Liquor Laboratory

ll logo white
ll logo white

Can You Put Whiskey in Eggnog? Let’s Find Out (2024 Best Edition)

can you put whiskey in eggnog

Last Updated on March 27, 2024 by Lydia Martin

Eggnog is a classic and well-loved beverage always present during Christmas and other festivities. There can be countless eggnog recipes on the internet, but can you put whiskey in eggnog? 

Will the whiskey-eggnog recipe work, or will it be a waste? Let’s have a closer look. 

Does Whiskey Work With Eggnog? 

Bushmills Irish Whiskey

Whiskey surprisingly works with eggnog. Eggnog is a classic drink often served in holiday festivities, and most people with a sweet tooth would love it. It is made from cream or milk, vanilla, eggs, cinnamon stick, freshly grated nutmeg, and powdered sugar. 

When homemade eggnog is mixed with whiskey, it will create a creamy, bitter, and sweet drink you can do in mere minutes. Since it is a versatile cocktail, you can use different whiskeys like rye, Irish, bourbon, and Scotch. 

Whiskey Types That Work With Eggnog 

Whiskey Types That Work With Eggnog 

Rye Whiskey

Sagamore Spirit Rye Whiskey

Rye whiskeys can be spicy because of the high rye content, but it gives a savory flavor to your homemade eggnog. It is peppery, grassy, more aggressive, and has a signature spicy finish that mixes great with cream. 

It cuts the sweet taste of the drink and gives it a little kick that you cannot find in traditional eggnog. 

Irish Whiskey

Irish whiskey can be your go-to option if you want a whiskey-eggnog that is easy to drink. Irish whiskey tastes light, fruity, and cleaner than other liquor types, so it will surely blend well with sugar, milk, cinnamon, and of course, egg.  

Its sophisticated profile will cut through the sweetness of the cocktail drink and very ideal for chill nights. 

Read: Was Mountain Dew Made For Whiskeys?

Bourbon Whiskey 

Bourbon Whiskey

Bourbons are sweeter than other whiskeys because they should contain at least 51% corn on their mash bill [1]. Its profile is rich in vanilla, honey, caramel, malt, and oak, so it is no surprise that it will be a great combination for the recipe.

Read: Recommended Alcoholic Eggnog Brands

Scotch Whisky

Scotch whisky gives a lot of kick to cocktails because of the flavor profile of the alcohol. The strong smokey flavors and hardy bite of Scotch whisky dominate the creamy taste of the delicious cocktail. 

If you are into cocktail recipes with strong booze, a bottle of Scotch is a great choice. 

The Best Eggnog & Whiskey Cocktail Recipe

The Best Eggnog & Whiskey Cocktail Recipe

Prep Time: 30 minutes

Total Time: 30 minutes


  • 4 eggs (large)
  • ¾ cup powdered sugar
  • 1 tsp freshly grated nutmeg
  • ½ tsp ground cinnamon
  • ⅛ tsp ground allspice
  • ⅛ tsp ground cloves
  • 4 oz whiskey
  • 2 oz cognac, brandy, or rum
  • 2 oz orange or vanilla liqueur
  • 12 oz whole milk
  • 8 oz heavy cream
  • Ice
  • Fresh nutmeg for garnish 


Beat the eggs in a blender for a minute, slowly add the sugar, allspice, cloves, and cinnamon, then blend for another minute. Keep the blender on, then add nutmeg, whiskey, cognac, milk, and cream until incorporated. 

Pour the mixture into a bowl and cover it before placing it in the refrigerator for chilling. Serve in a wine glass with ice, and put nutmeg on top of each glass. 

Serving: 8

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How much whiskey do you put in eggnog?

In a 4 oz eggnog cocktail, you can use half an ounce of whiskey. A nearly half a shot of the distilled spirit can make the drink boozy but enjoyable. Some whiskeys are sharp and strong, which greatly balances the drink’s sweetness. 

What is eggnog with bourbon whiskey called?

Eggnog with bourbon whiskey is called bourbon eggnog. It is a sweet and classic cocktail with the right spice and warmth level that you can indulge in any festivities. 

Does whiskey go well with eggnog?

Yes, whiskey pairs exceptionally well with eggnog, creating a delightful and classic holiday drink. The rich, creamy texture of eggnog complements the robust and complex flavors of whiskey, resulting in a harmonious combination that many people enjoy during festive seasons.

What is the best alcohol to put in eggnog?

While whiskey is a popular choice, other spirits like rum and brandy are also excellent options for enhancing the flavor of eggnog. Each spirit adds its unique twist, with rum providing a sweet and spiced character, brandy contributing a fruity note, and whiskey imparting a robust and warming quality. The best choice ultimately depends on personal preference.

Does eggnog with whiskey go bad?

Eggnog with whiskey can go bad if not stored properly. Both the dairy in the eggnog and the alcohol in the whiskey act as preservatives, but it’s crucial to refrigerate the mixture and consume it within a reasonable timeframe, typically within a few days. Pay attention to any changes in odor or appearance, as spoilage may occur, especially if the eggnog is left at room temperature for an extended period.

Is eggnog made from Whisky?

Traditional eggnog recipes do not necessarily include whiskey, but adding whiskey is a popular variation. Eggnog is a creamy holiday beverage made from a mixture of eggs, sugar, milk, cream, and spices like nutmeg or cinnamon. Whiskey, along with other spirits like rum or brandy, is often added to enhance the flavor and create a spirited version of this festive drink.

What Whisky is best for eggnog?

The best whiskey for eggnog depends on personal taste preferences, but generally, a bourbon or a blended whiskey works well. Bourbons, with their sweeter and full-bodied profiles, can complement the richness of eggnog. Additionally, a smooth blended whiskey can provide a balanced and mellow flavor. Popular choices include brands like Maker’s Mark, Buffalo Trace, or Jameson, but experimenting with different whiskies allows you to tailor the eggnog to your liking. It’s advisable to choose a whiskey that harmonizes with the creamy sweetness of the eggnog without overpowering the overall flavor.

Does eggnog taste better with alcohol?

The addition of alcohol to eggnog is subjective, but for many, it enhances the overall flavor profile, providing a warming and complex character that complements the richness of the traditional holiday beverage. The alcohol can add depth, warmth, and a nuanced complexity that elevates the overall drinking experience.

Why do people put liquor in eggnog?

Adding liquor to eggnog is a long-standing tradition that enhances the drink’s flavor and creates a festive, spirited concoction. The alcohol, whether it’s whiskey, rum, brandy, or another spirit, introduces new dimensions of taste, contributing spiciness, sweetness, or fruity notes, depending on the chosen spirit. It transforms the creamy base into a more indulgent and celebratory holiday treat.

Does alcohol make eggnog last longer?

Alcohol can act as a preservative in eggnog, potentially extending its shelf life. The alcohol content inhibits the growth of bacteria and spoilage, providing some additional stability to the mixture. However, it’s crucial to refrigerate eggnog promptly and consume it within a reasonable timeframe to ensure both safety and optimal flavor.

Does eggnog curdle with alcohol?

While curdling can occur if certain conditions are not met, such as using a high-acid alcohol or adding alcohol to eggnog that is not fresh, it’s not a common issue with standard recipes. Using fresh ingredients, chilling the eggnog properly, and choosing compatible spirits typically prevents curdling. However, caution should be exercised to avoid introducing the alcohol too quickly or using excessively acidic spirits.

How long does eggnog whiskey last?

The shelf life of eggnog with whiskey depends on various factors, including the freshness of the ingredients and how well it’s stored. Generally, when properly refrigerated, eggnog with whiskey can last for a few days to a week. The alcohol in the whiskey acts as a preservative, but it’s essential to monitor for any signs of spoilage, such as changes in odor or appearance. Consuming it within a reasonable timeframe ensures the best quality and safety of the eggnog with whiskey.

How much alcohol does it take to preserve eggnog?

The addition of alcohol to eggnog contributes to its preservation, with the alcohol acting as a natural preservative by inhibiting bacterial growth. While there isn’t a specific quantity required for preservation, a typical guideline is to include at least 10-20% alcohol by volume in the eggnog recipe, ensuring both a pleasant taste and improved shelf life.

How long is eggnog safe?

The safety of eggnog hinges on proper handling and storage. If prepared with fresh ingredients and promptly refrigerated, traditional eggnog without alcohol remains safe for consumption for about 3 to 5 days. When alcohol is added, the preservative properties can extend the shelf life slightly, allowing it to be enjoyed safely for up to a week or a bit longer. It’s crucial to monitor for any signs of spoilage, such as an off odor or changes in appearance, and discard if doubts arise about its safety.

What pairs with eggnog?

Eggnog is a versatile drink that pairs well with a variety of flavors, enhancing its festive and creamy profile. Some delightful pairings include:

Spices: Sprinkling a touch of nutmeg, cinnamon, or even a hint of cloves on top of eggnog complements its inherent spiced notes, creating a harmonious blend of flavors.

Chocolate: Whether in the form of chocolate shavings, cocoa powder, or a drizzle of chocolate syrup, chocolate adds a decadent richness that pairs wonderfully with the sweetness of eggnog.

Coffee or Espresso: Combining eggnog with coffee or espresso results in a comforting and indulgent beverage, blending the robust flavors of coffee with the creamy sweetness of eggnog.

Nuts: Garnishing eggnog with chopped nuts, such as pecans or almonds, introduces a delightful crunch and nutty undertones, adding texture to the velvety drink.

Whipped Cream: A dollop of whipped cream on top of eggnog contributes to its luxurious texture, creating a heavenly combination of lightness and richness.

Caramel or Butterscotch: Drizzling eggnog with caramel or butterscotch sauce adds a sweet and buttery flavor, elevating the overall taste experience with a touch of indulgence.

So, Can You Put Whiskey in Eggnog? 

You can put whiskey in eggnog, and it’ll taste surprisingly delicious! The warmth and kick of whiskeys complement well with the sweetness and creaminess of eggnog. Whiskey-eggnog is versatile, so you can use rye, bourbon, Irish or Scotch whisky for the recipe. 

Have you tried whiskey in eggnog? How is it? Let us know by commenting down below. 


5 Rules That Make It Bourbon

Lumint ad Side Bar
Flex Ad Side Bar