Liquor Laboratory

7 Best Tequilas for Jello Shots: Party-Perfect Choices (2023)

Best Tequila For Jello Shots

Last Updated on September 22, 2023 by Lydia Martin

As you gear up your shot glasses for summer parties and festive gatherings, the quest for the perfect tequila to elevate your gelatin creations takes center stage!

So, to discover the best tequila for Jello Shots to rock your next party, I have conducted a spirited experiment with various tequila brands.

Here are my top picks to craft those colorful and unforgettable jiggly delights.

Top 7 Tequilas To Make Tequila Jello Shot Recipe

1. 1800 Silver Tequila

Person Holding Bottle of 1800 Silver Tequila

Average Price: approx. $37 (company website) 

Alcohol Content: 40% ABV

Nose: Robust agave aroma, with fruity and black pepper notes

Palate: Sweet with a slightly citrus taste and gentle peppery finish

Star Rating: ★★★★★

Why We Like It: 1800 Silver stands out for its approachable flavor, making it a good choice for those new to Tequila Jello Shots.  

“Gummy bears go well with Jello, and if you soak your bears in spirits before adding them to the Jello Shot molds, you’ll add an extra kick to your Shots.” – Taylor Tobin, Journalist

I like using this spirit in a classic Margarita mix because of its approachable smoothness. So, when I use it for a Tequila Jello Shot, I would go for the Margarita Jello Shot with lime jello, Margarita salt, and lime juice. But how many jello shots will get you drunk?

2. Espolon Blanco

Bottle of Espolon Blanco

Average Price: approx. $30 (Drizly) 

Alcohol Content: 40% ABV

Nose: Sweet agave, light citrus, vanilla, and herbal aroma 

Palate: Light peppery taste with mild alcohol and light citrus hints

Star Rating: ★★★★★

Why We Like It: I appreciate Espolon for its affordability, availability, and versatility. It’s a very easy drink with no intense flavors, but it’s more interesting as a mixer than a sipper.

It creates a harmonious blend with a Jello mix (or Margarita mix). Besides, it’s available almost anywhere, perfect for a last-minute party spirit recipe.

Read: Our Favorite Chasers For Casamigos Tequila

3. Patron Silver

Man Holding Bottle of Patron Silver

Average Price: approx. $53 (Drizly) 

Alcohol Content: 40% ABV

Nose: Bright agave and clean citrus aroma

Palate: Smooth and clean taste with black pepper, agave, and cinnamon notes

Star Rating: ★★★★★

Why We Like It: Now, I know Patron is an expensive tequila, but if you’re into higher-end tequilas for your colored Jello Shot, it is among the cheapest choices to stir in. 

I only recommend it if you make Tequila Jello Shots for yourself or special gatherings. It adds a sophisticated agave touch to the Jello mixture, or Margarita mix recipe.

4. Agavales Blanco

Bottle and a Glass of Agavales Blanco

Average Price: approx. $18 (Drizly) 

Alcohol Content: 40% ABV

Nose: Fresh agave, apple, grass, and black pepper 

Palate: Bitter with some agave, roasted nuts, and a hot finish 

Star Rating: ★★★★

Why We Like It: Agavales Blanco is an affordable option for crafting Tequila Jello Shots. It has no offensive flavors, so if you sip it straight, you will only have a bland drink. 

However, it’s a good mixer for a Jello Shot recipe, incorporating a subtle kick to your cocktail.

Read: Best Vodka For Jello Shots

5. El Jimador Silver

Hand Holding Bottle of El Jimador Silver

Average Price: approx. $24 (Drizly) 

Alcohol Content: 40% ABV

Nose: Roasted agave aroma, mint, and slightly herbal notes

Palate: Prominent agave taste, with subtle black pepper and herbal hints

Star Rating: ★★★★

Why We Like It: El Jimador Silver is another smooth but budget-friendly option to make the best Tequila Jello Shots. 

It brings a fresh and straightforward agave taste that complements the fruity flavors of this cocktail recipe.

6. Olmeca Altos Plata

Bottle of Tequila Olmeca Altos Plata

Average Price: approx. $31 (Drizly) 

Alcohol Content: 40% ABV

Nose: Subtle floral and citrus aroma with cooked agave notes 

Palate: Medium-bodied with clean agave and peppery taste

Star Rating: ★★★★

Why We Like It: Olmeca Altos Plata is blanco or white tequila that works well in a Margarita mix.

While some well-known party beverages may fall short, Shots deliver on both taste and the enjoyable buzz!” – Liquor Laboratory

It provides the same effects in Tequila Jello Shots, incorporating a vibrant agave and peppery flavor, perfect for a fun-filled gathering filled with shots. But how long are jello shots good for?

7. Jose Cuervo Especial Silver

Bottle of Jose Cuervo Especial Silver on the Table

Average Price: approx. $27 (1L on Drizly) 

Alcohol Content: 40% ABV

Nose: Little herbaceous aroma, with a persistent smell of nail polish remover

Palate: Little black pepper, vanilla, and artificial sweetness and bitterness 

Star Rating: ★★★

Why We Like It: I would not recommend taking this one straight, but this product is quite a decent mixer to stir in for Tequila Jello Shots.

It is a mixto that only has at least 51% agave in the blend, resulting in flavors that taste artificial.

So, if you plan to craft affordable Tequila Jello Shots, this one is among the ultimate budget-friendly options.

*Note: Average prices are based on Drizly and the official product websites. The star rating was determined based on a blind test, with 1 being the lowest and 5 being the highest. Each product was evaluated on its overall quality, flavor profile, complexity, smoothness, and overall enjoyment.

FAQs

What is the best liquor to use for Jello Shots?

Tequilas and vodkas are the best liquors to use to make Jello Shots. But you can also go for other spirits like whiskey or cognac.

Keep a 1:1 ratio for liquor and gelatin; stir one part for cold water and two parts for boiling water to ensure a balanced flavor and Jello that sets easily [1].

Are Jello Shots better with vodka or tequila?

Both vodka and tequila are good liquor bases for Jello Shots. Vodka is the most commonly used for this recipe; others also use flavored vodkas to achieve their desired flavor [2]

But you can also use tequila with a Margarita mix to craft a delicious Jello Margarita version. 

How long are Tequila Jello Shots good for?

Tequila Jello Shots can stay good for seven to ten days if stored in a covered container inside the fridge. The fridge is also ideal for setting the gelatin instead of the freezer.

Carefully pour the mix into shot glasses or small plastic cups, then use the baking tray for easier access.

What tequila type is best for Jello Shots?

The best tequilas for Jello Shots are the Silver or Blanco tequilas. It is the equivalent of vodka with the same clear, almost flavorless, and unaged flavor profile. 

Key Takeaways

The best Tequila Jello Shots do not require expensive spirits to make the recipe delicious and appealing. You can make Tequila Jello Shots in easy steps. The prep time is around 20 minutes, and the process takes over two hours.

First, refrigerate the combined tequila and cold water in a large bowl. Then, in another bowl, stir the gelatin powder and boiling water. You can also use a Margarita mix. 

Combine all the ingredients, and add food coloring if desired. Carefully pour the mixture into small plastic cups or shot glasses, but leave a little room for the Margarita salt and lime wedge.

Put them in the fridge to set, then enjoy your delicious boozy treats.

References:

  1. https://www.insider.com/guides/kitchen/Jello-shots
  2. https://www.thrillist.com/culture/everything-you-need-to-know-about-Jello-shots
Lumint ad Side Bar
Flex Ad Side Bar