Deciding between Buffalo Trace vs Woodford Reserve can be challenging because both have unique flavor profiles. They also have a reputation for producing high-quality Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey.
But really, which one is best for you?
Our team did intensive research to find the key differences and compare the two spirits in this in-depth review, so read on.
Bourbon Face-Off: Woodford Reserve vs Buffalo Trace
Woodford Reserve and Buffalo Trace are two of the most famous and well-acclaimed Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey in the whiskey world. Also, their rich history, distillery, and profile sets the two great bourbons apart.
Woodford Reserve was released in 1996, while Buffalo Trace is a flagship bourbon released in 1999. While it doesn’t have an age statement, Woodford Reserve bourbon is younger than Buffalo Trace bourbon.
Moreso, they do not have the same mash bill ratio because Woodford Reserve uses 18% rye while Buffalo Trace contains less than 10% rye. The high rye content on Woodford Reserve makes it spicier and bolder than Buffalo Trace.
Their Differences
History & Origin
Woodford Reserve Distillery started as the Old Oscar Pepper Distillery in 1812. It was then operated as Labrot & Graham Distillery before Brown-Forman purchased the brand in 1993 and named it Woodford Reserve Distillery.
Buffalo Trace, on the other hand, is a tribute to the ancient buffalo that carved its pathways in the Kentucky River.
Even in the whiskey Prohibition Era [1], Buffalo Trace Distillery managed to survive and remain in operation to produce bottled whiskey for medicinal purposes.
Production & Distillation Process
Buffalo Trace bourbon produces Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey using a large column still and modern techniques.
On the contrary, Woodford Reserve uses three large copper stills and the traditional way of producing Kentucky bourbons.
Column distillation helps control the purity and strength of the bourbon, which makes a huge difference in the spirit before maturation in the barrel.
The art of making fine bourbon happens in different distilleries, from grains to bottles.
Maturation
Buffalo Trace is aged in charred oak barrels for eight years, while Woodford Reserve bourbon is matured for six to seven years.
Buffalo Trace has a unique aging process wherein the barrels are stored on the middle floors of its warehouse for great temperature fluctuations.
Maturation in a charred wood barrel gives a perfectly balanced taste and pleasantly sweet aromatics to the Kentucky bourbons.
Fun Fact: Both brands do not bear an age statement, but since they are labeled as Kentucky straight bourbon, they must be matured in charred oak barrels for a minimum of two years [2].
Mash Bill
In the Buffalo Trace vs Woodford Reserve battle of bourbons, the mash bill contents contribute to the bourbon profile, but unfortunately, only the latter disclosed their recipe.
Woodford Reserve bourbon uses 72% corn, 18% rye, and 10% malted barley, and its rye content makes it spicy.
The exact proportion of Buffalo Trace is close to the vest of Master Distiller Harlen Wheatley.
It was not revealed, but two things are for sure: (1) it has at least 51% corn, and (2) it uses rye on its mash bill because of its spicy notes when we tried a bottle.
But which bourbon is comparable to Woodford Reserve?
Tasting Notes: Buffalo Trace vs Woodford Reserve
Buffalo Trace
- Palate: Pleasantly sweet, espresso, chocolate, spicy, vanilla, wood, floral notes, toffee, anise, and dried fruit
- Nose: Complex aroma, sweet vanilla, molasses, caramel, and mint
- Color: Deep Amber
- Finish: Long, smooth and serious depth of flavors
Woodford Reserve
- Palate: Rounded and smooth, complex citrus, mint, rye spice, chocolate, toffee, sweet caramel, vanilla, and cinnamon
- Nose: Dried Fruit, mint, orange, cocoa, vanilla, tobacco, and rye spice
- Color: Brilliant Honey Amber
- Finish: Long and silky smooth
Alcohol Content & Price Point
| Bourbon Brand | Alcohol Content | Average Price |
| Buffalo Trace | 45% | $34.99 |
| Woodford Reserve | 45.2% | $39.99 |
*Average prices are based on Drizly online. Prices may vary in local liquor shops.
Ownership & Distillery
In Buffalo Trace vs Woodford Reserve, each barrel is produced by well-known distillers and multi-brand companies.
Buffalo Trace bourbon is owned by Sazerac Company, a large alcoholic beverage company with over 450 brands.
Woodford is owned by Brown-Forman, the same company that owns Jack Daniel’s Tennesse Whiskey.
Buffalo Trace Distillery produces the flagship bourbon and other spirits like Eagle Rare and George T. Stagg.
On the other hand, Woodford Reserve is a National Historic Landmark producing fine bourbon since 1812.
How To Drink It
Buffalo Trace has a complex aroma and taste, and it is best to drink straight or with a splash of water than as a cocktail. But is Buffalo Trace wheated bourbon?
However, Woodford Reserve is a versatile spirit, so you can drink it neat, on the rocks, or as a cocktail.
Since it is more tasty and rich in spice, it has a bold grain that will not easily fade on the nose and palate when consumed as cocktails. Check out Woodford Reserve vs Maker’s Mark here.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Is Buffalo Trace smoother than Woodford Reserve?
The perception of smoothness in whiskey is subjective and can vary depending on individual taste preferences and sensory perceptions. Buffalo Trace and Woodford Reserve are both highly regarded bourbon brands, each with its own distinct flavor profile and characteristics. Buffalo Trace is known for its balanced and approachable flavor, with notes of caramel, vanilla, and oak, while Woodford Reserve offers a richer and more complex palate, with layers of caramel, spice, and fruit. Some drinkers may find Buffalo Trace to be smoother due to its softer and more delicate flavor profile, while others may prefer the depth and complexity of Woodford Reserve.
Which is better for Old Fashioned, Woodford Reserve, or Buffalo Trace?
Both Woodford Reserve and Buffalo Trace can be excellent choices for an Old Fashioned cocktail, and the decision ultimately comes down to personal preference and the desired flavor profile of the drink. Woodford Reserve’s rich and complex flavor profile, with notes of caramel, spice, and fruit, can add depth and sophistication to an Old Fashioned, while Buffalo Trace’s balanced and approachable character, with hints of caramel, vanilla, and oak, provides a solid foundation for the cocktail. Experimenting with both bourbons in an Old Fashioned cocktail can help determine which one best suits your taste preferences and enhances your drinking experience.
Is Buffalo Trace’s flavor more complex than Woodford Reserve?
Buffalo Trace and Woodford Reserve each offer their own unique flavor profiles, and the perception of complexity can vary depending on individual taste preferences and sensory perceptions.
Buffalo Trace is known for its balanced and approachable flavor, with notes of caramel, vanilla, and oak, while Woodford Reserve offers a richer and more complex palate, with layers of caramel, spice, and fruit. Some drinkers may find Buffalo Trace to be more straightforward and easy-drinking, while others may appreciate the depth and nuance of Woodford Reserve’s flavor profile.
Ultimately, the complexity of flavor is subjective, and both bourbons offer their own distinct characteristics and qualities.
Which Bourbon is more suitable for mixing cocktails: Buffalo Trace or Woodford Reserve?
Both Buffalo Trace and Woodford Reserve are versatile bourbons that can be used in a variety of cocktails, including classics like the Old Fashioned, Manhattan, and Whiskey Sour.
However, Buffalo Trace is often favored for mixing cocktails due to its balanced flavor profile and approachable character. With notes of caramel, vanilla, and oak, Buffalo Trace provides a solid foundation for cocktails, adding depth and complexity without overpowering other ingredients.
Woodford Reserve, on the other hand, offers a richer and more complex flavor profile with layers of caramel, spice, and fruit.
While Woodford Reserve can certainly elevate cocktails with its depth of flavor, some drinkers may prefer to enjoy it neat or on the rocks to fully appreciate its nuances.
Ultimately, the choice between Buffalo Trace and Woodford Reserve for mixing cocktails depends on personal preference and the desired flavor profile of the drink.
Are there any notable price differences between Buffalo Trace and Woodford Reserve?
Generally, Buffalo Trace is priced slightly lower than Woodford Reserve, making it a popular choice for those seeking quality bourbon at a more affordable price point.
What flavor profiles can I expect from Buffalo Trace and Woodford Reserve?
Buffalo Trace often features sweeter flavors like caramel, toffee, and butterscotch, whereas Woodford Reserve boasts more robust flavors such as oak, spice, and dark fruit notes.
Which Bourbon is preferred for sipping neat: Buffalo Trace or Woodford Reserve?
Preference for sipping neat varies among individuals. Some may enjoy Buffalo Trace’s smoothness and sweetness, while others may appreciate Woodford Reserve’s depth and complexity without dilution from mixers.
Do Buffalo Trace and Woodford Reserve offer limited edition releases or special bottlings?
Both distilleries occasionally release limited edition or special bottlings, which may offer unique flavor profiles or higher proof variations. These releases can be highly sought after by enthusiasts.
And The Winner Is…
Woodford Reserve is clearly the winner in Buffalo Trace vs. Woodford Reserve battle. While it is not as cheap as Buffalo Trace, its fruity and tasty palate profile and nose are complex, more versatile, and interesting than Buffalo Trace.
Truly, nothing beats the traditional way of producing bourbons.
If you are into bold and interesting whiskey notes, Woodford gets the upper hand. However, if you want sweeter (but not as sweet as Maker’s Mark), go with Buffalo Trace.
Both are great bourbon whiskeys, but a bottle of the best Woodford Reserve bourbon is worth trying.
References:
