What Bourbon Is Similar to Bulleit? High-Rye Bourbons to Try

Updated November 2026

The bourbons most similar to Bulleit are other high-rye Kentucky straight bourbons: Four Roses Small Batch, Old Grand-Dad, Basil Hayden and Old Forester 86 Proof. Bulleit Bourbon is 90 proof (45% ABV) and is widely reported to use a mash bill of 68% corn, 28% rye and 4% malted barley, so look for a rye share in the high teens to mid thirties and a proof between about 80 and 100. Old Grand-Dad Bonded (100 proof) or Old Grand-Dad 114 is the pick if you want the same spice with more strength.

This guide explains what makes Bulleit taste the way it does, then compares bottles with a similar grain recipe using proofs from brand pages and state liquor board listings. It is a style match, not a ranking.

What makes Bulleit taste like Bulleit

Bulleit describes its bourbon as having “a bold, spicy character” thanks to an “especially high rye content.” The brand’s own tasting notes call it “smokey and woody on the nose with a hint of spice,” with “tones of maple, oak and nutmeg with a light toffee flavour” and “a distinctively clean and smooth finish.”

The key number is rye. Tasting Table notes that many standard bourbons use roughly 15% to 20% rye; Bulleit’s reported 28% sits well above that, which is where the pepper and baking-spice notes come from. Difford’s Guide lists the same 68/28/4 recipe. Bulleit’s current US bottling of its flagship bourbon carries 45% Alc/Vol on the label, and US retail listings show it as 90 proof.

Like every bourbon on this page, Bulleit has to meet the federal standard in 27 CFR § 5.143: at least 51% corn, distilled at no more than 160 proof, entered into new charred oak containers at no more than 125 proof. “Straight” bourbon must also be aged at least two years. Those rules set the baseline; the rye share, yeast and barrel entry proof are what separate one high-rye bourbon from another. For a refresher on the terms, see what is straight bourbon and what are the 5 keys of bourbon.

Bourbons with a similar high-rye profile

Four Roses Small Batch

Four Roses is the closest family resemblance. Bulleit was long distilled at Four Roses before Diageo built its own distillery, and Four Roses still uses a high-rye mash bill. Four Roses runs two mash bills: OB at 60% corn, 35% rye and 5% malted barley, and OE at 75% corn, 20% rye and 5% malted barley (VinePair). Small Batch blends four recipes (OBSO, OBSK, OESK and OESO) and is 90 proof, the same strength as Bulleit, per the Iowa Alcoholic Beverages Division listing. If you want to explore the range, see our guide to the best Four Roses bourbon.

Old Grand-Dad

Old Grand-Dad, made by Beam, uses a rye share VinePair puts at 27%, almost exactly Bulleit’s. Beam describes the flagship as “medium-bodied” with sweet vanilla and a “peppery spiciness” from clove and cinnamon, and a “long and very spicy” finish. The standard bottling is 80 proof. Old Grand-Dad Bonded is 100 proof and must meet the bottled-in-bond rules (one distiller, one distillation season, at least four years in a bonded warehouse). Old Grand-Dad 114 is 114 proof (57% ABV), per Virginia ABC, which describes prominent rye spice, dark fruit and a long, peppery finish. Since Beam makes it, our explainer on whether Jim Beam is whiskey or bourbon covers the producer.

Basil Hayden

Basil Hayden shares Old Grand-Dad’s high-rye mash bill, which Tasting Table lists as 63% corn, 27% rye and 10% malted barley. Virginia ABC lists it at 80 proof and notes that its higher rye content gives it a spicy, sweet flavor. It is the gentlest bottle in this group: the same spice family as Bulleit, at a lower strength.

Old Forester 86 Proof

Old Forester sits at the lower end of high rye. Difford’s Guide reports a mash bill believed to be 72% corn, 18% rye and 10% malted barley, from the same Brown-Forman distillery that supplies much of the whiskey in Woodford Reserve. The brand’s notes describe citrus, tropical fruit and delicate florals on the nose, with citrus zest, ripe pear, fresh mint and clove on the palate. It is 86 proof. If Old Forester appeals to you, our guide to what bourbon is similar to Woodford Reserve covers its close relative.

Bourbons that are not a close match

Wheated bourbons such as Maker’s Mark replace rye with wheat as the flavoring grain, so they taste softer and sweeter than Bulleit. They are a good choice if you find Bulleit too spicy; see what bourbon is similar to Maker’s Mark. Finished bourbons such as Angel’s Envy spend extra time in wine casks after aging, which adds fruit that Bulleit does not have; see what bourbon is similar to Angel’s Envy. Buffalo Trace is a common everyday alternative, but its producer does not market it as a high-rye bourbon, so expect a different balance. Hard-to-find allocated bottles on our rare bourbons list are rarely a practical stand-in.

How to choose a Bulleit substitute

  • Same strength, same spice: Four Roses Small Batch (90 proof).
  • More strength: Old Grand-Dad Bonded (100 proof) or Old Grand-Dad 114.
  • Lighter and easier sipping: Basil Hayden (80 proof).
  • Fruitier, less peppery: Old Forester 86 Proof.

Check the label before you buy, since proofs and line-ups change. For mixing, high-rye bourbon is a natural fit in a Manhattan or Old Fashioned; see our Bulleit bourbon cocktails and the best bourbon for a Manhattan. For a broader view of the category, browse our bourbon brands guide, single barrel bourbons and the Bourbon Guide.

Frequently asked questions

What proof is Bulleit Bourbon?

Bulleit Bourbon is 90 proof, or 45% ABV, as printed on the brand’s label.

What is Bulleit’s mash bill?

Bulleit’s brand page describes a “unique blend of rye, corn, and barley malt” without percentages. Difford’s Guide and Wikipedia report 68% corn, 28% rye and 4% malted barley.

Is Four Roses the same as Bulleit?

No. Four Roses distilled Bulleit for many years, but they are separate brands. Diageo opened a Bulleit distillery in Shelbyville, Kentucky, on March 14, 2017, and Four Roses uses its own two mash bills and ten recipes.

Is Basil Hayden similar to Bulleit?

Yes in style. Both are high-rye bourbons with about 27% to 28% rye, but Basil Hayden is bottled at 80 proof, so it tastes lighter than 90 proof Bulleit.

Is Bulleit a good bourbon for cocktails?

Its rye spice holds up well against sweet vermouth and bitters, which is why high-rye bourbons are a common choice for stirred drinks.

Sources

  • Bulleit, Bulleit Bourbon product page (45% Alc/Vol, brand tasting notes, high rye).
  • Difford’s Guide, Bulleit Kentucky Straight Bourbon (45%, 68/28/4 mash bill); Old Forester (86 proof, 72/18/10 mash bill).
  • Wikipedia, Bulleit Bourbon (1987 first distillation by Tom Bulleit, Shelbyville distillery opened March 14, 2017, mash bill).
  • VinePair, Four Roses recipe guide (OB and OE mash bills); Old Grand-Dad guide (27% rye, shared with Basil Hayden, 80, 100 and 114 proof).
  • Iowa Alcoholic Beverages Division, Four Roses Small Batch 750 ml (90 proof, OBSO, OBSK, OESK, OESO).
  • Beam Distilling, Old Grand-Dad and Old Grand-Dad Bottled in Bond (80 and 100 proof, tasting notes).
  • Virginia ABC, Old Grand-Dad 114 (114 proof); Basil Hayden Bourbon (80 proof).
  • Tasting Table, Basil Hayden bottle guide (63/27/10 mash bill).
  • Old Forester, 86 Proof product page (tasting notes).
  • 27 CFR § 5.143, Whisky (eCFR); 27 CFR § 5.88, Bottled in bond.

Leave a Comment