Liquor Laboratory

ll logo white
ll logo white

10 Best RumChata Substitutes: Creamy Liqueur Alternatives

Rumchata Substitute

Whether it’s due to dietary restrictions, unavailability, or simply a desire to explore new flavors, knowing the best Rumchata substitute can be a game-changer in your mixology journey.

However, finding the perfect alternative can be a trial-and-error and daunting task on the bar scene.

So, through meticulous taste testing, we identified substitutes that come closest to capturing the essence of Rumchata. Keep reading to find out.

Top 10 RumChata Substitutes

1. Baileys Irish Cream Liqueur

Baileys Irish Cream Liqueur

Average Price: Roughly $21.49 (Total Wine)

Alcohol Content: 17% ABV

Nose: Rich, creamy, chocolatey, vanilla, subtle whiskey notes

Palate: Creamy, sweet, chocolate, vanilla, hint of Irish whiskey

Star Rating: ★★★★★

Why We Like It: We’ve tried Baileys Irish Cream as a Rumchata substitute in various cocktails and are obsessed with its lusciously creamy and sweet flavor profile.

Baileys Irish Cream [1] seamlessly integrates into recipes, adding a velvety texture and a harmonious blend of chocolate, vanilla, and whiskey undertones.

“Most very old drinks taste horrible. The wood finishes them off.” -Tom Jago, Creator of Bailey’s

However, unlike Rumchata, Baileys Irish cream does not have cinnamon flavorings, so there is still a taste difference in the rich drink.

Whether in coffee, desserts, or warm drinks like Irish coffee, the gold chocolate cream liqueur makes an excellent choice for replicating the luxurious taste of Rumchata.

2. Kahlúa

Bottle of Kahlúa

Average Price: Roughly $21.99 (Total Wine)

Alcohol Content: 16% ABV

Nose: Roasted coffee, subtle sweetness, hints of rum and vanilla

Palate: Smooth coffee, caramel, dark rum, subtle vanilla, sweetness

Star Rating: ★★★★☆

Why We Like It: Like Baileys Irish Cream, Kahlúa is a fascinating Rumchata substitute close to the smooth cream liqueur because it combines premium aged rum and coffee beans.

The coffee cream liqueur is crafted with 100% Arabica coffee beans [2], so it offers a distinct coffee character with a bold and robust flavor profile.

Having experimented with it in various cocktails, the coffee-flavored liqueur with caramel, rum, and vanilla is evident in every sip.

3. Godiva Chocolate Liqueur

Godiva Chocolate Liqueur

Average Price: Roughly $23.99 (ABC)

Alcohol Content: 15% ABV

Nose: Intensely chocolatey, with hints of vanilla and subtle spice

Palate: Creamy chocolate, velvety and spiced

Star Rating: ★★★★☆

Why We Like It: Godiva gold chocolate cream liqueur is delicately creamy as the drink mixes alcohol with luscious chocolate and subtle vanilla notes.

4. Frangelico

Bottle of Frangelico

Average Price: Roughly $28.99 (Total Wine)

Alcohol Content: 20% ABV

Nose: Roasted hazelnuts, subtle sweetness, hints of vanilla

Palate: Nutty, sweet, hints of vanilla and spices

Star Rating: ★★★★☆

Why We Like It: If the classic cocktail or baking recipe calls for Rumchata, Frangelico hazelnut liqueur brings a uniquely nutty twist and lovely caramel sweetness.

5. Sangster’s Rum Cream

Sangster's Rum Cream

Average Price: Roughly $5.50 (Duty Free)

Alcohol Content: 15% ABV

Nose: Creamy, hints of coffee, coconut pulp, banana, and a touch of citrus

Palate: Creamy, rich coffee, luscious coconut, sweet banana, and a zesty citrus note

Star Rating: ★★★☆☆

Why We Like It: Sangster’s is a Caribbean Rum Cream with an enticing blend of creamy coffee, luscious coconut milk, sweet banana, and a zesty citrus twist.

Its Caribbean heritage and rich flavors make it an ideal choice for cocktails that traditionally call for Rumchata, such as the Cinnamon Toast Crunch Shot.

Also Read:

6. Wray & Nephew Rum Cream

Wray & Nephew Rum Cream

Average Price: Roughly $11.95 (Jamaican Care Packages)

Alcohol Content: 15% ABV

Nose: Creamy, hints of rich rum, vanilla, and caramel

Palate: Creamy, sweet, rich rum, velvety vanilla, and caramel

Star Rating: ★★★☆☆

Why We Like It: We’ve enjoyed savoring this indulgent creation, and it doesn’t disappoint.

Its creamy texture and rich, sweet flavors of rum, velvety vanilla, and caramel make it an excellent choice as a Rumchata alternative.

The Rum Cream liqueur takes center stage when it’s time for a refreshing drink that won’t leave your nostrils tingling.

7. Ponche Kuba

Ponche Kuba

Average Price: Roughly $14.99 (Total Wine)

Alcohol Content: 9% ABV

Nose: Delicate, sweet flavors with a lightly spiced aroma

Palate: Rich, sweet, exceptionally smooth, and delicate

Star Rating: ★★★☆☆

Why We Like It: Ponche Kuba is a delightful liqueur that seamlessly transforms into a Rumchata alternative.

Its sweet, creamy, and slightly spicy profile makes it an excellent choice for cocktails traditionally calling for Rumchata, such as the Espresso Martini [3] or Snickerdoodle Martini.

Its creamy appearance mirrors its luxurious taste, which is rich, exceptionally smooth, and delicately sweet.

8. Almond Milk + Amaretto Liqueur

Average Price: Varies

Alcohol Content: 21-28% ABV (Amaretto Liqueur)

Nose: Subtle almond, sweet amaretto notes

Palate: Creamy almond, sweet amaretto, delicate nuttiness

Star Rating: ★★★☆☆

Why We Like It: Combining almond milk with Amaretto liqueur creates an excellent Rumchata alternative that offers a unique twist to cocktails and recipes.

When tasted, the creamy almond milk pairs harmoniously with the sweet amaretto, introducing a delicate nuttiness that suits well with Rumchata-based drinks.

If you want a non-alcoholic option, you can substitute Rumchata with whipped cream, coconut milk, coconut cream, cinnamon flavor simple syrup, or heavy cream with vanilla extract.

9. Vanilla Vodka

Average Price: Varies

Alcohol Content: 25-40% ABV

Nose: Sweet vanilla, subtle vodka notes

Palate: Smooth vanilla, mild vodka undertones, creamy sweetness

Star Rating: ★★★☆☆

Why We Like It: Vanilla vodka is an exciting and convenient substitute for Rumchata in various cocktails.

On the nose, it exudes sweet vanilla aromas with just a hint of vodka. The palate delivers a smooth and creamy sweetness with mild vodka undertones.

This substitution offers a unique twist to cocktails traditionally calling for Rumchata, adding a distinct vanilla flavor while maintaining the creamy texture.

10. Blue Chair Bay Key Lime Rum Cream

Blue Chair Bay Key Lime Rum Cream

Average Price: Roughly $19.99 (Total Wine)

Alcohol Content: 15% ABV

Nose: Bright, fresh, citrus aromas

Palate: Tangy key lime flavors melded with a sweet, velvety meringue, accompanied by subtle undertones of cinnamon, almond, and amaretto.

Star Rating: ★★★☆☆

Why We Like It: Blue Chair Bay Key Lime Rum Cream is a delightful and distinctive alternative to Rumchata.

“Discovering RumChata substitutes is like finding new flavors to play with.” -Liquor Laboratory 

Blue Chair Bay Key Lime Rum Cream infuses a tropical twist, making it an ideal choice for those seeking a Rumchata alternative that offers a taste of sunshine and seaside relaxation.

Note: The star rating was determined based on every mixer’s flavor’s balance, aroma, smoothness, and quality when used in cocktails.

FAQs

What alcohol taste like RumChata?

If you’re looking for alcohol that tastes similar to RumChata, consider exploring cream liqueurs with a creamy, sweet, and sometimes spiced profile, like Bailey’s Irish Cream.
However, while Rum creams share some similarities with RumChata, each has its distinct flavor profile. It’s always a good idea to taste-test and adjust ratios in your recipes.
For non-alcoholic options, you can add natural cinnamon powder, ice cream, premium cocoa butter, cocoa powder, heavy cream, or dairy cream for a creamy flavor with hints of spices.

Is RumChata similar to Bailey’s?

RumChata and Bailey’s Irish cream liqueur are both cream liqueurs but have distinct flavor profiles.
RumChata is one of the most popular cream liqueurs with a spiced, cinnamon-vanilla taste, while the Irish cream liqueur offers a chocolatey, coffee-flavored profile.
RumChata and Irish cream are creamy and sweet, making them versatile in cocktails and desserts, but they cater to different flavor preferences.

Is Kahlua the same as RumChata?

Kahlúa and RumChata are not the same. Kahlúa is a coffee liqueur with a rich coffee flavor.
In contrast, RumChata is a creamy liqueur with a blend of Caribbean rum [4] and horchata cream liqueur (that tastes like finely blended rice pudding), featuring sweet cinnamon and vanilla notes.

How can I make a homemade substitute for RumChata?

One can make a homemade version of RumChata by combining rum, dairy cream or a non-dairy alternative, sweetener, and flavorings like cinnamon and vanilla. Recipes may vary, but a simple version could involve mixing rum with sweetened condensed milk, evaporated milk, vanilla extract, and ground cinnamon.

Can I use a different type of alcohol in place of rum?

Yes, you can experiment with different types of alcohol to create your own version of a creamy liqueur similar to RumChata. Some alternatives to rum could include vodka, whiskey, or even flavored liqueurs like amaretto or hazelnut liqueur.

Are there pre-made alternatives to RumChata available in stores?

Yes, there are pre-made alternatives to RumChata available in many liquor stores and supermarkets. These may include other brands of creamy liqueurs with similar flavor profiles, as well as non-alcoholic creamers and flavorings that can be used to create your own version at home.

On A Final Note

Exploring RumChata substitutes is a journey of taste and creativity. Each alternative, whether Baileys, Kahlúa, Frangelico or countless others, brings its distinct flavor palette to the table.

This variety empowers mixologists and home bartenders like us to craft cocktails and desserts that are delicious and tailored to various preferences and the requirements of specific recipes.

You can also check out Wisconsin-produced cream liqueur, Spanish cream liqueur made from Amarula fruit (fruity flavor), Kern’s Original Horchata Milk & Rice Drink (rice-based Mexican drink), and pineapple rum cream.

Have you tried substituting Rumchata with other cream liqueurs? How does it taste? Let us know in the comment box.

References:

  1. https://www.wsj.com/articles/tom-jago-helped-create-baileys-irish-cream-the-worlds-top-selling-liqueur-1540564200
  2. https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/kahlua-and-gail-simmons-put-a-new-twist-on-the-espresso-martini-301668321.html
  3. https://www.thespruceeats.com/espresso-martini-recipe-761050
  4. https://www.britannica.com/topic/rum-liquor
Lumint ad Side Bar
Flex Ad Side Bar