Skip to content 
Last Updated on December 28, 2022 by Lydia Martin
Bourbon should not contain flavoring agents, but the aging in charred oak barrels gives the spirit its unique vanilla character that many bourbon enthusiasts crave.
Bourbons have different flavor profiles, and some are made with more pronounced vanilla notes.
Here are the best bourbons with vanilla notes that burst in aroma and taste. Read on.
Top 15 Bourbons Known By Their Vanilla Notes
15. Angel’s Envy Kentucky Straight Bourbon
Average Price: Roughly $54.99 (Drizly)
Alcohol Content: 43.3%
Why We Like It:
Angel’s Envy Kentucky Straight bourbon is reddish amber bourbon whiskey finished in port wine barrels for an additional distinct flavor profile.
On the nose and the palate, it has a pronounced aroma and taste of vanilla and caramel.
It has gained a fandom for its complex flavor profile suited for avid fans of dessert-like whiskeys.
We enjoyed drinking it on the rocks as there’s a clean and lingering sweetness with some of Madeira that fades slowly.
14. Wild Turkey Rare Breed
Average Price: Roughly $54.99 (Drizly)
Alcohol Content: 56.4%
Why We Like It:
Wild Turkey Rare Breed is a hand-selected small-batch bourbon whiskey with a rich aroma and taste of vanilla.
It is a barrel-proof bourbon, so there’s no water added to dilute the alcohol, flavor, and tasting notes from the barrel aging.
The unique marriage of 6,8, and 12-year-old bourbon barrels gives a remarkably smooth and sweet flavor.
13. Maker’s Mark 46
Average Price: Roughly $65.99 (Drizly)
Alcohol Content: 47%
Why We Like It:
Maker’s Mark is known for their bourbon whiskey that boasts softness, mellowness, and sweetness, thanks to its red winter wheat and the amazing aging process.
The Maker’s Mark was crafted using Bill Samuels, Jr.’s taste vision and ten seared French oak staves before the bourbon reached maturity.
This amazing aging process results in an easy-to-sip whiskey with rich vanilla and caramel. And baking spices that will greet your nose and palate.
12. Rebel Bourbon
Average Price: Roughly $17.99 (Drizly)
Alcohol Content: 40%
Why We Like It:
If you prefer a budget-friendly bourbon with vanilla notes, Rebel bourbon will not disappoint you.
We consumed the bourbon neat and on the rocks, and every sip was packed with a smooth body and full flavor from the whiskey.
The award-winning bourbon whiskey will greet you with vanilla, butter, and honey aroma and taste. Then, traces of warm spice and raisins will spice things up a notch.
11. Noble Oak Double Oak Bourbon
Average Price: Roughly $37.99 (Drizly)
Alcohol Content: 45%
Why We Like It:
Noble Oak Double Oak is an award-winning bourbon finished in sherry oak for an amazing golden chestnut hue and rich flavor.
The aging process of the bourbon gives character and an improved tasting profile to the spirit [1]. Noble Oak Double Oak gives out rich vanilla, warm spice, and dried fruit aroma and taste.
We like the lingering flavors of cherry and wood, along with some honey and caramel aroma and finish.
10. Noah’s Mill Small Batch Bourbon
Average Price: Roughly $60.99 (Drizly)
Alcohol Content: 57.15%
Why We Like It:
Noah’s Mill Small Batch is one of the market’s richest and lush whiskeys. It has a rich aroma of floral, walnuts, prunes, and vanilla notes.
The palate has a nice balance of baking spices and lingering vanilla and caramel notes.
It is a high-proof Willet whiskey but tirelessly blends well for a sweet, mellow, and distinct flavor profile.
Snag bottles of this vanilla bomb bourbon before it becomes attainable, as bourbon aficionados know about Noah’s Mill.
9. Wild Turkey 101
Average Price: Roughly $33.98 (Drizly)
Alcohol Content: 50.5%
Why We Like It:
Another bourbon from Wild Turkey made it to our list of the best bourbon with vanilla notes, and this bourbon boasts a rich character thanks to its aging in deepest alligator char oak barrels.
It features high rye content that carries a pleasant bite, and we enjoyed drinking the bourbon neat and on the rocks. We tried it in Old Fashioned, and it also shines well.
Wild Turkey 101 has a rich, bold signature of Wild Turkey spice, and the vanilla and caramel notes are evident in every sip.
8. Larceny Small Batch Bourbon
Average Price: Roughly $29.58
Alcohol Content: 46%
Why We Like It:
Larceny Small Batch has been racking up golden awards for years because of its nuanced and exceptional flavor.
It is smooth and soft because it uses wheat instead of rye as the secondary grain.
Larceny has a bright new copper color, and its rich toffee, brown sugar, freshly baked bread, butterscotch, and vanilla notes are notable and well-loved.
It has a sweet, savory, and long finish with caramel, butterscotch, and vanilla notes.
7. Hudson Bright Lights Big Bourbon
Average Price: Roughly $50 (Drizly)
Alcohol Content: 46%
Why We Like It:
Hudson Bright Lights Big Bourbon never shies away from the spotlight as it is a bold, grain-forward bourbon that delivers a great flavor profile and utmost versatility.
It is made from 95% corn and 5% malted barley, and after aging in new charred oak barrels for at least three years, it is fully packed with rich vanilla and salted caramel aroma and taste.
Our first sip contains creamy vanilla, caramel corn, dried cherries, and nutty sweetness. It ends well with warming butterscotch, brown sugar, and charred oak.
6. Henry McKenna Single Barrel
Average Price: Roughly $69.99 (Drizly)
Alcohol Content: 50%
Why We Like It:
Henry McKenna Single Barrel is a Bottled-in-Bond bourbon [2], and it has been resting through 40 Kentucky seasons before bottling at 100 proof.
Bourbon enthusiasts will agree that it has a perfect balance of flavor profiles and versatile tasting notes.
Henry McKenna is a great choice if you want a high-proof liquor with a vanilla bomb.
The first sip has nice oak, vanilla beans, and floral and fruity notes. We like the buttery caramel, rich malts, and creamy vanilla it boasts from start to finish.
5. Garrison Brothers Small Batch Texas Bourbon
MSRP: $79.99 (Official Website)
Average Price: Roughly $86.99 (Drizly)
Alcohol Content:
Why We Like It:
Garrison Brothers Small Batch Texas is an award-winning small-batch bourbon with overflowing gourmet-grade and finest ingredients.
It is made from sweet mash bill, and thanks to its aging in barrels under heat-forged in the Texas sun, it yields a richer, darker, and fuller bourbon.
The leather, buttery toffee, spicy cinnamon, and dried orange peel greet us on our first sip. The finish is reminiscent of vanilla-toasted almonds and sugar cookies.
4. Buffalo Trace Bourbon
Average Price: Roughly $34.99 (Drizly)
Alcohol Content: 45%
Why We Like It:
Buffalo Trace Bourbon is a flagship bourbon, and this deep amber whiskey has a rich aroma of vanilla, molasses, and mint.
The crowd-favorite bourbon features a vanilla bomb on the nose and palate, spice, oak, dark fruit, anise, and toffee notes.
You can consume it neat and on the rocks, and it can elevate your bourbon cocktail because of its rich and great flavor profile.
“One of the world’s great whiskies”
– Jim Murray, Writer, and Whisky Critic
3. Booker’s Bourbon Whiskey
Average Price: Roughly $99.99 (Drizly)
Alcohol Content: 63.25%
Why We Like It:
Booker’s bourbon whiskey is a rare, unfiltered, uncut bottled bourbon that focuses on the sweet spot of the whiskey. It is well-aged for the most intense flavor of the whiskey.
The Booker’s Bourbon whiskey features high alcohol content, and this deep amber bourbon has nice complex flavors of vanilla, oak, and nuts.
During our taste test, we appreciated more of its flavor when we consumed it neat and on the rocks because it has a robust vanilla and caramel taste.
It has a long and lingering finish with a slight smokiness.
2. 1792 Full Proof
Average Price: Roughly $58.25 (Drizly)
Alcohol Content: 62.5%
Why We Like It:
1792 Full Proof has been long acknowledged for its rich and distinguished flavor profile.
The bourbon whiskey underwent a distinct production process to ensure premium quality.
1792 Full Proof bourbon has a strong and bold flavor, but it boasts an incredibly balanced sweet vanilla, spice, and notes of caramel aroma and taste.
1. Woodford Reserve Double Oaked
Average Price: Roughly $52.99 (Drizly)
Alcohol Content: 45.2%
Why We Like It:
Woodford Reserve Double Oaked is an innovative approach to traditional bourbon to create a colorful and rich flavor of bourbon whiskey.
The bourbons are uniquely matured in separate charred oak barrels for additional sweet oak and soft character.
The bourbon is filled with notes of vanilla, caramel, oak, and honey. The finish is full of warmth and ends with vanilla, caramel, and baking spice.
FAQs
Is there a vanilla-flavored bourbon?
Yes, there is a vanilla-flavored bourbon, but it is not labeled as a bourbon but a flavored whiskey.
Jim Beam Vanilla combines Madagascar Bourbon vanilla bean and bourbon whiskey.
It has a perfect balance of full-bodied vanilla and hints of oak that complement the deep caramel notes of bourbon whiskey.
What is the best bourbon for vanilla extract?
Buffalo Trace is the best bourbon for vanilla extract. It has a medium price point, uses non-GMO [3] ingredients, and features an average alcohol content.
Final Verdict
Bourbons are not created equal and If you’re looking for the best bourbon with vanilla notes, pick a bottle from the list above.
1792, Garrison Brothers, Henry McKenna, and Buffalo Trace are some bourbons that burst prominent vanilla notes and are not that expensive.
But Woodford Reserve Double Oak caught our hearts because of its vanilla-centric flavor profile that it owes to the vanilla nature of double oak barreling.
References:
- https://www.thespruceeats.com/effect-of-aging-on-liquor-759921
- https://www.gearpatrol.com/food/drinks/a36466533/what-is-bottled-in-bond/
- https://www.nsf.org/blog/consumer/clearing-confusion-organic-non-gmo-labels
Lydia Martin hails from Redmond, Washington, where you’ll find some of the best cocktail bars and distilleries that offer a great mix of local drinks. She used to work as a bar manager in Paris and is a self-taught mixologist whose passion for crafting unique cocktails led her to create Liquor Laboratory. Lydia can whip up a mean Margarita in seconds! Contact at [email protected] or learn more about us here.
