Last Updated on May 23, 2022 by Lydia Martin
Peanut butter and whiskey are certainly not something you thought would taste good together. However, back in 2018, this was proven untrue, and the brands just never stopped making their versions. But which ones are worth drinking?
Let’s find out the best peanut butter whiskey brands and what sets them apart.
Table of Contents
Top 15 Must-Try Peanut Butter Whiskey Brands
1. Two Trees Peanut Butter Whiskey
Two Trees Peanut Butter whiskey is one of the nine flavored whiskies from Two Trees Distilling Company. They recently added three to the nine different flavors they have. This bottle has the full flavor of a regular velvety whiskey, then progresses to brown sugar and caramel into a taste of roasted peanut butter.
You can also notice Carolina peach, crisp apple, and Michigan cherry hints. Since this bottle is not aged in traditional wooden barrels, the innovative methods can still infuse the flavors well. Each 750 ml bottle of this flavored spirit is roughly $25 with an ABV of 35%
2. Bird Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey
Bird Dog Peanut Butter whiskey is aged corn, rye, or barley bourbon. These were aged in regular oak barrels and infused with peanut butter flavors and real peanuts. It has traditional whiskey burn like a regular unflavored spirit.
However, the natural peanut butter flavoring masks the burn and makes it enjoyable to drink. Bird Dog also has higher alcohol content than other peanut butter whiskies. It has 40% ABV. Each 750 ml bottle is sold at around $18.
3. Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey
Skrewball Peanut Butter whiskey started this craze. Steven Yeng concocted a drink at his bar in San Diego and named it “Peanut Butter whiskey,” which became an instant hit. This made him decide to develop a flavored whiskey and sell it to the public. They started selling it in 2018 in the San Diego area, and the rest followed.
Skrewball whiskey has sweet notes of caramel and vanilla. Skrewball Peanut Butter whiskey comes out more like a liqueur than whiskey with the peanut butter flavor. With an ABV of 35%, every 750 ml of Skrewball Peanut Butter whiskey is roughly $29.
4. Skatterbrain Peanut Butter Whiskey
Skatterbrain is a Canadian whiskey base flavored drink from Universal Brands in Minnesota. It became available to the public in 2020. The packaging of this flavored whiskey is very similar to Skrewbal. Flavor-wise, it has vanilla notes, caramel, and butterscotch taste on top of the peanut butter.
One thing noticeable is that the sweetness and the peanut butter whiskey taste are artificial. They do not claim that they are using natural flavors anyway. A 750 ml bottle is sold for roughly $19.
5. Ole Smoky Peanut Butter Whiskey
Ole Smoky is known for its moonshine, producing other spirits before venturing to flavored whiskies. They use a 2-year-old corn whiskey as the base. It has a smooth texture with bursting flavors of buttered popcorn, licorice, and honey.
The peanut butter kick is profound, from the nose to the palate. You can treat this as a straight bourbon whiskey since this is best drank straight or on the rocks. It is one of the best peanut butter-flavored bottles, sold for roughly $21.
6. Sheep Dog – Peanut Butter Whiskey
Sheep Dog Peanut Butter whiskey is Sazerac’s offering to the growing market of flavored drinks, released in 2020. This one does not have any actual peanuts or peanut butter components. Among the flavored whiskeys in the market, Sheep Dog stands different from the rest that uses natural peanut extract.
The palate is greeted with caramel, butterscotch, vanilla flavors, then the peanut butter kick. There is a lot of room for improvement in this bottle. Each 750 ml bottle is around $20.
7. Hard Truth Peanut Butter Whiskey
Hard Truth Peanut Butter whiskey is another best peanut butter whiskey. It is straight bourbon-based with a dark-gold hue made by Hard Truth Distilling Company. Compared to other peanut butter whiskey brands, this bottle offers more complexity with flavor.
It has clear oaky notes with an equally balanced sweet and salty taste. It is infused with deep-roasted peanuts that provide a pleasant aftertaste. This flavorful whiskey from the Hard Truth distillery is sold at around $32 per 750 ml.
8. PB&W Peanut Butter Whiskey
PB&W Peanut Butter whiskey is from Old Elk distillery, which also produces Dry Town gin and bourbon whiskey. However, the distillery never disclosed whether they are using their “premium whiskey” as the base for this peanut butter-flavored whiskey.
This bottle is one of the early competitors of Skrewball Peanut Butter whiskey. It has a deep salted peanut butter flavor with notes of caramel and vanilla with a hint of apple. The viscosity of the liquid is not too much. Each 750 ml bottle is roughly $26.
9. Coastal Creek Peanut Butter Whiskey
Coastal Creek is a product of Total Wine & More. They used a slightly aged bourbon, around six months old, before infusing it with a peanut flavor mixture. The scent itself is very precise.
There is a high level of natural flavors added but complemented with vanilla and caramel popcorn flavors with notes of pure cane sugar. The peanut butter presence is much stronger on the nose and the palate than Skewball Peanut Butter whiskey. Each 750 ml is roughly $22.
10. Copper Still Chocolate Peanut Butter Whiskey
Copper Still Chocolate Peanut Butter whiskey is from Copper Mountain Beverages. It is a spiked hot chocolate flavored whiskey infused with natural peanut butter flavors. The more dominating taste would be dark chocolate.
The nose will catch a full scent of roasted peanuts and vanilla. It is one of the best peanut butter whiskey for the richness of flavor, caramel color, and viscosity. However, it does have a harsh burn. This bottle is sold roughly at $21 per 750 ml.
11. Rams Point Peanut Butter Whiskey
Rams Point Peanut Butter whiskey is from Sazerac, the reputed spirit manufacturer since 1869. The peanut butter taste is very similar to Reese’s Peanut butter cup, even with the smell, with a slight whiff of chocolate. The sweet-salty taste is there but more on the sweet side.
This peanut butter-flavored whiskey also has a medium oak appearance and leaves a bit of a bitter finish. You can have a delicious shot of this variant, but it would be best to have it chilled or iced. Each 750 ml is sold for roughly $17.
12. Blind Squirrel Peanut Butter Whiskey
Blind Squirrel Peanut Butter whiskey is also from Universal Spirits, maker of Skatterbrain. This peanut butter whiskey tastes more like a whiskey rather than a liqueur. The scent of American whiskey and roasted peanuts is very profound.
Another noticeable feature of this whiskey is its thick consistency. It has subtle notes of caramel and vanilla. However, the sugary taste is almost too much. It is great with cocktails and mixed drinks. A 750 ml bottle of this is roughly $18.
13. Shepherd’s P’Nutty Peanut Butter Whiskey
Shepherd’s P’Nutty Peanut Butter whiskey is another offering from Sazerac. The peanut butter flavor of this bottle is more precise and balanced compared to the two other variants that came from the same distillery, Sheep Dog and Rams Point.
The consistency of this flavored spirit is more defined by a perfect balance of caramel, vanilla, and peanut butter. It is sweet but not overwhelming. It is one of the peanut butter whiskeys that can be drunk straight or by shots. Each 750 ml bottle is sold for roughly $21.
14. Barrel & Banter Peanut Butter Whiskey
Barrel & Banter Peanut Butter whiskey is one of the best peanut butter-flavored whiskey. However, this one is for the more sophisticated drinkers. The whiskey flavor is more visible, and the taste does not simply rely on the sweetness.
You can savor the unique flavor far from the flavor profile of the rest of the peanut butter-flavored whiskeys on the market. You can easily taste the oaky notes and other flavors, including the local grains used to make the base. Each 750 ml is sold at around $20.
15. Sqrrl Peanut Butter Whiskey
Sqrrl Peanut Butter whiskey is from Beam Suntory, makers of Jim Beam. The flavor profile of this bottle is not solely dependent on the sweetness of peanut butter. The American whiskey flavor is evident with great peanut butter and chocolate balance.
The scent of warm peanuts will greet the nose before fully tasting it on the palate. This bottle has a more balanced content than Skrewball peanut butter whiskey with a much more affordable price. Each 750 ml bottle is sold at around $17.
What’s Peanut Butter Whiskey?
Peanut Butter whiskey is an alcoholic drink with a whiskey base infused with peanut butter flavor. Some use natural peanut butter essence, while others infuse their products with artificial flavoring. Its normal alcohol content ranges between 30% – 45%.
How To Drink Peanut Butter Whiskey
You can drink peanut butter whiskey straight. Some varieties are well-balanced, which are perfect as they are. However, some may lean on the sweeter side, which is best chilled or served on the rocks. Another good option for Peanut butter whiskeys is to mix them in cocktails.
Does It Give A Real Peanut Butter Taste?
Yes, it gives a real peanut butter taste, especially the brands that use real peanuts or peanut butter essence. Some have uneven fractions on their ingredients which causes the taste to become too sugary. Others use artificial flavors, making the overall flavor inferior to the rest of the products.
Is It Safe To Drink If You Have Peanut Allergies?
No, it is not safe to drink peanut butter-flavored whiskeys if you have peanut allergies  since most legitimate brands infuse their products with real peanuts. Products like Spiked Peanut Butter Cider add real peanuts to ensure that the flavors are authentic and more defined, contrary to artificial flavoring.
Popular Peanut Butter Whiskey Cocktail Recipes
Peanut Butter Whiskey Sour
Prep Time: 2 minutes
Total Time: 5 minutes
- 1-ounce peanut butter whiskey (any brand)
- 1-ounce bourbon
- Angostura Bitters (3 drops)
- One egg white
- ¾ ounce fresh lemon juice
- ¾ ounce maple syrup (optional if you don’t want it to be too sweet)
Fill your cocktail shaker with ice halfway. Pour in all ingredients, and cover. Vigorously shake until contents become foamy. It can be around three minutes. Pour on a cocktail glass and top with grated lemon zest. Serve.
Peanut Butter Chocolate Old Fashioned
Prep Time: 2 minutes
Total Time: 3 minutes
- 1.5-ounce bourbon
- ½ ounce whiskey
- ½ ounce crème de cacao/chocolate whiskey (non-creamy)
- Two dashes of chocolate bitters
- cherry bark vanilla bitters (optional)
- Reese’s peanut butter cup (garnish)
In a mixing glass, pour all ingredients except garnish. Fill with ice and stir. Continue mixing until liquor contents are chilled. Get a rocks glass and place one huge ice cube inside—strain content over the rocks glass. Top with Reese’s cup and serve.
What do you eat with peanut butter whiskey?
You eat bacon macaroni and cheese or maple syrup and bacon. Peanut butter flavored drinks are best paired with creamy and decadent foods. Anything that has rich and savory flavors will be perfect for these variants.
Will peanut butter whiskey get you drunk?
Yes, peanut butter whiskey can get you drunk even if it contains less alcohol. A bottle normally has 30-45% ABV, which is still high enough to cause nausea and dizziness if consumed fast. Beginner drinkers will also have a higher possibility of getting drunk due to lower alcohol tolerance.
Peanut butter whiskeys are becoming popular worldwide because of the complex flavors it offers. If a drinker searches for something out of the ordinary, this is the best bottle to choose. It is no longer a choice for peanut butter lovers alone as some manufacturers are going beyond just providing the peanut butter taste.
There are always a few who stands out and take time to improve what they have to offer to be distinct and not just have that peanut butter taste. We were precise in our description, so the choice is now in your hands.
Lydia Martin hails from Redmond, Washington, where you’ll find some of the best cocktail bars and distilleries that offer a great mix of local drinks. She used to work as a bar manager in Paris and is a self-taught mixologist whose passion for crafting unique cocktails led her to create Liquor Laboratory. Lydia can whip up a mean Margarita in seconds! Contact at [email protected] or learn more about us here.