Updated November 2026
Kirkland Signature Hard Seltzer and White Claw Original are close matches on the numbers: both are 5% ABV with about 100 calories per 12 oz can, which is one US standard drink. The real differences are who makes them, the flavor lineup, where you can buy them and the base each brand uses. White Claw is made by Mark Anthony Brewing; Kirkland cartons have named contract producers, including Patco Brands and MPL Brands NV.
If you are standing in a Costco aisle deciding whether the house brand is a fair swap for the name brand, this page lays out what each can actually says, what the label rules require, and how the two compare on strength, calories, flavor and availability. For the full background on how these drinks are made, see our explainer on what alcohol is in hard seltzer.
Quick comparison
| Point | Kirkland Signature Hard Seltzer | White Claw Original |
|---|---|---|
| Alcohol | 5% ABV | 5% ABV |
| Calories per 12 oz | About 100 | 100 |
| Carbs per 12 oz | About 2 g (launch reports) | 2 g |
| Producer | Contract brewers named on cartons (Patco Brands; MPL Brands NV) | Mark Anthony Brewing |
| Where sold | Costco warehouses where state law allows | Most US beer retailers |
| Stronger version | None in the seltzer line | White Claw Surge, 8% ABV |
Strength and calories
When Kirkland Signature Hard Seltzer first appeared in Costco warehouses in September 2020, early reports put it at 5% alcohol, 100 calories and 2 grams of carbohydrate per can, sold in 24 can variety packs. A 2025 VinePair tasting of the current cartons also listed 5% and 100 calories. White Claw’s original hard seltzer is listed by retailers at 5% ABV, 100 calories and 2 grams of carbs per 12 oz can.
That means the two land on the same drink math. A 12 oz can at 5% holds 0.6 fl oz of pure alcohol, which is exactly one US standard drink as the NIAAA defines it (14 grams of alcohol, or 0.6 fl oz). Calories track alcohol closely in seltzers: 14 grams of alcohol at about 7 calories per gram is roughly 98 calories before you count any sugar.
The gap opens only if you reach for White Claw’s stronger line. White Claw Surge is listed at 8% ABV and 160 calories per 12 oz can, which is about 1.6 standard drinks per can. Kirkland does not sell an 8% seltzer, so if you compare a Surge to a Kirkland can you are not comparing like for like. Our guide to White Claw drinks walks through that math in more detail.
Who makes each one
White Claw launched in 2016 and is produced by Mark Anthony Brewing, part of the Mark Anthony Group. The US version is described by the brand as made from a gluten free alcohol base; for the details, see what alcohol is in White Claw.
Costco does not brew its own seltzer. Like most Kirkland Signature products, it is made under contract and sold under the store label. VinePair reported in 2025 that the cartons it bought named Patco Brands and MPL Brands NV, Inc., and that it was not clear which company made which flavor. Producers can change, so the name printed on your carton is the one that applies. We cover this in more depth in who makes Kirkland hard seltzer, and the same contract model applies to Kirkland beer.
Base, gluten and label rules
US hard seltzers are made in one of two ways: fermented sugar (often cane sugar) or a malt base made with malted barley and hops. Under 27 CFR § 7.1, a malt beverage is a fermented drink made at least partly from malted barley with hops, and those products need TTB label approval. Seltzers fermented from sugar are still taxed as beer but fall under FDA food labeling instead. Either way, every can sold in the US must carry the government health warning required by 27 CFR § 16.21.
Flavor matters for the rules too. Under 27 CFR § 25.15, flavors and other nonbeverage ingredients that contain alcohol can contribute no more than 49% of the alcohol in a finished malt beverage, so most of the alcohol has to come from fermentation.
White Claw’s US seltzer is sold as gluten free. VinePair described the Kirkland seltzer it tested as malt based and gluten free. Because producers and recipes can change, anyone who must avoid gluten should check the carton they buy rather than rely on a review.
Flavors
The Kirkland seltzer launched in 2020 with a four flavor variety pack: mango, grapefruit, black cherry and lime. The 2025 VinePair tasting listed raspberry, mango, lime and black cherry, so the lineup has shifted at least once. Kirkland sells its seltzer only as a mixed case, so you cannot buy a single flavor.
White Claw offers a far wider range, with several numbered variety packs, single flavor packs, the 8% Surge line and lower calorie options. In 2020 the brand also launched White Claw 70, a 3.7% ABV version with 70 calories and 0 grams of sugar per can, in pineapple and clementine. Availability of individual flavors varies by store.
Costco also added a separate Kirkland Signature Vodka + Soda in January 2025. It is a different product: a canned cocktail made with vodka rather than a fermented base, listed at 4.5% ABV and 100 calories in pineapple, peach and watermelon. If you want a spirit based can to compare with White Claw’s own vodka sodas, that is the one to look at. Our Vodka Guide explains the base spirit.
Which should you buy?
We do not pick a winner here, because the cans are so close on paper that the choice comes down to what you want:
- Buy Kirkland if you already shop at Costco, want a large mixed case and are happy with a short flavor list.
- Buy White Claw if you want a specific flavor, a single six pack, a stronger 8% can or a lower calorie option, or if you do not have a Costco membership.
- Compare other brands if neither suits you. Our Vizzy vs White Claw comparison and our guide to the best hard seltzer for your needs cover the other big names.
Not every Costco sells alcohol. State laws decide whether a warehouse can stock beer, and some states limit grocery and club store sales, so the seltzer is not available everywhere. For how seltzer stacks up against a regular lager, see hard seltzer vs beer, and for more on the category, our Beer Guide.
FAQ
Is Kirkland hard seltzer the same as White Claw?
No public source confirms that. White Claw is made by Mark Anthony Brewing, while Kirkland cartons have named other contract producers, including Patco Brands and MPL Brands NV. The two share the same 5% strength and about 100 calories per can.
Is Kirkland hard seltzer stronger than White Claw?
No. Both are 5% ABV in a 12 oz can. White Claw Surge, at 8%, is stronger than either.
How many calories are in a Kirkland hard seltzer?
About 100 calories per 12 oz can, with about 2 grams of carbs according to launch reports. Check the carton for the current figures.
Is Kirkland hard seltzer gluten free?
VinePair described the version it tested as gluten free. Because producers can change, check the carton you buy if you need to avoid gluten.
How many Kirkland seltzers equal one drink?
One 12 oz can at 5% is one US standard drink. The NIAAA defines binge drinking as a pattern that brings blood alcohol to 0.08%, usually about 5 drinks for men or 4 for women in about 2 hours. Never drink and drive.
Sources
- VinePair, Kirkland Signature hard seltzers tasting, 2 July 2025 (producers on carton, 5% ABV, 100 calories, flavors).
- Fox News, Costco Kirkland hard seltzer launch report, 25 September 2020 (5%, 100 calories, 2 g carbs, launch flavors, 24 can pack).
- Chowhound, Kirkland Signature Vodka + Soda, 31 March 2025 (4.5%, 100 calories, flavors, January 2025 launch).
- White Claw US support and retailer nutrition listings (Original 5%, 100 calories, 2 g carbs; Surge 8%, 160 calories).
- Food Network, White Claw 70 announcement, 7 May 2020 (3.7%, 70 calories, 0 g sugar).
- 27 CFR § 7.1, § 16.21 and § 25.15 (eCFR / Cornell LII).
- NIAAA, What Is a Standard Drink? and Drinking Levels Defined.