Best Bourbon for a Hot Toddy: 6 Bottles and an Easy Recipe

Updated November 2026

The best bourbon for a hot toddy is a sturdy, 90 to 101 proof bottle with a spicy, high rye profile, because hot water, lemon and honey dilute and soften the whiskey fast. Wild Turkey 101, Old Grand-Dad Bonded, Evan Williams Bottled-in-Bond, Buffalo Trace, Four Roses Small Batch and Woodford Reserve all hold their shape in a steaming mug. Use 1.5 to 2 oz of bourbon to about 4 oz of hot water.

A toddy is just spirit, sweetener, citrus and hot water, so a soft 80 proof whiskey tends to disappear once the water goes in. Here is how to choose a bottle, plus a balanced recipe.

Why proof matters in a hot toddy

A toddy is mostly water. A typical build of 1.5 oz bourbon in 4 oz of hot water plus honey and lemon leaves the finished drink at well under a third of the bourbon’s own strength. Heat also drives off aroma quickly, so the gentle vanilla notes of a lighter bourbon can fade before you finish the mug.

Bottles in the 90 to 101 proof range bring more flavor per ounce, so the oak, caramel and baking spice still read through the honey and lemon. Bourbon with a higher share of rye in the mash adds pepper and clove notes that suit the drink’s traditional spices. Skip cask strength; above about 110 proof the alcohol turns sharp when hot.

US law sets a floor here too. Under 27 CFR § 5.143, whisky must be bottled at not less than 40 percent alcohol by volume (80 proof), and bourbon must come from a mash of at least 51 percent corn, be distilled at 160 proof or less, and go into charred new oak containers at 125 proof or less. “Straight” bourbon adds a minimum of two years in those barrels. Every bottle below is a straight bourbon.

6 good bourbons for a hot toddy

These are listed by style, not ranked. Proofs were checked against state liquor board listings and brand pages; label strength can change, so check the bottle.

Wild Turkey 101 (101 proof)

The boldest pick here and a classic choice for warm drinks. Wild Turkey describes an aroma of “vanilla with cinnamon and oak,” a palate with “oak and baking spices in the middle,” and a finish of “bold, signature Wild Turkey spice and orange peel.” That orange peel note pairs naturally with a lemon wheel and cloves. Iowa’s Alcoholic Beverages Division lists it at 101 proof.

Old Grand-Dad Bonded (100 proof)

A high rye bourbon that tastes made for a toddy. The brand describes “aromas of cinnamon, citrus peel and toasted oak with hints of dried fruits,” a palate of “sweet vanilla, hints of dried fruits and rye-forward warmth,” and a “long lingering peppery finish.” North Carolina’s ABC Commission lists the bonded bottling at 100 proof.

Evan Williams Bottled-in-Bond (100 proof)

The “white label” Evan Williams is a dependable everyday mixing bourbon. The distillery describes it as robust and rich with “a potent punch” that stays easy on the palate. Pennsylvania’s Fine Wine and Good Spirits lists it at 100 proof. If you make toddies for a crowd, this is the bottle to batch with.

Buffalo Trace (90 proof)

A rounder, sweeter option for people who want the drink to taste more like honey and caramel than spice. The distillery describes “a complex aroma of vanilla, mint and molasses” and lists it at 90 proof (45 percent ABV). Go toward 2 oz of bourbon if you use a 90 proof bottle.

Four Roses Small Batch (90 proof)

Four Roses blends several of its own bourbon recipes for this bottling, which gives a balance of fruit and spice that sits well against lemon. Iowa ABD lists Four Roses Small Batch at 90 proof. Note that “small batch” has no legal definition under US labeling rules; it is a producer’s description, not a standard.

Woodford Reserve (90.4 proof)

A polished, slightly richer pick for a toddy you want to sip slowly. The label states 90.4 proof (Iowa ABD rounds it to 90 in its listing). Its oak and dried fruit character works well with a cinnamon stick in place of cloves.

What “bottled in bond” tells you

Two of the picks above say bottled in bond. Under 27 CFR § 5.88, a bonded spirit must be the product of one distilling season, made by one distiller at one distillery, aged at least four years in a government bonded warehouse, and bottled at exactly 100 proof, with the label identifying the distillery. For a toddy, that guarantee of 100 proof and four years of age is a useful shortcut when you are standing in front of an unfamiliar shelf.

Bourbon hot toddy recipe

This version leans on bourbon’s sweetness, so it uses a little less honey than most Scotch or Irish whiskey toddies.

  • 1.5 to 2 oz bourbon (use the larger pour for 90 proof bottles)
  • 0.5 oz fresh lemon juice
  • 0.5 oz honey syrup (2 parts honey to 1 part hot water)
  • 4 oz hot water, just off the boil
  • Garnish: lemon wheel studded with 3 cloves, or a cinnamon stick
  1. Fill your mug with hot water for a minute to warm it, then pour that water out.
  2. Add the honey syrup and lemon juice, then the bourbon.
  3. Top with the hot water and stir until the honey is fully mixed in.
  4. Add the clove studded lemon wheel or cinnamon stick, let it steep for a minute, and taste. Adjust with more honey or lemon.

Honey syrup blends far more easily than raw honey, which tends to sink and clump. Water just off the boil, rather than at a rolling boil, keeps the alcohol from smelling hot. For a richer winter drink, swap the water for warm apple cider and drop the honey to a quarter ounce.

Bourbon vs other whiskey in a toddy

Bourbon gives a sweeter, rounder toddy with vanilla and caramel, thanks to its corn heavy mash and new charred oak. Blended Scotch, the base in many traditional recipes, adds a drier, sometimes lightly smoky edge. Irish whiskey is lighter and fruitier. If you want to compare styles side by side, see our guide to the best whiskey for a hot toddy. For more bottle background, the bourbon guide covers the main styles and brands.

More warm and winter drinks

If you are stocking up for the season, the same bottles work in a bourbon eggnog and in our winter bourbon cocktails. For a rum based alternative, try this hot buttered rum recipe, and for party ideas see our Christmas cocktails. Shopping on a budget? Our list of the best cheap bourbon includes several toddy friendly bottles.

Many people reach for a toddy when they have a cold. Warm liquids can feel soothing, but alcohol does not treat a cold and can interact with cold medicines; read does whiskey help a sore throat before mixing one when you are sick.

Frequently asked questions

What proof bourbon is best for a hot toddy?

Bourbon between 90 and 101 proof works best. Hot water dilutes the drink heavily, so a stronger bourbon keeps its flavor, while very high proof bottles above about 110 can taste sharp when hot.

How much bourbon goes in a hot toddy?

Use 1.5 oz of a 100 proof bourbon or about 2 oz of a 90 proof bourbon with roughly 4 oz of hot water, 0.5 oz of lemon juice and 0.5 oz of honey syrup.

Is bourbon or Scotch better in a hot toddy?

Neither is wrong. Bourbon makes a sweeter toddy with vanilla and caramel; blended Scotch makes a drier one. Choose the whiskey you already enjoy drinking.

Can I use apple cider instead of water?

Yes. Warm apple cider makes a richer, fruitier toddy. Because cider is already sweet, cut the honey to about a quarter ounce and keep the lemon for balance.

Should the water be boiling?

Use water just off the boil. Boiling water makes the alcohol smell harsh and can scorch delicate aromas. Warming the mug first keeps the drink hot longer.

Does a hot toddy cure a cold?

No. A warm drink can feel comforting, but alcohol does not cure a cold and can interact with cold and flu medicines. Check with a pharmacist or doctor if you are taking medication.

Sources

  • 27 CFR § 5.143, whisky class and type designations (Cornell Legal Information Institute).
  • 27 CFR § 5.88, bottled in bond labeling requirements.
  • Wild Turkey, Wild Turkey 101 product page (proof and tasting notes); Iowa Alcoholic Beverages Division product listing (101 proof).
  • Beam Distilling, Old Grand-Dad Bottled in Bond (tasting notes, 100 proof); North Carolina ABC Commission item listing (100 proof).
  • Fine Wine and Good Spirits (Pennsylvania), Evan Williams Bottled-in-Bond listing (100 proof, producer description).
  • Buffalo Trace Distillery, Buffalo Trace Bourbon page (90 proof, tasting notes).
  • Iowa Alcoholic Beverages Division listings for Four Roses Small Batch (90 proof) and Woodford Reserve (90).

Leave a Comment