Liquor Laboratory

ll logo white
ll logo white

What Is So Great About Buffalo Trace? Answered (2024)

What Is So Great About Buffalo Trace

Everyone has their go-to bourbon, and usually, a backup bottle is needed in case the selection becomes limited.

Buffalo Trace has been one of the most versatile and dependable bourbons in the market today, and once the shelf is refilled with inventory, it’s gone in a snap. 

Those new to bourbon may wonder what is so great about Buffalo Trace, so we’ll crack the code for you. Read on. 

8 Things That Make Buffalo Trace Awesome

8. Its Distillery Is A National Historic Landmark

Buffalo Trace Distillery

In 2013, the US declared Buffalo Trace Distillery a National Historic Landmark because it is the oldest continuously operating distillery in America. 

Based on the Buffalo Trace’s official website, the distillery was described as an intact and rare example of a distillery that operated before, during, and after Prohibition [1].

The distillery was founded in 1775, and today, it remains operational. 

7. Historic Lineage

Buffalo Trace’s history is an open book to everyone, and one of the things that makes Buffalo Trace great is its historical lineage. Some of the people behind the brand’s success are Colonel E.H. Taylor and George Stagg

Albert B. Blanton kept the distillery running through Prohibition, and even Pappy Van Winkle became part of the brand.

Read: Is Buffalo Trace Free From Gluten?

6. Its Master Distiller Reinvented Bourbon

photo of Elmer T. Lee

Bourbon is one of the well-accepted types of whiskey, and the first ever Master Distiller of Buffalo Trace helped reinvent bourbon. Master Distiller Elmer T. Lee almost didn’t get hired by the brand. 

When bourbon struggled against gin and vodka, Lee created the first ever single barrel bourbon that emphasized the process of quality bourbon.

It was introduced to Americans, and until today, it is widely accepted and loved. 

5. Has Various Mash Bills

Bourbon should be made with at least 51% corn to be labeled as one, and one of the reasons that Buffalo is great is that it has various mash bills. Currently, five Buffalo Trace Mash bills are used for different whiskeys under the distillery. 

Bourbon mash bills are as follows: (1) low rye (less than 10%), (2) high rye bourbon (12-15%), (3) wheated bourbon mash bill, (4) rye whiskey mash bill (51% rye), and (5) high rye whiskey mash bill. 

4. Shelters Hugely Significant Bourbons

4 different bottle labels of Pappy Van Winkle

Buffalo Trace is known to shelter giant significant bourbons like Pappy Van Winkle. The wheated bourbon was invented by William Larue Weller, Pappy, and aside from 51% corn, it contains a higher proportion of wheat.

Pappy Van Winkle is one of the after-sought bourbons in the market, and it came from Buffalo Trace. 

3. Highly Popular

Buffalo Trace is highly popular compared to other bourbon brands. Bourbon connoisseurs will agree that Buffalo Trace is a remarkable and well-known brand in the market today.

It is a decent bourbon well-loved by many because of its affordability and versatility. 

2. It’s High-Proof

Most bourbons contain 40% ABV or 80 proof, and you’ll see variations of distilled spirits like “cask strength” that is not cut with any water. However, for its price point, Buffalo Trace has high proof. 

Buffalo Trace clocks in at 45% ABV (90 proof), which is not common for other flagship bourbons. It has more heat on the palate than other bourbons like Four Roses and Bulleit, and the mash bill balances its flavor profile. 

1. Remarkable Spice & Char-Driven Flavor

pouring bottle of Buffalo Trace on a glass

Enough of the background because one of the top reasons why Buffalo Trace is great is because of its flavor profile. 

It has a remarkable spice and char-driven flavor that, when you do blind tastings, you will easily identify that it’s a BT. It is not heavily charred, slightly woody, spicy, and not too sweet.

Most bourbon drinkers will give us a thumbs up because the quality for the price is awfully hard to beat. 

FAQs Related to What is so great about Buffalo Trace

Why is it so difficult to find Buffalo Trace?

Buffalo Trace is difficult to find because of high demand, state population, and affordability. The distillery has difficulty keeping up with the historical consumption, which leads to supply issues. 

Is Buffalo Trace a good sipping bourbon?

Yes, Buffalo Trace is a good sipping bourbon. This solid bourbon has surprisingly nice fragrant, rye-forward scents with enough intensity and character that you can enjoy sipping.
It is an everyday bourbon drink that is not overly complex but enjoyable and interesting to drink. 

How long does Buffalo Trace age their bourbon?

Buffalo Trace is aged seven to nine years in new charred oak barrels.
Aging is vital to BT bourbon because it gives the distilled spirit its identity and flavor profile. Every bottle is aged gracefully using traditional and innovative processes. 

What makes Buffalo Trace special? 

Buffalo Trace is highly regarded for its smooth taste, rich flavor profile, and long history of craftsmanship, making it a favorite among whiskey enthusiasts worldwide.

Why is Buffalo Trace considered a top-tier whiskey?

Buffalo Trace is praised for its exceptional quality, achieved through meticulous production methods, including the use of high-quality ingredients, time-honored recipes, and careful aging processes.

What sets Buffalo Trace apart from other whiskeys?

Buffalo Trace stands out for its distinct flavor profile, characterized by notes of caramel, vanilla, and oak, as well as its versatility, making it suitable for sipping neat, on the rocks, or in cocktails.

How does Buffalo Trace’s heritage contribute to its greatness?

With a history dating back to the early 19th century, Buffalo Trace embodies a legacy of tradition, innovation, and dedication to quality, earning it a reputation as one of the premier whiskey producers in the world.

What awards and accolades has Buffalo Trace received?

Buffalo Trace has received numerous awards and accolades from industry experts and whiskey enthusiasts, recognizing its outstanding craftsmanship, exceptional taste, and commitment to excellence.

Can you taste the difference between Buffalo Trace and other whiskeys?

Yes, Buffalo Trace offers a unique flavor profile and smoothness that distinguish it from other whiskeys, providing a memorable and enjoyable drinking experience for discerning palates.

Final Thoughts

The legacy alone of Buffalo Trace is enough to speak for the brand itself.

From pre-prohibition until today, Buffalo Trace remains a timeless craft that honors tradition and embraces innovation and change. 

The unique flavor profile, affordability, rich history, and well-established legacy of the brand make Buffalo Trace great.


Lumint ad Side Bar
Flex Ad Side Bar