Buffalo Trace Bourbon Bottle Prices & Sizes (2023 Updated)
Last Updated on November 26, 2023 by Lydia Martin
The Buffalo Trace Distillery, located in Frankfurt, Kentucky, is the continuously-operating distillery in the United States. When alcohol wasn’t even allowed to be manufactured and sold, this distillery miraculously survived and sold whiskey for “medicinal purposes.”
Its flagship product, the Buffalo Trace Bourbon, is well-loved by bourbon aficionados. Let’s look at the Buffalo Trace Bourbon price and its unique flavor notes.
An Overview On Buffalo Trace Bourbon
While the actual inception of the Buffalo Trace Distillery remains vague, records indicate that distilling on the site began as early as 1775.
In 1812, Harrison Blanton constructed the actual distillery, and over the years, it has changed quite a few hands in ownership.
Probably the most profound is George T. Stagg, as some people still refer to the location as the George T. Stagg Distillery. In 2013, the 130-acre bourbon behemoth was declared a National Historic Landmark.
The Buffalo Trace Bourbon is as carefully made today as it was over 200 years ago: rich and complex, yet incredibly smooth and silky.
Buffalo Trace is double-distilled and aged in new oak barrels. It is said that the distillery produces around 10,000,000 liters of this whiskey per year. But why is Buffalo Trace difficult to find?
Fun Facts
How It’s Made
The Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon is specially handcrafted in the world’s most awarded distillery.
Its low-rye proprietary mash bill is double-distilled and aged in new oak barrels for eight to ten years before being bottled at 90 proof.
This makes Buffalo Trace special and well-loved.
The long aging process ensures that all sharpness is rounded out. Check out the Kentucky Bourbon Festival here.
Read: Buffalo Trace Cigar Guide
Main Ingredients
The company has never disclosed the main ingredients nor the mash bill for its bourbon, but being the experts that we are, here’s what we can tell you.
Buffalo Trace Bourbon is friendly on the nose, unintimidating even for bourbon beginners. It has pleasant notes of honey and caramel, laced with hints of oak and citrus.
As you sip, rich butterscotch, toffee, and brown sugar say hello, but these are slowly balanced out with spicy rye the longer the bourbon sits on your tongue. It has a moderate finish with a lingering spice.
Read: Bradshaw Straight Bourbon Guide
Ways To Drink Buffalo Trace Bourbon
Like other bourbons, you can enjoy Buffalo Trace neat, with a little water, or mixed drinks. Whiskey connoisseurs (us included!) highly recommend sampling Buffalo Trace Bourbon in its pure, unadulterated form first.
This process will allow you to fully experience all the flavor nuances within the spirit.
Make sure that you use a brandy snifter for the added aroma. However, if you find Buffalo Trace’s neat is too harsh for you, you can dial the bite down by adding ice or a tiny drop of water [1].
Read: Who Really Owns Howler Head Whiskey?
If you use ice, keep in mind that a larger ice cube is better preferred as this won’t easily melt and dilute your drink.
And lastly, Buffalo Trace Bourbon shines beautifully in whiskey-based cocktails.
The Whiskey Sour, Old Fashioned, and Mint Julep are just some of the best cocktails for this spirit. Here’s a more thorough liquor guide for newbies.
Common Buffalo Trace Bourbon Prices
| Type | Size | Alcohol Proof | Average Price |
| Buffalo Trace Bourbon | 750ml | 90 | Around $34.99 |
| Buffalo Trace Distillery Bourbon Cream | 750ml | 34 | Around $27.99 |
| Buffalo Trace Experimental Collection | 750ml | 90 | Around $149.99 |
| Buffalo Trace Kosher Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey | 750ml | 94 | Around $54.99 |
| Buffalo Trace Kosher Rye Recipe | 750ml | 94 | Around $124.99 |
| Buffalo Trace Kosher Wheat Recipe | 750ml | 94 | Around $69 |
| Buffalo Trace White Dog Wheated Mash | 375ml | 114 | Around $22.99 |
Compared To Other Bourbons
Evan Williams
Evan Williams is a Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey brand produced in Bardstown, Kentucky, otherwise known as the Bourbon Capital of the World.
Much like Buffalo Trace, this bourbon is sweet and smooth, with strong notes of caramel and chocolate. This works extremely well when taken neat or in cocktails.
A 750 ml bottle of Evan Williams is around $17.99, about half of Buffalo Trace at a similar size.
Read: Top Buffalo Trace Bourbon Alternatives
Bulleit Bourbon
Bulleit Bourbon is well-known for its 150-year-old high-rye bourbon recipe, made with 95% rye and 5% malted barley.
The high rye content contributes to a bold, spicy character, laced with hints of vanilla, honey, and nutmeg. The spirit is bottled at 45% ABV, which is stronger than Buffalo Trace’s 40%.
Bulleit Rye costs around $21.99 to $29.89 for a 750 ml bottle, only slightly cheaper than Buffalo Trace.
Read: Bulleit Bourbon vs Buffalo Trace
Jim Beam
When you say bourbon, Jim Beam is probably number one on the list. This brand has a whopping 18 variants, each as delicious as the other.
Each shares Jim Beam’s signature caramel and vanilla notes with a crisp and clean finish.
Jim Beam is probably one of the cheapest bourbons on the market. You can get a 750 ml bottle for less than $20, relatively more inexpensive than Buffalo Trace.
Related Posts:
- Booker’s Bourbon Full Guide
- 1792 Bourbon Full Guide
- Warbringer Warmaster Full Guide
- Howler Head Whiskey Full Guide
- Uncle Nearest Whiskey Full Guide
Popular Buffalo Trace Bourbon Cocktails
Old Fashioned
Prep Time: 5 minutes
Total Time: 5 minutes
Ingredients:
- 2 oz Buffalo Trace Bourbon
- 2 dashes of Angostura bitters
- Sugar cube
- Water
- Large ice cube
- Orange peel
Instructions:
Put the sugar cube in a rocks glass, followed by the bitters and a splash of water. Muddle until the sugar has fully dissolved. Drop the large ice cube and pour in the bourbon. Gently stir until combined. Garnish with the orange peel.
Serving: 1
Buffalo Brew
Prep Time: 5 minutes
Total Time: 5 minutes
Ingredients:
- 1.5 oz Buffalo Trace Bourbon
- 0.5 oz Amaro Meletti
- 2 oz strong cold brew coffee
- 0.25 oz rich demerara simple
- 1 dash orange bitters
- 2 dashes Bittermens Xocolatl Mole bitters
- Bourbon cream
- Espresso bean
Instructions:
Pour all ingredients (except the cream) into a cocktail shaker with ice and shake well until combined. Pour and strain into a chilled cocktail glass.
Top with bourbon cream and garnish with an espresso bean. More Buffalo Trace bourbon cream recipes here.
Serving: 1
Bourbon Peach Smash
Prep Time: 5 minutes
Total Time: 5 minutes
Ingredients:
- 2 oz Buffalo Trace Bourbon
- 1 oz simple syrup
- ½ peach, diced
- 4 mint leaves
- Ginger beer
- Peach slice
- Fresh mint
- Ice
Instructions:
Put the diced peach, mint leaves, and syrup in a cocktail shaker and muddle until the ingredients have released their natural juices.
Add the ice and bourbon and shake until everything is combined and chilled.
Pour and strain the mixture into a rocks glass with fresh ice and top with ginger beer. Lastly, garnish it with fresh mint and a peach slice.
Serving: 1
FAQs
What is a good price for Buffalo Trace Bourbon?
You can expect to pay about $40 for a bottle of Buffalo Trace Bourbon, which we believe is a fair price for its excellent quality. Let’s compare Buffalo Trace and Eagle Rare bourbon here.
Is Buffalo Trace expensive?
No, Buffalo Trace is not expensive. It’s not as cheap as other bourbon brands, like Jim Beam and Jack Daniels, but it’s not crazy expensive either.
We would consider it a mid-range bourbon brand at around $40-ish for a 750 ml bottle. Here’s our detailed comparison between Buffalo Trace and Woodford Reserve.
In Conclusion
Buffalo Trace Bourbon isn’t merely a spirit — it’s a piece of US history. The spirit, produced at one of the oldest distilleries in the country, is rich and complex, yet smooth and mellow at the same time.
It’s a firm staple to any bourbon lover’s collection and is friendly enough for a beginner’s palate.
It’s impossible to take a sip of Bourbon Trace bourbons without being in awe of their majestic history.
Reference:
- https://www.livescience.com/60158-why-whiskey-tastes-good-diluted.html
35 isn’t the msrp. If it’s sold at that price the liquor store is jacking up the prices as they sometimes do. MSRP is closer to $25
It’s great at retail prices but not worth the markups some places do. If you’re paying over $35 for it, you’re paying too much. I’m mixing it with Pepsi as I write this.
Very nice! I agree!
Being from Texas Buffalo Trace is hard to find as my fellow Texas appreciate bourbon. I have found it to retail for $27.99 in most high volume retailers like Total Wine, Spec’s or Twin Liquors. I think that’s more than fair price for a Good Well Balanced Bourbon for even the most sophisticated palate.
Apple juice works well as a mixer with Buffalo Trace. Msrp in my neck of the woods is $35. Not a bad price. Also Bulleit Rye Bourbon compares great to Buffalo Trace
Thanks!
A couple things from a guy who lives 15 minutes from the Buffalo Trace Distillery:
1. It should cost around $27. Any more and your store is price gouging. Here in Lexington, we’re lucky to find it. When we do, it’s always a one bottle limit.
2. Jack Daniel’s is not bourbon. It’s sour mash. Its not made or aged the same way.
If you ever get out here, be sure to visit the distillery. If you can book one, tours are fantastic, free, and they include a tasting of 5 or 6 different items. Plus there’s a gift shop where you can buy BT plus whatever bottle they feature that day, like Blanton’s, Eagle Rare, EH Taylor, etc.