Clicky

Jameson vs Jack Daniel’s Whiskey: Which is Better? (2022)

Last Updated on November 10, 2022 by Lydia Martin

When it comes to smooth whiskey, Jameson and Jack Daniel’s are famous names as they are known for being unmistakably smooth and mellow whiskeys. 

Going head to head, which one is the better and smoother whiskey?   

Let’s uncover their fair share of similarities and differences here in Jameson vs Jack Daniel’s and see which is the best bar-cart staple. 

Jack Daniel’s & Jameson Irish Whiskey Compared 

JACK DANIEL'S AND JAMESON BOTTLES

Jack Daniel’s and Jameson Irish Whiskey have different geographical origins and come from different whiskey categories.

Jack Daniel’s is a Tennessee whiskey, while Jameson is an Irish Whiskey. 

Their smoothness is lent by different procedures, as Jack Daniel’s uses charcoal filtration while Jameson undergoes triple distillation. 

Both are flagship distilled spirits, but Jameson’s bottle started to roll out in 1968, while Jack Daniel’s Old No. 7 was introduced in 1866. 

Head To Head Battle 

History & Origin

It was 1866 when Jack Daniel introduced Jack Daniel’s whiskey Old No. 7, to the world.

Jasper “Jack” Newton Daniel introduced the world to his signature charcoal-mellowed whiskey. 

1780 seen on the bottles of Jameson Irish, refers to the foundation of Bow Street Distillery founded by Jameson’s father-in-law, John Stein. 

The first bottle of Jameson Irish rolled out in 1968, and for two centuries, the whiskey was exclusively sold by the cask. 

Production & Distillation 

Jack Daniel’s uses a well-considered recipe of sour mash, 80% corn, 8% rye, and 12% barley, while Jameson Irish whiskey is made from both unmalted and malted barley. 

Jameson is a triple-distilled Irish whiskey in copper stills, while JD is distilled once, and then after being distilled at 140-proof, it undergoes sugar maple charcoal filtration that will take 3-5 days. 

“Charcoal can accomplish in days what the barrel takes a couple of years to accomplish,”

– Jeff Arnett, Master Distiller.  

Maturation & Age Statement

wood barrels

Both alcoholic beverages undergo aging as they will give the whiskey its flavor profile and nice color. 

Jameson whiskey is aged for at least four years in ex-bourbon casks and ex-sherry casks before being bottled at 80 proof. 

A flavorful, smooth, and budget whiskey is unmistakably Jack, aged in a new charred oak barrel before bottling at similar alcohol content (40% ABV – 80 proof). 

Irish Whiskey vs Tennessee Whiskey

Jack Daniel’s is not a bourbon whiskey, and even though it follows certain requirements to be labeled as bourbon, Jack Daniel’s chose to be labeled as a Tennessee whiskey. 

Tennessee whiskeys should be produced in Tennessee and contain at least 51% corn, like bourbon [1].

Also, it should undergo charcoal filtering or Lincoln County Process [2]. 

On the other hand, Irish whiskey should be made in Ireland and aged for at least three years in wooden casks.

It is typically triple distilled for a smooth taste and is best to drink neat. 

Tasting Notes 

old woman drinking whiskey

Jameson Irish Whiskey

Palate: Nice balance of nuts, spice, sweet sherry, ripe fruit, vanilla, caramel, 

Color/Hue: Rich deep amber

Nose: Caramel, floral, marmalade, sweet notes, peppered with spicy wood

Finish: Medium, caramel spice, and exceptional smoothness 

Jack Daniel’s Tennessee Whiskey

Palate: Caramel, vanilla, maple, sweet oak, char

Color/Hue: Warm amber

Nose: Banana, wood polish, and oak 

Finish: Black pepper, oak spice, citrus, sweet and smooth

Originating Region 

Jameson’s originating region is in Dublin City in Ireland, while JD’s originating region is in Lynchburg, Tennessee. 

Jack Daniel’s is America’s best-selling whiskey, and it should be made only in Tennessee to be considered a Tennessee whiskey. It is well-loved by many and a favorite drink of Frank Sinatra. 

On the other hand, Jameson whiskey originated in Ireland and is well-loved by many. You can drink Jameson neat or as a mixed drink like Irish coffee. 

Ownership & Distillery

Jack Daniels Old #7 Whiskey Bottle

Brown-Forman Corporation owns JD, and the production process of this good whiskey is made in Jack Daniel’s Distillery. It is believed to be the oldest registered distillery in the US. 

Pernod Ricard owns Jameson whiskey, and the Pernod Group has been part of the brand since 1988. You can find their distillery on Bow St in Dublin City, Ireland. 

Price & Value

JD is cheaper than Jameson whiskey. In the latest pricing of Drizly, JD’s costs around $26.49, while Jameson’s is roughly $30.99 per 750ml bottle. 

While they have slight differences in price points, both distilled beverages are well-lauded and recognized worldwide. 

Jack Daniel’s is one of the best-selling American whiskeys, while Jameson is the best-selling Irish whiskey. 

Their Similarities

Jameson Irish Whiskey on a wooden barrel

Blended

Jack Daniel’s and Jameson are blended distilled spirits with a nice flavor profile and exceptional smoothness. 

Unlike Scotch whisky, which is made from a single grain, Jameson and Jack Daniel’s are made from multiple grains and blended to achieve a consistent color and taste profile. 

Offers Several Flavored Spirits

As both spirits came from alcoholic beverage giants, it is not surprising that they offer several flavored spirits. 

Aside from the Flagship whiskey of Jameson, the brand offers Jameson Caskmates, Orange, Cold Brew, Black Barrel, IPA Edition, and Stout Edition (craft beer barrels) that you can drink neat or combined with ginger ale. 

Jack Daniel’s has a wide selection of flavored spirits like Tennessee Apple, Fire, Rye, Honey, and Cider. They also offer Single Barrels and Bottled-in-Bond bottlings.  

FAQs 

Which is smoother, Jameson or Jack Daniel’s Tennessee whiskey?

Jameson is smoother than Jack Daniel’s. While Jack Daniel’s is smooth and mellow, Jameson’s is remarkably smooth as it is thrice distilled. 

The extraordinary blended smoothness is the primary reason the brand remains the best-selling Irish whiskey today. 

Is Jack Daniel’s better in cocktails than Jameson?

Yes, Jack Daniel’s is better in cocktails than Jameson’s. It would be best to drink Jameson neat or on the rocks to taste more of its flavor profile. 

On the other hand, Jack Daniel’s has nice tasting notes that blend well with mixers like ginger ale, Coke, or bitters.

It can be a nice alternative to Jim Beam or rye and Scotch whiskies.   

Final Verdict

Jameson and Jack Daniel’s are best-selling distilled spirits because of their undeniable smoothness. 

However, after careful deliberation, expert voting, and blind tasting, Jameson is the better whiskey because of its sophisticated quality and versatility. 

We tried both spirits neat, on the rocks, and with mixers (Coke and ginger ale), and Jameson’s taste shines and stands out. 

While Jack Daniel’s is a good and budget-friendly option, Jameson’s smoothness and great-tasting profile are remarkable, well-loved, and lauded by many. 

Its premium ingredients, meticulous production process, and triple distillation make it one of the best-distilled spirits hard to pass up. 

References:

  1. https://www.cnbc.com/2015/06/04/5-rules-that-make-it-bourbon.html 
  2. https://www.britannica.com/story/the-story-of-nearest-green-americas-first-known-black-masterdistiller 

Leave a Comment