Last Updated on August 22, 2023 by Lydia Martin
Bourbon is a type of American whiskey made primarily from corn and aged in charred oak barrels.
There are many different brands and styles of bourbon, and some are considered to be more collectible than others.
So what are the best bourbons to collect? Let’s find out.
Top 15 Bourbons Every Collector Must Score
15. Michter’s 10-Year Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon
Average Price: approx. $342.99/750ml (Caskers)
Alcohol Content: 46.4% ABV
Why We Like It: Michter’s 10-year bourbon is a versatile spirit that experts and beginners can enjoy.
If you’ve tried Michter’s 20-Year, you shouldn’t miss this one. It must be a staple in your mini bar at home; however, it’s very hard to find this bottle today.
14. E.H. Taylor, Jr. Warehouse C Tornado Surviving
Average Price: approx. $9,998.99 /750ml (Caskers)
Alcohol Content: 50% ABV
Why We Like It: This incomparable expression has been rated an exceptional performer, justifying its hefty price.
If you’re tempted to spend a lot of money on Warehouse C, we suggest getting your hands on Tornado Surviving, which is more worth it.
13. Barrell Bourbon Batch 27
Average Price: approx. $91.99/750ml (Caskers)
Alcohol Content: 57.9% ABV
Why We Like It: This limited-edition bottle is made from a blend of Kentucky, Tennessee, and Indiana bourbons aged 5 to 15 years.
The notes prevalent in this whiskey include cherry and oak, making it a great and cool bottle to own.
12. Elijah Craig 23-Year Single Barrel
Average Price: Approx. $222.99/750ml (Caskers)
Alcohol Content: 45% ABV
Why We Like It: Elijah Craig 23-Year single barrel doesn’t over-oak. Its robust tannins support a variety of flavors, such as orange peel, vanilla, and cinnamon.
As one of Elijah’s high-grade rye barrels from their best facility, this expression reached its full aging potential while maintaining its taste and smooth finish.
11. Hirsch The Horizon Straight Bourbon
Average Price: approx. $39.99/750ml (Total Wine)
Alcohol Content: 46% ABV
Why We Like It: This new expression from Hirsch is transparent and should appeal to whiskey lovers.
Made with MGP’s juice from Indiana, expect flavors and notes unusual for a Kentucky Bourbon. If you love more earthy notes and good spice, this is for you.
10. Evan Williams 23-Year Straight
Average Price: approx. $16.49/1.75L (Total Wine)
Alcohol Content: 53.5% ABV
Why We Like It: This Evan Williams 23 is an incredibly versatile whiskey you can enjoy in almost any way possible.
Aside from collecting, this bottle is a better choice if you’re planning on drinking it. You’ll like its chocolate, cherry nose, and nuanced flavor profile.
9. Bardstown Bourbon Collaborative Series
Average Price: approx. $42.49/750ml (Total Wine)
Alcohol Content: 50%-59.2% ABV
Why We Like It: Bardstown collaborative series used barrels from different sources, including The Prisoner winery in California and Armagnac from France.
“The robust profile is a direct result of the care and coordination in shipping these flavorful barrels. The day they are emptied in Grand Rapids, they are filled with bourbon in Bardstown. The rich waves of chocolate malt from KBS carry through the entire aging process and balance beautifully with classic bourbon.”— Dan Callaway, Product Development VP/ Master Blender.
There’s a delicate blend of floral bouquets complemented by chantilly cream, grilled peach, and pecan, and it creates a distinct and complex finish that’s perfect for any occasion.
8. Four Roses Single Barrel
Average Price: approx. $45.99/750ml (Total Wine)
Alcohol Content: 50% ABV
Why We Like It: You shouldn’t miss this limited-edition expression, as it’s one of Four Roses’ best bottles in their 2020 lineup.
If you love their small-batch spirits, expect better overall flavor here. It’s more complex, with notes of vanilla and maple, and the palate is full of sweet and savory flavors.
7. Willett Single Barrel Family Estate 4 Year Old
Average Price: approx. $70/750ml (Caskers)
Alcohol Content: 55% ABV
Why We Like It: This Willett 4-year-old single barrel features a very pungent aroma, full of sweet and candy corn flavors on the palate with some heat on its finish.
With its high proof, expect a strong cinnamon flavor, with some gingerbread cookies coming in.
6. Blue Note 9-Year-Old Premium Small Batch
Average Price: approx. $48.99/750ml (Total Wine)
Alcohol Content: 46.5%
Why We Like It: This unpopular Blue Note 9-year-old is a premium Tennessee-style whiskey. It has a strong maple syrupy flavor with candied orange notes.
If you want to collect one bottle or haven’t tried any expression from this brand, this spirit is a good way to start.
5. Woodinville Straight Bourbon Port Cask Finish
Average Price: approx. $51.99/750ml (Total Wine)
Alcohol Content: 45% ABV
Why We Like It: This dark and sweet bourbon has a lot of character and complexity, and we love how it performs to any drink.
The fig and date notes usually prevalent in Scotch whiskey are present in this drink. Also, the lingering finish adds some chocolate to this mix.
4. Buffalo Trace Antique Collection
Average Price: approx. $23.99/750ml (Total Wine)
Alcohol Content: 40%-63.8% ABV
Why We Like It: All spirits in this collection could have been chosen as the best.
The Buffalo Trace Antique Collection  is an excellent investment piece, as the stunning ryes from Buffalo Trace’s renowned brands, such as George T. Stagg, Eagle Rare, and Weller, are present here–ideal presents for any special occasion.
3. Booker’s 10-Year-Old 25th Anniversary Edition
Average Price: approx. $93/750ml (Total Wine)
Alcohol Content: 65% ABV
Why We Like It: This Booker’s anniversary edition bottle is particularly meaningful as it’s the last example of the brand’s unconditioned and cask-proof whiskey.
Fred Noe Jr. dedicated this bottle to honor his father, and it’s available in only 1,000 cases.
2. Wild Turkey Rare Breed
Average Price: approx. $56.99/750ml (Total Wine)
Alcohol Content: 58.4% ABV
This is a great blend of flavors and aromas and embodies bourbon’s real essence.
1. Blanton’s Straight From The Barrel
Average Price: approx. $249/750ml (Caskers)
Alcohol Content: 64.6% ABV
Why We Like It: Our top collector’s bourbon expression is this Blanton’s SFTB. The unique thing about this bottle is that it has eight different tops, each with its own letter, spelling out “B-L-A-N-T-O-N-S.”
If you want a higher-proof spirit, this limited-edition is bottled at over 120-proof, featuring notes of oak and spice, with a beautiful butterscotch finish.
What bourbons appreciate in value?
Bourbons that appreciate in value are old and rare ones. Older bourbon expressions are more valuable compared to younger expressions.
Also, rare bourbons or limited-edition bottles worth more than widely available ones.
Can you make money collecting bourbon?
Yes. Collecting bourbon can make money, making it a source of passive income.
Selling them in the future gives ROI, and limited-release bottles may cost more in the years to come.
If you’re an existing bourbon collector or want to start gathering exceptional bottles, all these expressions are a great addition to your liquor cabinet.
From Michter’s 10-Year to Four Rose Singe Barrel to Blanton’s SFTB, these bourbon expressions are perfect for collecting and drinking.