Liquor Laboratory

ll logo white
ll logo white

12 Best Store Bought Bloody Mary Mix Options (2023 Updated)

Best Store-Bought Bloody Mary Mix

Last Updated on November 26, 2023 by Lydia Martin

Looking for the perfect Bloody Mary mix to kickstart your day? Well, look no further! We’ve tasted our way through the options, and we’re here to share our top picks.

So, if you’re ready to spice up your mornings with the perfect blend, keep reading for the best store-bought Bloody Mary mix you should try next!

Top 12 Store-Bought Bloody Mary Mixes

1. Tres Agaves Bloody Mary Organic Mix

Hand Holding Bottle of Tres Agaves Bloody Mary Organic Mix

Average Price: around $9.99/1L (Total Wine)

Star Rating: 5/5

Why We Like It: If you like the classic flavor, Tres Agaves is the best Bloody Mary mix with a delightful twist. The tomato-forward flavor, coupled with an array of savory spices, elevates the spice level.

“Sometimes you need coffee, and sometimes you need a Bloody Mary.” – Mike Dirnt, American Musician

The touch of citric acid tastes fresh, and the hint of heat provides a kick. So, it’s a harmonious cocktail mix that elevates the Bloody Mary to a new level of enjoyment.

2. Finest Call Bloody Mary Premium Drink Mix

Finest Call Bloody Mary Premium Drink Mix on a Table

Average Price: around $4.99/1L (Total Wine)

Star Rating: 5/5

Why We Like It: Finest Call has a lineup of equally impressive Bloody Mary mixes. We like using fresh lemon juice and tomato juice, setting them apart from other cocktail mixes.

It’s one of the best Bloody Mary mixes for its cracked black pepper and horseradish, providing a rich and indulgent texture. Combined with a smoky Mezcal, it’s a delicious mix to savor.

3. Zing Zang Bloody Mary Mix

Bottle of Zing Zang Bloody Mary Mix and a Glass of Drink

Average Price: around $9.99/1.75L (Total Wine)

Star Rating: 5/5

Why We Like It: This Zing Zang Bloody Mary mixer [1] delivers a balance of zingy flavors with seven vegetable juices plus an extra kick of vinegar, celery seed, and pepper.

We recommend Zing Zang for those seeking a tangy and vibrant Bloody Mary experience. It’s our go-to brand for a bright, zesty, tangy Bloody Mary that awakens your taste buds.

4. Bourbon Barrel Foods Bloody Mary

2 Bottles of Bourbon Barrel Foods Bloody Mary and a Glass Drink

Average Price: around $14/32oz (MSRP)

Star Rating: 4/5

Why We Like It: If you want something unique, Bourbon Barrel Foods Bloody Mary Mix is a standout choice for its unique ingredients, including Bourbon Barrel Aged Worcestershire and Bourbon Smoked Spices.

Cold-pressed lemon and lime juices add a refreshing twist to the classic Bloody Marys [2]. Besides, it’s vegetarian-friendly, delivering a distinctive and flavorful Bloody Mary experience.

5. V8 Bloody Mary Original Mix

Bottle of V8 Bloody Mary Original Mix with Celery and Lime on a Table

Average Price: around $3.34/46oz (Walmart)

Star Rating: 4/5

Why We Like It: The V8 is a vibrant and well-balanced cocktail with great consistency. The blend of tomato juice, Worcestershire sauce, and hot sauce provides a satisfying kick.

The infusion of lemon or lime juice adds a refreshing touch, making this one of the best Bloody Mary mixes, perfect for those seeking a bold, zesty cocktail mix that excites the palate.

6. McClure’s Bloody Mary Mixer

Jar of McClure's Bloody Mary Mixer and a Shaker

Average Price: around $13.99/320z (MSRP)

Star Rating: 4/5

Why We Like It: McClure’s is the perfect choice if you’re after a bold, spicy Bloody Mary mix. Also, if you love pickles, you’ll like McClure’s pickle flavor with hints of black pepper and hot peppers.

We find this spicy Bloody Mary mix tasting great with bourbon garnished with bacon. You may also add vodka if you prefer. Regardless, it’s one of the best Bloody Mary blends worth savoring.

7. Stirrings Simple Bloody Mary Cocktail Mixer

Stirrings Simple Bloody Mary Cocktail Mixer on a Table

Average Price: around $7.99/25.4oz (MSRP)

Star Rating: 4/5

Why We Like It: This Bloody Mary mixer cleverly incorporates a pinch of sugar to balance the acidity of the tomato juice. Besides, we like how the hot sauce for Bloody Mary and the spice blend adds a unique kick.

The big flavors provide a memorable brunch cocktail. Just add your favorite spirit and rim your glass with Stirrings Bloody Mary Rimmer for an extra touch of perfection.

8. Toma Original Bloody Mary Mix

Toma Original Bloody Mary Mix and a Shaker

Average Price: around $32/2-pack (MSRP)

Star Rating: 4/5

Why We Like It: Its blend of tangy tomato juice, aromatic spices, and a subtle hint of heat delivers a truly unforgettable drinking experience.

Elevate Bloody Marys with its extraordinary flavors and fresh ingredients, providing the true essence of a remarkable mix.

9. Crispy Pig Whiskey Bloody Mary

Cans of Crispy Pig Whiskey Bloody Mary

Average Price: around $10.99/4-pack (Total Wine)

Star Rating: 4/5

Why We Like It: We like this Bloody Mary mix as it’s a ready-to-drink option, offering a convenient and delicious way to enjoy Bloody Marys.

This great Bloody Mary mix uses top-notch, locally sourced ingredients. Plus, it’s gluten-free and avoids additives, making it a premium choice for discerning drinkers. But what’s our recommended vodka for Bloody Mary?

10. Real Dill Bloody Mary Mix

Jar of Real Dill Bloody Mary Mix and a Cocktail Drink

Average Price: around $14.99/32oz (MSRP)

Star Rating: 4/5

Why We Like It: Real Dill Bloody Mary Mix boasts extraordinary flavors with a perfect balance of tanginess and depth in every sip.

Whether enjoyed over ice, with a few dashes of liqueur, or with preferred garnishes, this mix’s complexity and versatility make it one of our favorite Bloody Mary mixers.

11. Collins Classic Bloody Mary

2 Bottles and a Glass of Collins Classic Bloody Mary

Average Price: around $13.99/32oz (MSRP)

Star Rating: 3/5

Why We Like It: Collins Classic is a wallet-friendly choice that stays true to the traditional Bloody Mary recipe [3]. While it doesn’t use all-natural ingredients, it retains a delicious and classic flavor profile.

Adding sugar enhances the tangy Worcestershire sauce, and garnishing with jalapeno-stuffed olives or banana peppers adds an enjoyable kick.

Read: Bloody Mary Mix to Vodka Ratio

12. Mr. and Mrs. T Bloody Mary Mix

Bottle and a Can of Mr. and Mrs. T Bloody Mary Mix

Average Price: around $2.47/4-pack (Amazon)

Star Rating: 3/5

Why We Like It: Mr. and Mrs. T Bloody Mary mix delivers classic flavors with cayenne pepper and Chipotle pepper puree but lacks some of the complexity found in premium options.

“Life’s better with a Bloody Mary in hand—spice up your day.” – Liquor Laboratory 

While it may not have the bold flavors, we find it a reliable choice if you seek a simple and affordable Bloody Mary mix. As an alternative, you may try the Old Bay Bloody Mary mix.

 *Note: The star rating was determined based on their flavor and overall taste, spiciness, texture, quality of ingredients, versatility, value for money, and availability.

FAQs

What is the best alcohol to put in a Bloody Mary?

The perfect alcohol for the best Bloody Mary mix is vodka [4]. Its neutral flavor complements the Bloody Mary, allowing the spices and ingredients to shine. It even tastes great with a celery stalk garnish and celery salt rim.

Does Trader Joe’s have Bloody Mary mixes?

Yes, Trader Joe’s has a Bloody Mary mixture. Trader Joe’s is one of the Bloody Mary Mix brands, which uses tomato puree (instead of tomato juice), briny clam juice (instead of pickle brine), and a savory spice blend.

You can also check out some easy tequila drinks here.

Key Takeaways

After trying various store-bought options, one stands out: Tres Agaves Organic BM Mix.

It’s the best Bloody Mary mix for its perfect balance of flavors, from robust tomato to zesty spices, elevating our cocktail experience.

But don’t just take our word for it; options like Finest Call Premium and Zing Zang Bloody Mary Mix deliver their own unique delights.

So, why wait? Grab a bottle of each and elevate your brunch today. Cheers to delicious Bloody Marys!

References:

  1. https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/zing-zang-debuts-new-1-75l-ready-to-serve-bloody-mary-cocktail-301794437.html
  2. https://www.scmp.com/lifestyle/travel-leisure/article/3165781/where-was-bloody-mary-invented-and-what-about-james-bonds
  3. https://www.southernliving.com/bloody-mary-7093218
  4. https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/agricultural-and-biological-sciences/vodka
Lumint ad Side Bar
Flex Ad Side Bar