Updated November 2026
Dalmore 12 and Macallan 12 are both 12-year-old single malt Scotch whiskies, but they reach sherry in different ways. Dalmore 12 spends its first years in ex-bourbon American oak, then part of it is finished in oloroso sherry casks, and it is bottled at 40% ABV (80 proof) in the US. Macallan 12 Sherry Oak matures entirely in sherry-seasoned oak casks from Jerez and is bottled at 43% ABV (86 proof) in the US. Pick Dalmore for orange, chocolate and coffee; pick Macallan Sherry Oak for dried fruit, toffee and a firmer, spicier sherry profile.
Both lean on sherry casks, which is why shoppers compare them. The differences come from geography, wood and strength.
Dalmore 12 vs Macallan 12 at a glance
| Feature | The Dalmore 12 | The Macallan 12 Sherry Oak |
|---|---|---|
| Region | Northern Highlands (Alness, Ross-shire) | Speyside (Easter Elchies, near Craigellachie) |
| Owner | Whyte and Mackay (part of Emperador) | Edrington |
| Founded | 1839 | 1824 |
| Casks | Ex-bourbon American white oak, then part finished in 30-year-old Matusalem oloroso sherry butts | Sherry-seasoned oak casks from Jerez for the full maturation |
| US strength | 40% ABV, 80 proof | 43% ABV, 86 proof |
| Age statement | 12 years (youngest whisky in the bottle) | 12 years (youngest whisky in the bottle) |
| Brand flavor cues | Citrus, chocolate, Seville orange, coffee | Vanilla, ginger, dried fruit, wood smoke, toffee |
The Dalmore 12: bourbon oak first, sherry second
The Dalmore distillery stands at Alness, Ross-shire, in the northern Highlands. Alexander Matheson founded it in 1839, the Mackenzie family ran it from the late 1800s, and Whyte and Mackay has owned it since 1960. Emperador Distillers has owned Whyte and Mackay since 2014. Its onion-shaped spirit stills carry a water cooler on the neck, which pushes vapor back down into the still (reflux).
According to US retail listings that carry the brand’s description, Dalmore 12 first matures in American white oak ex-bourbon casks, which give vanilla and honey. Spec’s describes a split: roughly nine years in bourbon wood, after which half the whisky moves into 30-year-old Matusalem oloroso sherry butts from Gonzalez Byass while the other half stays in bourbon casks, and the two are married before bottling. Target and Spec’s both list the US bottle at 40% ABV, 80 proof.
The brand describes the nose as citrus fruits, chocolate and aromatic spices; the palate as Seville oranges, dried fruits and hints of vanilla pod; and the finish as roasted coffee and dark chocolate. If you like a dessert-leaning single malt with a strong orange note, this is the bottle the comparison favors. Read more in our Dalmore guide.
The Macallan 12: three different 12-year-olds
The Macallan sits on the Easter Elchies estate near Craigellachie in Speyside. Alexander Reid founded it in 1824, and Edrington owns it today. When people say “Macallan 12” they may mean one of three bottles, so check which one you are holding:
- Sherry Oak 12: the classic. It matures entirely in sherry-seasoned oak casks from Jerez. The North Carolina ABC Commission lists the 750 ml bottle at 86 proof.
- Double Cask 12: on shelves since 2016, it combines sherry-seasoned American oak with sherry-seasoned European oak. North Carolina ABC also lists it at 86 proof. The producer describes creamy butterscotch, toffee apple, candied orange and vanilla custard on the nose, honey, wood spice and citrus on the palate, and an oaky, warm, drying finish.
- Triple Cask Matured 12: the 2018 rename of the former Fine Oak range, built from three cask types rather than sherry oak alone.
For Sherry Oak 12, Macallan’s producer notes describe a nose of vanilla with hints of ginger, dried fruits, sherry sweetness and wood smoke; a smooth palate of rich dried fruits and sherry with wood smoke and spice; and a finish of sweet toffee, dried fruits, lingering wood smoke and spice. Our Macallan hub covers the rest of the range, and how to drink Macallan covers serving.
How they taste side by side
The biggest difference is the wood path. Dalmore builds a bourbon-cask base of vanilla and honey and then adds sherry character late, so the orange and chocolate notes sit on top of a soft, sweet core. Macallan Sherry Oak never sees ex-bourbon wood, so the sherry influence runs through the whole whisky: more dried fruit, more spice and more of the wood-smoke note the producer calls out.
Strength matters too. At 43%, Macallan Sherry Oak and Double Cask carry a little more weight and heat than Dalmore at 40%. A few drops of water soften either one.
Which one should you buy?
- Choose Dalmore 12 if you like orange, chocolate and coffee notes, a softer 40% pour, and a whisky that drinks like a digestif.
- Choose Macallan 12 Sherry Oak if you want the full sherry-cask profile with dried fruit, spice and toffee at 43%.
- Choose Macallan 12 Double Cask if you want sherry influence with more honey and vanilla from American oak.
- Want peat smoke? Neither is an Islay-style whisky; see our best single malt Scotch guide.
- New to Scotch? Either works neat with a splash of water. Our best Scotch for beginners list gives more starting points, and Glenlivet vs Macallan compares Macallan with another Speyside staple.
What “12 year single malt” means on both labels
Under the Scotch Whisky Regulations 2009, regulation 3, a Single Malt Scotch Whisky must be made at a single distillery from only water and malted barley, by batch distillation in pot stills, and matured in Scotland in oak casks of no more than 700 litres for at least three years. The Scotch Whisky Association’s guidance notes that the only age a label may state is the age of the youngest whisky in the bottle (regulation 12), and that plain caramel coloring (E150a) is the only coloring permitted. Learn more in our explainer on single malt.
US labeling follows the same logic. Under 27 CFR § 5.74, when a batch blends barrels of different ages, “the label may only state the age of the youngest spirits.” So every drop in both bottles is at least 12 years old. Under 27 CFR § 5.143, Scotch whisky sold in the US must be a distinctive product of Scotland made in compliance with UK law.
Pour math: standard drinks
A US standard drink contains 14 grams of alcohol, which equals 1.5 oz of 40% spirit. A 1.5 oz pour of Dalmore 12 at 40% is one standard drink. The same pour of Macallan 12 at 43% is about 1.08 standard drinks (1.5 × 0.43 = 0.645 oz of alcohol, divided by 0.6). A 750 ml bottle holds about 17 standard drinks at 40% and about 18 at 43%. See whiskey drinks and pour math for more, and the Whiskey Guide for the wider category.
FAQ
Is Dalmore 12 better than Macallan 12?
Neither is objectively better. Dalmore 12 leans toward orange, chocolate and coffee at 40%; Macallan 12 Sherry Oak leans toward dried fruit, spice and toffee at 43%. Choose by the flavor you prefer.
Is Dalmore 12 a sherry-cask whisky?
Partly. It begins in ex-bourbon American oak, and a portion is then finished in Matusalem oloroso sherry butts before the whisky is married. Dalmore also sells a separate 12-year Sherry Cask bottling, so check the label.
Which Macallan 12 is the closest match to Dalmore 12?
Double Cask 12 is the closest, because its American oak casks add vanilla and honey alongside the sherry, much like Dalmore’s bourbon-cask base.
What proof are they in the US?
Dalmore 12 is 80 proof (40% ABV). Macallan 12 Sherry Oak and Double Cask are 86 proof (43% ABV). Bottles from other markets can differ, so read the label.
Sources
- Target, The Dalmore 12 Year Scotch Whisky 750 ml listing (40% ABV, 80 proof; cask description and brand tasting notes).
- Spec’s, Dalmore 12 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky listing (40% ABV; cask split and Matusalem oloroso butts).
- North Carolina ABC Commission, The Macallan Sherry Oak 12Y and The Macallan Double Cask 12Y (86 proof, 750 ml).
- The Whisky Exchange, Macallan 12 Year Old Sherry Oak and Double Cask pages (producer’s tasting notes).
- The Whiskey Wash, The Macallan Double Cask 12 Year Old (October 2016; cask composition and producer notes).
- Scotchwhisky.com Whiskypedia, Dalmore distillery (founding, ownership, stills).
- Wikipedia, The Macallan distillery (location, founding, owner, ranges).
- Scotch Whisky Regulations 2009, regulations 3 and 12; Scotch Whisky Association, Guidance for Bottlers and Producers (2025).
- 27 CFR § 5.74 and 27 CFR § 5.143, eCFR.
- NIAAA, What is a standard drink.