories!)
Nose: Sweet, chocolatey notes blending seamlessly with the eggnog
Color: Milky white, evoking the purity of snow
Finish: Smooth and chocolatey, leaving a lingering sweetness
11. Fireball Eggnog
If you like a bit of heat on your desserts, this eggnog flavor drink combines the creamy base with fiery cinnamon whiskey for a bold twist.
Palate: A fiery blend of cinnamon spice and classic eggnog creaminess
Nose: Strong cinnamon with a hint of sweetness
Color: Cream with a subtle cinnamon hue
Finish: A bold and spicy drink with a warming cinnamon aftertaste
12. Vegan Eggnog
For health-conscious consumers, a vegan eggnog is a good alternative. This egg nog drink uses ingredients like almond milk, soy, or oat milk, maintaining the traditional flavors in a vegan-friendly way.
“To me, drinking a holiday eggnog is like sipping on liquid Christmas.” – Truman Capote, American Novelist and Screenwriter
Palate: Light and nutty, with a similar profile to classic eggnog but lighter in calories (with no added sugar)
Nose: Gentle spice and sweetness, akin to traditional eggnog but subtler.
Color: Off-white drink, slightly paler than dairy-based eggnog
Finish: Smooth and pleasant, without the richness of raw eggs, dairy, and added sugar
What is the dominant flavor in eggnog?
The dominant flavor in eggnog is a decadent whipped cream base typically accentuated with vanilla and nutmeg. As for store-bought eggnog flavors in a container, the taste profile varies, depending on the brand.
What is the best-tasting alcohol for eggnog?
The best-tasting alcohol for eggnog varies, but rum, bourbon, and brandy  are popular. Each drink adds a unique character to a nog drink, complementing other components like coconut milk, coconut cream, and eggs.
How do you get eggnog flavor?
You can get the typical eggnog flavor from the mixture of eggs, milk/cream, added sugar, and seasonings like nutmeg. For an egg nog twist, you can add any spirit for a boozy twist.
From the classic Old-Fashioned to the adventurous Fireball Eggnog, consumers will surely find a flavor that suits their palate. Each egg nog type brings its unique blend of taste, color, and finish.
Whether you prefer the traditional serving or the contemporary style, all these eggnog flavors are sure to add a festive touch to your December holiday celebrations.