Skip to content 
Last Updated on March 13, 2023 by Lydia Martin
We shop for liquors at Costco because of its great deals on authentic and quality brands. Knowing Costco offers big discounts and a wide array of choices, picking the best tequila may become challenging.
But fear not. We took the time to check Costco’s roster and compare the tequilas they have, in price, quality and flavor. Keep on reading to find the best tequila at Costco.
Top 10 Tequilas To Buy At Costco
10. Casamigos Reposado
Average Price: Roughly at $42.99 /750ml (Total Wine)
Distillery: Diageo
Alcohol Proof: 80 proof
Why We Liked It:
We love Casamigos Reposado because of its straight-up agave taste. The fruity and earthy notes are well balanced, too.
It has a taste of oak and smoke, giving the smooth finish a great transition. This bottle is perfect for sipping.
9. Herradura Ultra Anejo Tequila
Average Price: Roughly at $41.99 /750ml (Total Wine)
Distillery: Brown-Forman Distillers
Alcohol Proof: 80 proof
Why We Liked It:
Herradura Ultra Añejo is one of the smoothest and most flavorful tequilas. Aged 49 months, this añejo tequila has an interesting mix of coconut-pineapple-vanilla.
It may not be the ideal drink for tequila purists, but it is absolutely savory and addicting, especially when used as a mixing base.
8. Corralejo Tequila Reposado
Average Price: Roughly at $25.99 /750ml (Total Wine)
Distillery: El Tequila Grande de México
Alcohol Proof: 80 proof
Why We Liked It:
Reposados are rarely used as a mixing base, but this rested tequila is one of a kind.
It has a well-rounded flavor, stone fruits (1), agave, spice, and oak. It is very light and smooth. It is not so aromatic but has a very entertaining palate.
7. Don Julio 1942
Average Price: Roughly at $144.99 /750ml (Total Wine)
Distillery: Tequila Don Julio
Alcohol Proof: 80 proof
Why We Liked It:
Don Julio 1942 is a premium tequila aged for two and a half years. This bottle was concocted as a tribute to the year Don Julio began his tequila-making venture.
We love the scent of enticing rich vanilla with baked caramelized agave. The palate has additional hints of nougat and caramel.
You’ll enjoy round, rich, balanced flavors with a clean lingering finish with this tequila. Check out Don Julio 1942 vs Clase Azul here.
6. Patrón Reposado Tequila
Average Price: Roughly at $46.99 / 750ml (Total Wine)
Distillery: Hacienda Patrón Distillery
Alcohol Proof: 80 proof
Why We Liked It:
This reposado from Patron has its usual smooth and light freshness.
But what is worth noticing in this variant is the raw agave taste that provides the grassy and earthy notes.
The presence of the piña fruit is notable, to the nose and the palate, almost like a Blanco.
However, the strong oak, citrus, sweetness of honey, and smoothness verify that it is aged. But what’s the best Patron tequila?
5. Kirkland Signature Silver Tequila
Average Price: Roughly at $24.99 /1.75L (Total Wine)
Distillery: Corporate Distillery Santa Lucia
Alcohol Proof: 80 proof
Why We Liked It:
We liked that it is affordable, clean, and pure agave. The signature brand of Costco created a good bottle of Blanco with a real-tasting Mexican tequila.
The agave taste is paired with apple, citrus, and a bit of pear. The scent of alcohol goes very well with the agave smell. More on who makes Kirkland Tequila here.
Read: Kirkland Silver Tequila vs Other Tequilas
4. Don Pilar Anejo Tequila
Average Price: Roughly at $39.99 /750ml (Total Wine)
Distillery: Tequila Don Pilar
Alcohol Proof: 80 proof
Why We Liked It:
What we like about Don Pilar Añejo is the sweetness that reminds us of bourbon.
It also has the kind of smoothness that feels more like an extra añejo, making it very enjoyable to sip and drink neat.
The cooked agave flavor with caramel, oak, citrus, vanilla, and almond makes this bottle special. Plus, it also has a long sweet oaky finish.
3. Don Pilar Extra Anejo Tequila
Average Price: Roughly at $159.99 /750ml (Total Wine)
Distillery: Tequila Don Pilar
Alcohol Proof: 80 proof
Why We Liked It:
We already loved its añejo variant. Why wouldn’t we recommend its older brother?
This variant is aged for at least three years, and this expression has a defined oak flavor.
It blends perfectly with vanilla and butterscotch and the agave taste. It has a rather oily texture but a smooth and light body, making it fit for sipping.
Read: Top Tequilas Under $50
2. San Matias Reposado
Average Price: Roughly at $15.99 /750ml (Drizly)
Distillery: Casa San Matías
Alcohol Proof: 80 proof
Why We Liked It:
First, we liked its price because it is affordable. But what we loved more about this bottle was its surprisingly round and full taste.
The aroma introduces a prominent agave and citrus scent.
The palate is greeted with a blend of sweet and spicy flavors of chocolate, caramel, allspice, and pepper. The texture is very smooth and very creamy to the mouth, too.
1. Herradura Reposado Tequila
Average Price: Roughly at $36.99 /750ml (Total Wine)
Distillery: Grupo Industrial Herradura
Alcohol Proof: 80 proof
Why We Liked It:
Herradura tequila starts with an aromatic scent of agave with citrus and vanilla, which is very welcoming to the senses.
The initial taste is a bit dry, but it holds a nice surprise.
It transitions to fruity, citrusy, and sweet flavors with just enough acidity (2) and bite, plus it leaves a butterscotch aftertaste.
Other Tequila Brands At Costco
- Kirkland Signature Anejo – roughly $46.68/1L
- Jose Cuervo – roughly $17.99/750ml
- Sesion Blanco – roughly $37.99/750ml
- Casamigos Añejo – roughly $61.99/750ml
- Don Julio Blanco – roughly $46.99/750ml
Disclaimer: Average prices are based on Total Wine and Drizly online. Prices may vary in various Costco locations and local liquor shops.
FAQs
Do all Costco stores have the same tequila selection?
No, not all Costco stores have the same tequila selection. The store’s distance from the warehouse is one of the reasons why some bottles are not sold at a specific location.
Also, there are some local Costcos that are prohibited by law from selling liquors since it is not allowed in groceries in some states.
Does Costco deliver tequila to your home?
Yes, Costco delivers tequila to your home. You can visit their website and inquire about the availability and possibilities of home deliveries.
Final Thoughts
Herradura Reposado Tequila is the best tequila at Costco based on our blind testing. The flavor doesn’t come in short, and the quality is not far from that of expensive premium tequilas.
It is very smooth, which is great for sipping, but it also adds flavor to margaritas. It elevates the cocktail as it heightens the aroma with its agave scent.
The best tequilas at Cosco are the same tequilas enjoyed by many tequila lovers. A big advantage is that these are sold much lower than liquor stores, as Costco always offers good deals.
References:
- https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/agricultural-and-biological-sciences/stone-fruits
- https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0166983400825592
Lisa is a freelance lifestyle writer specializing in nightlife, leisure, and celebration. She has been in the field for eight years and has written articles featured in various local blogs and lifestyle magazines.
For Lisa, there’s nothing better than an ice-cold drink after a rough day (she’s not fussy). But she also likes to get a bit fancy every now and then. She believes you can never go wrong with a Moscow Mule or a classic Daiquiri anywhere you go. Contact at [email protected] or learn more about us here.
Can I find a tequila at Costco on Churchill in Dallas?