10 Best Hot Sauce Options for Bloody Mary: Spice It Up (2023)

Last Updated on September 13, 2023 by Lydia Martin

Sipping a zingy Bloody Mary is like a flavorful adventure for the taste buds, and finding the perfect hot sauce to elevate that experience is key!

However, with so many options available on the market today, it may be challenging to find the best hot sauce for Bloody Mary. Fortunately, we’re here to save you time and energy.

After savoring countless Bloody Mary cocktails, we’re here to dish out our favorite hot sauces for Bloody Mary – not just one but ten best hot sauces that’ll turn your Bloody Mary into a fiery mixology.

Top 10 Hot Sauces To Spike Up Bloody Mary

1. Tabasco Sauce

Person Holding Bottle of Tabasco Sauce

Average Price: around $6.86/12oz (Walmart)

Spiciness Level: Spicy

Star Rating: ★★★★★

Why We Like It: If you prefer the classic taste of the Southern tradition, Tabasco is the right hot sauce to add to Bloody Marys.

“Spice up your sip, let Tabasco lead your Bloody Mary journey.” – Liquor Laboratory 

The bold vinegar spice complements the tomato juice base, kicking up the heat level. Though it lacks subtlety, it never fails to deliver that classic spicy kick.

2. Sriracha Hot Sauce (Huy Fong Foods)

Close Up Image of Sriracha Hot Sauce (Huy Fong Foods)

Average Price: around $3.62/17oz (Walmart)

Spiciness Level: Spicy

Star Rating: ★★★★★

Why We Like It: If you’re like us, a Thai-style sensation fan, try Sriracha hot sauce in your Bloody Marys. We like the distinctive chili pepper paste, distilled vinegar, garlic, sugar, and salt blend.

It makes for a Spicy Sriracha Bloody Mary or Spicy Bloody Maria, delivering a flavorful, tangy punch unlike other hot sauces.

While it’s not the spiciest, it adds a unique aromatic twist to your Bloody Mary. But what’s the ratio of Bloody Mary mix to vodka?

3. El Yucateco Chile Habanero Hot Sauce

Bottle of El Yucateco Chile Habanero Hot Sauce

Average Price: around $6.48/8oz (Amazon)

Spiciness Level: Spicy

Star Rating: ★★★★★

Why We Like It: This hot sauce brings complexity and a bold kick to your Bloody Mary (or Bloody Maria). El Yucateco boasts a thick texture, unlike any thin, vinegar-heavy Louisiana hot sauce.

We like the rich habanero red peppers, tomatoes, and fine spices blend. Its complex and spicy flavors make it one of the best hot sauces for those who crave Mexican-style hot sauce in their Bloody Mary.

4. Melinda’s Habanero Hot Sauce

Bottle of Melinda's Habanero Hot Sauce on a Wooden Table

Average Price: around $4.49/5oz (MSRP)

Spiciness Level: Hot to extra spicy

Star Rating: ★★★★★

Why We Like It: Melinda’s hot sauces use quality ingredients, like habanero peppers and lime juice in the Original variety. It’s vinegar-based but with a less dominant vinegar taste, catering to all heat and flavor preferences.

Whether you prefer the original or explore different flavors, Melinda’s delivers quality, heat, and outstanding profile to elevate mild to spicy Bloody Mary.

5. Frank’s Red Hot Cayenne Pepper Sauce

Close Up Image of Frank's Red Hot Cayenne Pepper Sauce

Average Price: around $6.39/23oz (Target)

Spiciness Level: Mild to medium

Star Rating: ★★★★★

Why We Like It: Frank’s Red Hot is one of the versatile classic sauces – not just perfect for Buffalo wings but also in Bloody Marys.

We like the mild to medium spiciness that adds a pleasant kick without overpowering the Bloody Mary. Like Tabasco, Frank’s is another favorite hot sauce for Bloody Mary lovers.

Related Posts:

6. Cholula Sweet Habanero

Person Holding Bottle of Cholula Sweet Habanero

Average Price: around $9.99/12oz (Amazon)

Spiciness Level: Mild

Star Rating: ★★★★☆

Why We Like It: We like Cholula Sweet Habanero for its unique blend of pequin and arbol peppers, making the Bloody Mary smoky and nutty. Also, you can try it in a Bloody Maria with tequila.

Its mild spiciness adds depth and character, so it’s a must-try if you seek a flavorful taste from tradition. Or, if you can’t take a spicy Bloody Mary, Cholula is perfect to add to your Bloody Mary bar!

7. Mule Sauce with Habanero

Bottle of Mule Sauce with Habanero

Average Price: around $7.99/5oz (Amazon)

Spiciness Level: Extra spicy

Star Rating: ★★★★☆

Why We Like It: This sauce is a fiery blend of red habaneros, ghost peppers, and yellow Scotch Bonnet peppers with cane sugar, molasses, ginger, and garlic, giving a delectable flavor explosion.

If you’re inclined toward a peaty Scotch, spicy-sweet twist in your Bloody Mary drink, this zesty pleaser with Habanero delivers the perfect kick and heat and a hint of sweetness that’s sure to entice your palate.

8. El Yucateco Green Chile Habanero Hot Sauce

Bottle of El Yucateco Green Chile Habanero Hot Sauce

Average Price: around$4.99/4oz (Chile Mojo)

Spiciness Level: Extra hot

Star Rating: ★★★★☆

Why We Like It: Another favorite spice from El Yucateco is this Green Chile Habanero that packs a punch with its blend of habanero peppers, garlic, spice, and seasoning.

This is one of our go-to sauces whenever we like a spicy Bloody Mary (or spicy Bloody Maria).

9. BLiS Blast Hot Sauce

Man Holding Bottle of BLiS Blast Hot Sauce

Average Price: around $12.95/12.7oz (MSRP)

Spiciness Level: Medium hot

Star Rating: ★★★★☆

Why We Like It: For a barrel-aged brunch tail, try the Blis Blast sauce, aged in ex-bourbon, maple syrup, and Kentucky Breakfast Stout barrels.

This Michigan-made hot sauce boasts a triple infusion of rich, woody flavor, which we recommend if you want more smoke and a distinct, barrel-aged flavor.

10. Texas Pete Original Hot Sauce

Bottle of Texas Pete Original Hot Sauce

Average Price: around $9.75/3-pack (MSRP)

Spiciness Level: Medium hot

Star Rating: ★★★☆☆

Why We Like It: Texas Pete Original offers a straightforward, medium-spicy taste with a harmonious balance between aged red peppers and vinegar.

“Sometimes you need coffee, and sometimes you need a Bloody Mary.” – Mike Dirnt, American Musician

Combined with a few dashes dash of Worcestershire sauce and garnished with green olives, celery salt, and celery stalk, it makes for a zesty yet spicy Blood Mary.

*Note: The hot sauces are rated based on their quality, spiciness level, popularity, and how well they pair with a Bloody Mary. 


What kind of sauce do you put in a Bloody Mary?

You need to put hot sauce in a Bloody Mary, which is traditionally Tabasco. You can use variations like sriracha [1] if you want a spicy Bloody Mary flavor.

What is a spicy Bloody Mary made of?

A spicy Bloody Mary is typically made of vodka, tomato juice, hot sauce, Worcestershire sauce, horseradish, and just the right amount of black pepper and celery salt.

For some Bloody Mary [2] variations, add pickle or lemon juice for an added twist and flavor.

How do I choose a hot sauce for Bloody Mary?

Choose a hot sauce for Bloody Mary, depending on your heat preference. Opt for mild to hot sauces based on your taste.

If you want a similar flavor as the classics, go for mild to medium hot ones.

Key Takeaways

With all the hot sauces we’ve tried, Tabasco emerges as the classic champion. Its fiery kick and tangy vibrancy elevate the vodka-based cocktail, giving a timeless, unbeatable experience.

Yet, the ultimate choice depends on your personal preference. So, it’s best to explore all the good options, fill up your Bloody Mary bar, and craft your perfect cocktail.



Lydia Martin

Lydia Martin hails from Redmond, Washington, where you’ll find some of the best cocktail bars and distilleries that offer a great mix of local drinks. She used to work as a bar manager in Paris and is a self-taught mixologist whose passion for crafting unique cocktails led her to create Liquor Laboratory. Lydia can whip up a mean Margarita in seconds! Contact at [email protected] or learn more about us here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *