Liquor Laboratory

Buffalo Trace Old Fashioned Classic Recipe (2024 Updated)

buffalo trace old fashion cocktail recipe guide

Last Updated on February 26, 2024 by Lydia Martin

Old Fashioned is a simple cocktail recipe that you can easily whip up in less than five minutes. And many will agree that Buffalo Trace is the best bourbon for the cocktail. 

Check out this Buffalo Trace Old-Fashioned recipe we have for you today. 

The Best Buffalo Trace Old Fashioned Recipe   

The Best Buffalo Trace Old Fashioned Recipe

Prep Time: 4 minutes

Total Time: 4 minutes


Instructions: In a mixing glass, muddle the sugar with Angostura bitters. Stir it well until dissolved, then add ice and Buffalo Trace bourbon. 

Mix it well until chilled, then strain in a rocks glass with fresh ice. Lastly, twist the orange peel over the drink, then drop it into the rocks’ glass as a garnish. 

Serving: 1

Is Buffalo Trace Good For Old-Fashioned? 

Absolutely yes, Buffalo Trace is good for the Old-Fashioned cocktail. Buffalo Trace bourbon has a unique combination of mint, vanilla, toffee, dark fruit, anise, and molasses that complement the sugar and angostura bitters well. 

Buffalo Trace is a rich bourbon with enough alcohol content that does not overpower different mixers. Moreso, the spiciness of the bourbon stands out in cocktails and will not disappear easily. 

Read: Buffalo Trace Bourbon Cream Recipes

How Buffalo Trace Tastes In Old-Fashioned 

How Buffalo Trace Tastes In Old Fashioned 

Buffalo Trace tastes smooth and great in an Old-Fashioned cocktail. As we tasted our Buffalo Trace Old-Fashioned, the mixers helped enhance the complex taste of molasses, mint, and vanilla in the bourbon

The caramel taste of the bourbon is replaced with different spices like oak, dark fruit, and toffee. Also, the bourbon has a long and smooth finish with serious depth that does not fade quickly. But what does Old-Fashioned taste like in general?

Buffalo Trace Old-Fashioned’s Alcohol Content 

The estimated alcohol content of mixed drinks like Old-Fashioned can be computed using the formula (Alcohol Content x Liquor Volume / Total Drink Volume) x 100 [1].

The alcohol content of Buffalo Trace bourbon is 45%, while the Angostura bitters contain 44.7%. 

Here’s the computation of Buffalo Trace Old-Fashioned Alcohol Content:

  • Alcohol Content x Liquor Volume = (0.45 abv x 2 oz) + (0.447 abv x 0.042 oz) = 0.92 
  • Total Volume = 2 oz (Buffalo Trace) + 0.5 oz (melted ice) + 0.042 (Angostura bitters) = 2.542 oz
  • Estimated Alcohol Content = (0.92 / 2.542) x 100 = 36%

Therefore, one Buffalo Trace Old-Fashioned serving has 36% alcohol content. 

Can This Cocktail Get You Drunk?

Can This Cocktail Get You Drunk?

Yes, Buffalo Trace Old-Fashioned can get you drunk. Based on our computation above, each serving contains roughly 36% ABV, so it is a strong drink.

In addition, since it tastes great, the consumption can be higher than a straight pour of whiskey, which may get you drunk faster. 

In general, two or three Buffalo Trace Old-Fashioned servings in an hour can surely make you drunk. However, other factors such as your gender, weight, and lifestyle may affect your alcohol capacity. But is Buffalo Trace wheated bourbon?


How much is a glass of Buffalo Trace Old-Fashioned cocktail?

A glass of Buffalo Trace Old-Fashioned cocktail is roughly $10. It can be expensive when you order it in a bar because most bars aim for an 80% margin on liquor sales and 20% pour costs.

How do you order a Buffalo Trace Old-Fashioned cocktail? 

To order a Buffalo Trace Old-Fashioned cocktail, simply tell the bartender that you want a Buffalo Trace Old-Fashioned. But why is Buffalo Trace bourbon difficult to find

What is a Buffalo Trace Old Fashioned?

A Buffalo Trace Old Fashioned is a classic cocktail made with Buffalo Trace Bourbon as the base spirit, sugar, Angostura bitters, and a twist of orange zest. It’s a timeless drink with a rich history.

How do I make a Buffalo Trace Old Fashioned at home?

To make a Buffalo Trace Old Fashioned, start by muddling a sugar cube with a few dashes of Angostura bitters in a glass. Add a splash of water and continue to muddle until the sugar is dissolved. Then, fill the glass with ice cubes and pour in 2 ounces of Buffalo Trace Bourbon. Stir gently to combine, and garnish with an orange twist.

Can I use any bourbon for a Buffalo Trace Old Fashioned?

While you can technically use any bourbon for an Old Fashioned, Buffalo Trace Bourbon is preferred for its smoothness and rich flavor profile. However, feel free to experiment with different bourbons to find your preferred taste.

What type of glassware should I use for serving a Buffalo Trace Old Fashioned?

Traditionally, an Old Fashioned cocktail is served in a short, heavy-bottomed glass called an Old Fashioned glass or rocks glass. This allows you to fully enjoy the aroma and flavors of the drink.

Are there any variations of the Buffalo Trace Old Fashioned?

Yes, there are many variations of the Buffalo Trace Old Fashioned. Some common variations include using different types of bitters, such as orange or Peychaud’s bitters, or swapping out the sugar cube for simple syrup. You can also experiment with different garnishes, like a cherry or a lemon twist.

Can I make a large batch of Buffalo Trace Old Fashioned for a party?

Yes, you can definitely scale up the recipe to make a batch of Buffalo Trace Old Fashioneds for a party. Simply multiply the ingredients by the number of servings you need and mix them together in a pitcher or large bowl. Serve over ice and garnish individual glasses with orange twists.

Where can I find Buffalo Trace Bourbon?

Buffalo Trace Bourbon is widely available at liquor stores and online retailers. It’s a popular bourbon with a strong following, so you shouldn’t have trouble finding it at most well-stocked liquor stores.

In Conclusion 

Buffalo Trace Old-Fashioned is an enduring classic, and whether you are at home or an elaborate cocktail bar, it is easy and delicious to make. You can never go wrong with Buffalo Trace bourbon for Old-Fashioned because it can make your cocktail smoother and tastier. 

There is beauty in simplicity, so even amid the American whiskey cocktail boom, it is no surprise that Buffalo Trace Old-Fashioned remains one of our era’s favorite mixed drinks. 


Lumint ad Side Bar
Flex Ad Side Bar